Government ‘Asleep At The Wheel’ Over Road Safety – The Dog and Lemon Guide


The New Zealand government has utterly failed to take effective action to lower the road toll, says the car review website,

Editor Clive Matthew-Wilson was commenting after seven people were killed in Sunday’s tragic collision between a truck and a minivan.

“Many New Zealand roads are like a staircase without a handrail: you make a mistake, you’re going to get hurt.”

“Worse, this is the second fatal head-on collision on the same road in recent years.”

“The simple fact is: median barriers would have prevented both collisions, yet our incredibly slack government can’t seem to even build a fence down the middle of the road.”

“Studies show that we could actually reduce the road toll by 90% by doing nothing more than putting in roundabouts, median barriers and roadside fencing.”

Swedish traffic safety expert Lars Ekman has said that median barriers were a key factor in Sweden’s low road toll.

In Sweden, median barriers are installed on 76% of roads with a speed limit above 80kmh.

TDB Recommends

Matthew-Wilson adds that, while median barriers are expensive, they are actually cheap compared to the cost of building grand highways.

Ekman estimates that: “For 10% of the cost of a motorway you could make safe a stretch of road ten times as long.”

Matthew-Wilson says the current government often seems to be more interested in punishing motorists than in saving lives.

“Despite promising to roll out 198km of median barriers by mid-2021, between December 2018 and December 2020, the government installed just 37km of median barriers on state highways. As of July 2021, a further 12km of median barriers were installed on existing state highways.” (although this figure does not include median barriers fitted on new state highways under construction, nor median barriers installed on local roads.)

“Rather than hang their heads in shame and fast-tracking the installation of median barriers throughout our highway network, the government is instead now proposing to simply lower the speed limit on most of our roads. There is no evidence whatsoever that a lowered speed limit would have prevented Sunday’s tragedy. But a median barrier would have.”

Matthew-Wilson gave the example of the Kāpiti expressway, between Mackays and Peka Peka, north of Wellington. There have been no fatal accidents on this road, compared with seven in the previous two years before the median barrier was installed.

“The drivers who use the Kāpiti expressway aren’t behaving any better than they were before the expressway was opened. It’s just that the road has been altered in a way that stops mistakes turning into tragedy.”

Matthew-Wilson also slammed the government’s “reckless disregard” for the lifesaving benefits of Daytime Running Lights.

“The government has known for 20 years that Daytime Running lights can lower the daytime road toll by 25%. Yet the government has repeatedly ignored this cheap and simple lifesaving technology.”

“In 2010, the Log Transport Safety Council recommended DRLs as a way of preventing head-on collisions between trucks and ordinary vehicles. Again, the government simply ignored this advice.”

Matthew-Wilson adds:

“The government spent $51 million just on planning a cycleway over the Auckland harbour bridge. That amount of money would have paid for a cycle shuttle service over the bridge for the next ten years, with enough money left over to subsidise Daytime Running Lights for the majority of vehicles in this country.”


  1. Or- maybe the government should focus on encouraging people not to drive tired, as obviously caused this latest accident, rather than cracking down further and further on anyone with a single molecule of ethanol in their system?

  2. You can’t blame the government for the bad, rude and impatient driving on our roads I see it daily in my one hour drive on the Wellington motorway. We need to make defensive driving part of our driver licenses and we need to do a lot of driver education and awareness training. Many Nzers don’t even bother to stop when your on a pedestrian and they don’t merge like a zip and people using mobile phones need to get instant fines.

    • not saying it means anything but I used to resent wearing a seatbelt in the front passenger seat in the UK, I saw the state of NZ driving and am more than happy to wear one in the back seat now…just an observation.

  3. Will the new inquiry into Gib board show the National party created the monopoly Fletchers have and I remember John Key bragging about monopolies. And now we have Act and National wanting to quickly replace Gib board with something else. We need to be careful last time the National party dropped the building standards around building materials we had leaky homes. National have a bad track record for building anything just look at there last attempt in a PPP the budget blew out due to the tendering process loopholes and the Christchurch earthquake mess. Who can you trust?


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.