The decision to move to an immediate Level 3 lockdown over Auckland and Level 2 over the rest of the country for 3 days with the 3 Covid cases found in the Community was the right move.
We didn’t know the strain, but the limited contact the positive cases had suggested something far more contagious and that could be the UK or SA strains, so caution was wise, especially as it has turned out to be the UK strain.
However, nerves are frayed, people have barely recovered from 2020 and are emotionally stressed out, frustrations at the Auckland border this time were apparently far more vocal and angry.
The Political Opposition has channeled that frustration and have been far more critical of the Government this time so there are numerous political threats to Labour over the decision to go into Level 3.
Vaccine roll out: Criticism that we hadn’t received the vaccine for frontline staff earlier has evaporated with the first 30 000 doses touching down in Auckland 9.30am yesterday but the far greater challenge of rolling out the vaccination to everyone with the infrastructure for annual shots required alongside any new vaccine for new strains comes with a billion problems of its own. Getting that right matters.
Business: Hospitality has barely gotten up off the floor and they take a blow like this. Expect the Business Community to be very vocal over the instability these events cause and louder still for compensation. If Grant can feed the later he won’t have to listen so much to the former.
Double Standards: The sense that the Government allowed the Big Gay Out to occur because that’s their electorate could become a source of contention that can be fanned into something ugly.
National & ACT criticism of MIQ: National and ACT have lashed criticism on the latest Community cases and sheeted the blame directly back at the Government holding up report after report that have been damning of MIQ safety practices.
Qanon lunatics: NZ Qanon lunatics comparing Jacinda to Hitler protesting outside her electorate office in the middle of a Level 3 Covid lockdown is a reminder that sometimes evolution doesn’t work. These lunatics are out online spreading disinformation and playing up all the usual claims of Jacinda’s Socialist Secret Police marching us all into forced vaccinations camps. It would be funny if these clowns didn’t believe it with all the fervour of religious zealots. The SIS should be looking into these people urgently.
A larger crisis: Ultimately the biggest political danger to Labour is if this is the beginning of a far larger cluster that will see the country locked down for longer, especially if incompetence is proven as the reason. Kiwis are a fickle herd at the best of times and can turn like sheep in a paddock if they feel their self sacrifice has been mistreated by incompetence, the gratitude vote of 2020 will quickly swing the other way if a Level 4 lockdown is imposed because of a fuck up at MIQ that the Government had already been warned about.
So what will save the Government from these political threats?
The actual strain isn’t on our books so the virus has managed to get here via some method we can’t spot yet, which gives the Government breathing space in terms of MIQ blame, but the trust Jacinda has built with middle NZ runs incredibly deep and as frustrating as these shut downs get, we are all interconnected online and can see the devastating impact Covid is happening elsewhere.
We are living in the shadow of a global mountain of Covid dead and that reality melts most criticism.
As long as Jacinda is the best chance of keeping that horror from our shores, New Zealanders will forgive many mistakes along the way.
Increasingly having independent opinion in a mainstream media environment which mostly echo one another has become more important than ever, so if you value having an independent voice – please donate here.
If you can’t contribute but want to help, please always feel free to share our blogs on social media
Honesty is starting to fray too.
At the 1.00pm Sunday briefing, it was identified by the PM and Bloomfield that the woman infected worked in a role at Sky Chefs that was virtually frontline, doing laundry for the airlines vis a vis whatever had been in direct physical contact with our Covid imports. And because of that she had last had a Covid test in 18 Jan 21.
Clearly a journalist thought that a very long gap between tests and questioned Bloomfield who was quick to point out they had regime of fortnightly tests and that the patient went on leave on 05 February. I’m guessing he prayed journalists couldn’t do math and he was right.
No test on Feb 1 or the 2nd at the latest, why? That precise question was not asked and therefore no requirement to explain.
I assume these basic questions were asked by Bloomfield et al before the briefing given the situation was unfolding the previous day.
But as it turns out, no mandatory restring regime was in place at Sky Chefs. They were voluntary. Hence no test after almost 3 weeks.
And no one asked but airline staff do not go into quarantine. They are up to their eyeballs with infected passengers. If this thing slipped past the border then it’s no wonder. And i assume this state of affairs exists to satisfy the airlines bottom line.
This should not be a game of cat and mouse with the PM or the Director of Health but its sure as daylight looking that way.
Ommissions are just as dishonest as lies.
Dearest PM. Do NOT lose our trust being clever!
Yep. Bloomfield is a man clearly under pressure. And who wouldn’t be in his position. I’d say he was one of the better senior public servants however – sometimes failed by one or two over-ambitious underlings in his own empire, and a number of others in associated fiefdoms dealing with the pandemic. And there are quite a few – the very innovative, and business-oriented Ministry for Everything for starters. I’ll never vote for Labour again until they realise where the roadblocks and uber-operative bullshit artists are, and start to pull apart that bugger’s muddle. They won’t, of course – it’s too convenient at the moment for various Munsters of Her Madge’s Gummint, and worse still – it might mean they have to have a go at that useless tit running the SSC (oops …. PSC) who’s no doubt spending more time contemplating retirement and the New Year’s or Queen’s Birthday Honours list (possibly both).
“We are living in the shadow of a global mountain of Covid dead and that reality melts most criticism.
As long as Jacinda is the best chance of keeping that horror from our shores, New Zealanders will forgive many mistakes along the way.”
And nobody can deny JA has done incredibly well with any sort of credibility. Most of the rest of the Whurl is incredibly envious.
But there’s another thing that’ll figure come next election, and one Labour’s political rivals will play on (with good reason).
And that’s to do with Labour as a One Trick Pony. Managing COVID19 cannot be the excuse for not making any meaningful progress on housing; health; education; exploitation in all its forms; child poverdy; corrections and all areas of gummint where there’s inherent racism; growing inequality ……..
The clock’s ticking and the old ways of incrementalism and PR and spin merchants doing their best to convince the electorate that Rome wasn’t built in a day simply aren’t going to cut it. And a lot of that is coming from within the senior and upper muddle ranks of the PS, within Labour’s own ranks and all their hangers-on. The natives are getting restless and becoming more savvy to identifying bullshit and incompetence – sometimes with conspiratorial results
I saw on Facebook ex Labour MP Sue Moroney saying that circumstances have changed and it is time for the PM to institute a Capital Gains Tax on property, and build state houses in great numbers. I have seen dozens of Labour Party faithful I have known for years making similar comments.
This unprecedented MMP Majority Government has 6 months tops to show they are going to change tack and deliver something substantial for the working class.
So are we really the envy of the world or as right wing fanatic Mike Hosking reported this morning on the latest lockdown relating to just 3 cases ” We are the laughing stock of the world”.
Seems like more made up bullshit to me, the likes that got him into trouble with the broadcasting standards authority.
I struggle to understand how ten year olds learn how pandemics work yet Hosking doesn’t comprehend this?
And before the woke right go off on a free speech rant, remember the platform Hosking has and the inability to directly respond or challenge his speech based on what evidence he has that we are the laughing stock of the world.
Bert the height of stupidity is to do the same thing twice turn Hosking off and start the day with a calming cup of green tea. It will do wonders for your wellbeing . Just saying!
Is that an admission that you agree Trevor? Just saying!
If there was a REAL left wing party, Labour would NOT have the majority they have. But SADLY NZ hasn’t and probably never will have a viable alternative left wing. The rich who control our media only want the two real choices, Lab/Nats. Which are basically the same thing, only one is slightly more left in the corporatist state we live in.
It’s most probably the same in most westerns Govts.
https://www.rt.com/news/515621-netanyahu-disclose-names-vaccination/
https://www.rt.com/uk/515542-dominic-raab-covid-vaccine-passports/
Yep dont worry, no ones civil liberties and righrs will be reduced due to a virus that;
Accordong to a CDC update says individuals are more likely to survive the coronavirus after contracting it. The health agency says if you have the virus between the ages of 0 to 70, you have a 99% survival rate. And if you’re over 70, the survival rate is nearly 95%.
Those statistics show the risk is about old age not communicable disease. Illness increases with age as the body wears down. Flu cases return seasonally every year. There is little difference between the number of covid deaths and death by seasonal flu. There is little evidence that any covid variant is more deadly than any other. The chance of transmitting a coronavirus through surface touching has not been recorded. The chance of transmitting or contracting coronavirus through normal activity in the outdoors is miniscule. The big hope miracle vaccine does not prevent transmission or cure mania. The vaccine is similar to any flu vaccine in it’s range and effectiveness – people will need to take this every year for the rest of their lockdown lives. I could be wrong.
I watched Worldometer deaths from all causes 2020 as the year closed. World wide 400 000 more people died last year than 2019 out of an overall population net increase of over 82 million. A smaller increase in deaths than any year on year for the last decade. In the UK where deaths are reported to be one of the worst countries the deaths from all causes were exceeded in 5 of the last 20 years.
Before we knew it’s true danger the steps taken were sensible but I do expect that the world will settle down soon having put this all into perspective.
D J S
Yes David. One thing that has been found wanting here is the weakness of the global political elite in dealing with anything that requires even a basic understanding of science or statistics. Even worse, it’s highlighted that most of the general population are quite ignorant in these regards.
“There is little difference between the number of covid deaths and death by seasonal flu”.
Yep, influenza is significant in having us depart this mortal coil. But you may well be wrong in claiming its morbidity is comparable to covid. Someone will have the stats. Or the medical background. Until then I’ll reserve my judgement.
But I take your point. There’s quite a bit of FOCC around,particularly in AO/NZ where we have been isolated from the lived experience of a good many. I am sure a good many are almost over it. Sooner or later covid will become the norm – with protection mediated though seasonal jabs. But not everywhere and everyone it seems. Some of our behaviour will most likely change. In 50 years it will have almost been forgotten – a new crisis will have our attention. Another pandemic? Climate change? The end of fossil fuels? Growing inequality? Global conflict? The board sweep of history doesn’t lie.
UK Academic Stuart Ricthie has taken on some of the Covid myths to debunk them.
https://www.covidfaq.co/
On the claim that Covid is only as dead as the flu:
https://www.covidfaq.co/Claim-It-s-only-as-deadly-as-the-flu-024fc5546bc14806a4f402c9ee28316c
I think lockdown are a mistake…but you are saying that CDC are saying for under 70s it is 1% fatalities…. that is bullshit…it ain’t that high mortality…maybe it is for those that become ill, but most barely know they even had the virus…their immune system shrugs it off… it if was 1% death rate for all that would be very high
Why can’t some of you people get it into your thick heads that it isn’t solely about morbidity rate of COVID.
It’s also about keeping the health system functioning. When ICUs and respiratory wards are overwhelmed, a host of other demands on the system cannot be met, from trauma to transplants, from influenza to childhood respiratory needs. Elective surgeries get postponed, waiting lists lengthen.
People Die.
I doubt that the reaction to a new outbreak is going to cost labour any electoral support. It is widely approved as far as I can tell.
Curious about the issue of whether the infection came from the mother or daughter. That seems to be the focus of study at this stage as they became symptomatic at exactly the same time. I would have thought that as there is supposed to be a several days delay from infection to contagion that they cannot have infected each other but must have caught the virus at the same time from the same external source. Why is this not the focus of the investigation? Who did they meet together? Or did they both catch it from a packet of frozen chicken imported through Americold?
D J S
Apparently the daughter showed symptoms before the mother. So that’s why they think there is a possibility that the daughter got it first and gave it to the mother. The tests at Papatoetoe High are aimed to see if there was earlier infection there.
Contact tracing is always part of the process.
some conflicting articles.
D J S
Once Covid is the daily normal, like flu, that’s when Jacinda will be toast. Won’t be long. This country needs to get on with things and it needs to make some serious money. Jacinda doesn’t do ‘making money’.
That’s the reason for sporadic lock downs, keep the masses terrified and you control them.
Any graduate in communications will tell you that
Bomber says Jacinda will save us?
Faith consists in believing what reason cannot. Voltaire
Well if we listened to Seymour’s reasoning we’d probably be all dead.
Meh. The Sheeple are fine – most enjoy the ‘theater’ of lockdowns. They’ll only get agitated if Beetroot hits the economic eject button and raises rates to cool down price inflation.
What is becoming worrying is that not for the first time we have limited understanding of the vector of cases. it’s not gold standard if you don’t understand how it started.
When is the NZ government going to stop the US business led witch hunt against human rights?
The Dotcom decade – and what it has cost the taxpayer
https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/kim-dotcom-extradition-huge-number-of-legal-hours-sunk-into-megaupload-case/STC3WBK2TRET34U36N5GQHV5XY/
If Hollywood wanted to prosecute Dotcom they should do it on their own dime. Sony knew it might be fruitless but the rest of Hollywood lobbied Biden to lobby John Key to do their dirty work for them.
How many new houses could be bought with the money spent on lawyers for offences that should be prosecuted in civil courts like copywriter infringement by the super rich not the NZ taxpayers?
Police acting illegally for foreign business in NZ is not acceptable, hopefully under Labour/Greens they bother to do the right thing and settle it. Otherwise like their love of human rights abuses in China and being the first to extradite based on illegal searches for political whims, they will go down in history as abusers.
Natz got their just desserts in the last election with so many voters now turned off their agenda in NZ as it became more obvious they were working for foreign business and political lobbying not NZ’s good.
Jacindas measure of success would be if everybody survived (it is irrelevant to her that the majority of the population are going to be living in cars or tents, it does not matter that kids are starving, she does not care that crime is increasing exponentially because people see the inequality increasing and see no hope of future for themselves….. as long as we are not getting COVID?….. and the rich homeowners and investors are getting so much richer).
“The Political Opposition has channeled that frustration and have been far more critical of the Government this time so there are numerous political threats to Labour over the decision to go into Level 3.”
Well, can say, on behalf of labour, can I just write FUCK their political opposition. I do truly mean that. The cadre of overly indulged bludgers in blue and the various sickly shades there-of can just right fuck off.
If the natzo’s had been in ‘power’ we’d a been sold out in a heart beat and every ‘power’ grasping minion submissive to collins’ ‘power’ eyebrows would have already privatised the last gargle from our dead bodies. Capturing the last death-breath of a covid diseased victim to peddle to the natzo’s voting vampires for the money would have surely brought in ‘good coin’ and many profitable deals and relationships would have been sealed between the sweaty, polyester sheets in the drag houses along Cuba St.
If I were national I’d shut up, stay in the shadows and bank the lower rate. Or explode? What ever proves most thrifty for we tax payers. Just imagine if national had won the last election tho??? Imagine that !?
Wow your crystal ball is amazing. You knew all that yet you didn’t know last weekends lotto numbers?
Indulge us with the truth BG? Michael Woodhouse truth that is?
I don’t know what would have happened had National been in power, no one does. But I love the “If National were the govt, we’d all be dead don’t you know?”
How do you know that? Are you Nostradamus?
“Kiwis are a fickle herd at the best of times and can turn like sheep in a paddock if they feel their self sacrifice has been mistreated by incompetence, the gratitude vote of 2020 will quickly swing the other way if a Level 4 lockdown is imposed because of a fuck up at MIQ that the Government had already been warned about.”
You nailed it there Martyn.
If it gets into the general population, it’s the end of the Ardern government. But this isn’t so much fickle as rational: The only reason she was reelected was because she managed sound so soothing and reassuring before the election. It certainly wasn’t due to policy success in any other area!
She also got in Andrew cause john left on his own accord due to him finding out how unpopular even hated he had become.
And useless he, the flag referendum, his ministers and his policies were.
@ MB. You write.
“Kiwis are a fickle herd at the best of times and can turn like sheep in a paddock if they feel their self sacrifice has been mistreated by incompetence”
BBC:
“Sheep are one of the most unfairly stereotyped animals on the planet. Almost everything we believe about them is wrong….”
http://www.bbc.com/earth/story/20170418-sheep-are-not-stupid-and-they-are-not-helpless-either
“Reputation: Sheep are stupid, defenceless and harmless creatures that mope about on hillsides doing not very much. They are good for two things: being eaten and producing wool.”
“Reality: Sheep are actually surprisingly intelligent, with impressive memory and recognition skills. They build friendships, stick up for one another in fights, and feel sad when their friends are sent to slaughter. They are also one of the most destructive creatures on the planet.”
As long as they are given time to think instead of being panicked, they do indeed think quite effectively .
How often have you watched someone “working” their dog and notice that the dog has a far better understanding of how to work the sheep than the human.
D J S
Jacinda’s Socialist Secret Police marching us all into forced vaccinations camps?
It was Judith Collins’ questions in Parliament today which suggested she was the one for compulsory swabbing of people.
Comments are closed.