You are here:  Home  >  Most Recent Blogs  >  Current Article

National’s TPPA is not OK. We voted for change!

By   /  November 6, 2017  /  3 Comments

TDB recommends Voyager - Unlimited internet @home as fast as you can get

This is the time for action. It is time to hold the new government to account through every avenue you have available.

    Print       Email

On 8 November David Parker will sit down with fellow trade ministers from the TPPA-11 countries in Da Nang, Vietnam, and decide what to do with the deal. The officials have just finished three days of intense technical discussions in Tokyo.

There is now a 50/50 chance they will agree to proceed with the deal without the US and on what terms.

At most, some of the most objectionable parts of the existing agreement will be suspended (or ‘frozen’) pending re-entry by the US. Nothing is to be rewritten, except the rules for entry into force (which previously required the US’s participation).

All its toxic elements remain, to come into effect if the US decides to re-engage.

In other words, our new government may decide in the next few days to adopt an agreement that all three parties said should not be ratified when National tabled it in the House.

What parts of the TPPA might be ‘frozen’? In Japan, the officials considered around 50 items tabled by each country. Because of the ongoing shroud of secrecy, we don’t know what was on New Zealand’s list – and the TPPA’s secrecy pact means we won’t know for at least another four years unless the government decides to tell us!

We know the eleven countries have agreed to ‘freeze’ about one third of the 50 items.  A lot of these are on intellectual property (but not extending copyright for another 20 years, giving Hollywood, Sony etc the benefits without any cost to the US). Some other requests have been dropped.

The officials will try to agree on the remaining half when they reconvene in Da Nang tomorrow, then pass the remaining decisions to the trade ministers and if necessary the leaders. They won’t have a lot of time, because they will be meeting on the margins of the larger APEC meeting which they also have to attend. Hence, the 50/50 risk of an outcome.  

Crucial remaining issues on the list for ‘freezing’ include investor-state dispute settlement (ISDS), the ban on countries requiring personal or corporate data to be held locally (see my previous blog on the e-commerce text), and the rule that prevents state-owned enterprises from giving preference to local firms when they buy and sell products and services.   

But other important items are not on the agenda. These include the special rules that protect foreign investors (a separate issue from ISDS); the annex that allows big Pharma to have greater influence over Pharmac’s decisions; the requirement to adopt international conventions on intellectual property (such as the UPOV 1991 convention on plant varieties that the Wai 262 Waitangi Tribunal report said was inconsistent with the Treaty); the government’s right to prefer buying Kiwi-made; requiring foreign firms like Amazon to have an actual presence inside New Zealand to subject them more effectively to our consumer protection and tax laws; insisting that foreign buyers of resources like forests process the logs locally to promote work, regional development and ease the shortage of products; and many more.

This is the time for action. It is time to hold the new government to account through every avenue you have available.

Remind Labour it said there was no valid economic rationale, even when the US was involved, and a potential for job losses. And that it called for a health impact assessment –repeated to the new government by Doctors for Healthy Trade this week.

Remind New Zealand First it denounced the special rights for foreign investors who could enforce them against the government for massive damages in dubious offshore tribunals. There’s no point in saying we won’t have it in future agreements if it’s in the TPPA.

Remind the Greens they said the TPPA belongs to a failed neoliberal model, when the country and the world need genuine sustainability and the capacity to address climate change.

Above all, remind them they voted for real change.

Want to support this work? Donate today
Follow us on Twitter & Facebook
    Print       Email


  1. CLEANGREEN says:

    We dont want TPPA as iot is a corporate control plan to enslave us all and take everythjing from us.

    Jacinda dont sign TPPA and tal,k to our best expert on TPPA professor Jane Kelsey please and dont sign that toxic so callled ‘trade deal’ as it is not a trade deal but a foriegn control of our country and Government.

  2. Black Lemming says:

    Putting a freeze on ISDS until the US comes back doesn’t do much .

    Once Trump is deposed , support from paid off Democrats and Republicans will swiftly reinstate TPP -12 with life long corporate dominance by way of ISDS.

    NZF and the Greens must push Labour all the way to remove ISDS from all NZ FTAs and both Jacinda and David Parker need to achieve way more than a temporary freeze .

    This is Jacinda’s first big test .A new progressive NZ Govt will achieve nothing if corporations are allowed to have the tools to prevent or undo all the changes .

    ISDS has to be carved out and stay out .This really matters .

  3. Marc says:

    We are really none the wiser the the TPPA and what it may mean for most people, as the NZ media does not report and inform much on this topic.

    The same applies to other matters such as this:


    So nothing has changed, it seems it does not matter all that much who is in government, Nats or Labour, as the MSM here continues with the same kind of reporting, underreporting, misreporting, and feeding infotainment and endless advertising for consumerists.

    I have to go to overseas media to read about what really goes on.

    FFS, what a distressing state of affairs, no wonder we have so many narcissists, consumerist idiots and zombies walk and drive around every day. Put crap into their brains, and you get crap that goes on in most brains.

You might also like...

Foundation sets up givealittle page for Afghan villagers – Human Rights Foundation of NZ

Read More →