Dave Macpherson: Same mental health system, with the same creaking around the edges


Where has this Jacinda gone?

In the last two years of the unlamented National Government a series of horror stories focussing on the outcomes of poor or non-existent mental health care rocked the pages of both social and mainstream media. The response by the unlamented former Health Minister was somewhere between timid and non-existent, and an angry public cited poor mental health services as one of the key issues during the last general election campaign, although few politicians – with honourable exceptions being Andrew Little and Jacinda Ardern – actually had the gumption to talk openly about the issue.

Fast forward to halfway through the term of the new Labour-led Government and we look at what has changed. [Blank space here]

If you’re on the ground, desperately looking for mental health services to intervene for whanau/family members that are clearly unwell, you will be having just as hard a time as in any period in the last 5-10 years.

TDB Recommends NewzEngine.com

Waikato DHB has still only got one crisis management team for 400,000 people, spread over the length of a six hour drive. Canterbury DHB has still got inpatient facilities that are too old to be called Victorian, and are so decrepit that they are listed as a danger for both patients and staff. The culture of staff and families needing to tug their forelocks before the psychiatrists is still in place, with the odd honourable exception; and the culture of failing to be accountable for mistakes is very much alive throughout not only the DHBs, but also the Ministry of Health.

If you are a Government member, or Labour supporter, you may be saying about now things like – ‘give them a chance’ and ‘Rome wasn’t built in a day’. Speaking as someone who worked for them in the last election, I say that excuse is getting a little threadbare.

Yes, there has been a big travelling roadshow – the Mental Health Commission – which certainly travelled far and wide and received thousands of heartfelt and harrowing stories about failures in the mental health system. Many of these were well reported in its findings, although these strangely did not include the Maori part of the Panel’s findings, a diluted version of which has more recently been quietly slipped out as some sort of appendix.

The problem to date is that, apart from a literal handful of pilot/trials, no new initiatives have yet started as a result of these findings, and the Government itself has three times delayed the release of its statement as to what it will be doing, now tieing that in with the upcoming budget. And the thing about budgets is that they do not get things started immediately – very often the earliest implementation of budget initiatives happens the next financial year (after April 1) or, if you’re lucky, in the new calendar year.

The truth is, while the Prime Minister is still calling for urgency in this space, and has herself come up with proposals for sensible, no-brainer initiatives like more mental health trained staff in schools, the Government structure – particularly the Ministry of Health – has successfully grabbed the idea, and is in the process of bureaucratising it, Yes Ministering it and burying it. The question is: will we have a hard-driving Minister of Health that can resist this siren call?

The new 2020 election year will be on us in a few months – will there be anything in the mental health space to show for our 2017 votes?

Just in case Minister Clark has forgotten some of the types of mental health horror stories that hounded his predecessor, we highlight some of the very recent ones that have appeared:

  • A current set of cases in front of Coroner Wallace Bain relating to the deaths of five people in the Wellington area at the hands of different people with mental illnesses;
  • A severely ill person in the Waikato who was refused inpatient support by Waikato DHB’s mental health services until after he had attacked and injured his father;
  • A protest by hundreds of family members outside Parliament calling for better mental health support for their loved ones and others lost to suicide;
  • A Canterbury DHB mental health patient found living in such an emaciated state, amidst severe squalor, that she needed immediate hospital care, despite supposed regular checkups from DHB staff;
  • Record ‘seclusion’ levels at Waikato DHB’s inpatient mental health facility, and an unfair nationwide spate of blaming mental health patients for violence against staff when the real issue is lack of staff and facility resources (from Mental Health Foundation);
  • Young Blenheim woman turned away twice from Nelson-Marlborough DHB acute mental health services and now missing for over 2 months;
  • A suicide attempt by a young Muslim boy in Auckland after severe bullying at school because of his religious beliefs;
  • Taranaki DHB’s mental health ward described as a “run-down, dirty, filthy environment” sparking DHB and Ministry investigations (as if they didn’t know);
  • Waikato DHB tries to overturn Coroner’s finding that Nicky Stevens’ death was “avoidable” after a series of mistakes by DHB staff and management.

Does the Government really want this litany of horror stories to continue, without any obvious changes being implemented?

Dave Macpherson became an Elected Waikato DHB Board member after the DHB killed his son, he is TDBs mental health blogger.


  1. Jacinda wants to tidy up social media, so a source of social ills, e.g. transmitted and spread ‘hate speech’ and the likes, will be stopped or at least moderated.

    So she is in Paris now, rubbing shoulders with Monsieur Macron, who wants to silence some social media, as it does seem to give the Yellow Vests too much oxygen.

    For the rest: If you don’t like something, shut the door and look away, if you cannot stop it, that seems to be the message.

  2. The teachers want more money and support services, they only get some of what they demand. The health sector and its workers and patients will fare similarly, I fear.

    We do not have more money, so said Grant Robertson on Breakfast TV today, and Tracey Martin said something similar on lame tame Q+A last night.

  3. Yes Labour are going so slow with most issues now.

    It seems to be so soul destroying doesn’t it Dave?

    We also live in hope that jacinda will put it all right, as “it’s the putting it right that counts”

    • Saving the actual delivery for the next election bribe? I don’t know. Even that is a pipe dream me thinks, going by the broken promises and stalling Jacinda is playing for time. Still hope she will deliver, let’s face it, there would be none, nada, zip, if the Natzi’s were still in power.

  4. These issues are too crucial to the well-being of the whole community as well as for the sadly unwell, and Ardern’s govt will look like more and more like dilettantes if they don’t act pronto.

    If they are using the previous National govt as a role model, then they’re pretty sick themselves. Magdalene nuns would be better- and that’s not saying much either.

    Have just survived a week with my landline disconnected -and no internet access- the day I was quitting Spark. I still don’t know why, but I’m told the most likely reasons are a cock-up by Chorus, or mischief-making by Spark.

    It left me opposed to solitary confinement for prisoners in jail, and seriously querying mental health patients being put into seclusion. Health benefits ? What health benefits ? More like punishment.

    Back in the 70’s, at least one public hospital, had a practice of having patients heavily sedated for two weeks in their psyche ward.It was done to a friend of mine who something terrible had happened to, to give her the time out which she needed.

    I don’t know if that is still done. Another friend who nursed at Wellington Hospital’s psych unit in the 1990’s said it was bedlam at night. as overnight sedation of patients had been discontinued. A troubled or disturbed person being admitted, rather than finding it a needed haven, was likely to feel even worse, or even frightened.

    Time to look at the medicos who staff the Health Dept too – traditionally they have sometimes been second-raters looking for an easy ride.

    However confident the coalition may feel about the next election, sweet words won’t win it, but a pro-active social conscience would help.

  5. It’s pretty simple really. The economic pot shrinks and is biased towards the few. The social pot frays further with the consequent stresses. The marginalised increase whilst the comfortably off avert their eyes and vote for their pockets.

    Until we open our eyes and recognise that the shrinking pot needs to be more evenly distributed and that services need funding we will carry on having tragedies. We might learn to cope with mental health related issues if we saw them as a social issue we are all responsible for as opposed to aberrant individuals.

    Maybe a kinder society means teachers foregoing pay rises, and public servants being paid less. And the wealthier being made to pay more for the social good that they benefit from. If the pie is getting smaller it needs cutting into smaller even slices.

Comments are closed.