Similar Posts

- Advertisement -

11 Comments

    1. I think the point Moana is making is that the kura has been created despite the NatACT government and its public-funded private school experiment, not because of it. One could argue that Willie (and everyone else involved in establishing this school) subverted the intent of the charter school scheme (a stealth move towards commercializing and then privatizing public schools), and strategically hijacked the funds earmarked for it to set up an exemplary public school instead of the dumbed-down commercial school they wanted.

      If the charter schools scheme had never happened, it seems likely MUMA would have set it up under the existing system, as a “special character” public school, like Otautahi democratic schools Ao Tawhito (Discovery and Unlimited). If charter schools are abolished by a future left government, the MUMA kura could easily be converted into a special character school. Claiming that Willie is a advocate for the privatization agenda behind charter schools on the basis of his participation on this kura really is clutching at straws. Thanks a lot Moana for sharing your perspective on Willie’s work.

  1. Thank you for the back-grounder, Moana. It was insightful. (It gave us more knowledge than the superficial *Shock!Horror!* reporting of the msm.) As I wrote elsewhere, we’ve all made blunders in our lives. (I’m no exception.)

    The real point is, do we learn from them.

    If Willie learned from the experience, then it’s part of his life-journey. Just as every single one of us is on his/her own life journey.

    Now. On the issue of learning-from-past-mistakes – the same applies to the Labour Party itself and if some individuals can point the finger at Willie, then I point my finger at them and ask;

    What lessons has Labour learned from 30+ years of neo-liberalism, and what remedies does it intend to implement?

    Time will tell.

    1. 30+ years of neoliberalism hasn’t helped or benefited the average New Zealander, it has enabled a huge wealth transfer to the elite or 1%, State Assets were sold off for a pittance to colleagues of Government Ministers who made huge sums of money as they refloated them to the public, sold off shares to multi national corporations or just asset stripped them. We the public got basically suckered. We haven’t witnessed the social benefits we were promised from the sale of SOE’s as the new investors sought higher returns on their investments and guess what we the public are paying the price. Neoliberalism was flawed ideology.

  2. Thank you for this Moana I have always admired Willie he is true to his people and always will be. He also cares about our pakeha whanau throughout this country many who are suffering unnecessarily to.
    I am so happy he has chosen to stand.
    You mentioned he is not afraid of being disliked and unfortunately this is all part of being a good leader having to make the hard decisions sometimes ones that many may not like but we need for the betterment of our country and all our people. I haven’t voted for labour for many years but now because of Willie I am seriously thinking about it. Bring on the election and let the people speak my hope is for change because I believe if we carry on down the same old path under the tories we are heading towards social unrest

  3. One day I guess Labour MPs will learn that airing dirty laundry in public is the height of stupidity. The Nats don’t do it. Act did it once (to their cost). NZF doesn’t do it. Why? Because it is STUPID, STUPID, STUPID!!!

    Argh!

    Thank god I’m voting green this year.

    1. I don’t know about that Priss aunty Judith showed she wanted to be the tories leader and next minute shes been demoted

  4. The thing about Jackson is that he seems to be a wake-jumper. .. Then again, maybe labour is his political home?

  5. Thank you for your feedback.

    You’re correct Strypey, the National Government was intending to establish a charter/partnership school in Mangere so Waatea decided to pitch for it. It made sense, given they can wrap their whanau ora programmes around some of their students and families. They have two well respected educationalists on their board, awesome women. I’ve written articles for e-tangata criticising much of the National Party’s policy on education but I can’t argue with the kaupapa and commitment, let alone the results, that Waatea and the Whangarei charter school are having. And having met the kids from both schools – well behaved, proud, respectful, kind of hard to knock in these two cases.

    Bit nerve wracking as I saw a tender on the government website this week for more schools. I do fear what you are saying, Siobhan – no doubt.

    SamWise – “waka jumper” was a mischievous narrative. Shane Jones or Tau Henare, yes. But I guess if you question the policy direction or leadership or strategic power of your former party or think maybe you could be more valued or effective in another, then you will jump ship? Hone did that with Mana. Tariana did that from Labour while everyone else stayed put. Hard to understand why they didn’t feel compelled to join here.

    Agreed Frank. Can Labour distinguish itself now with a new vision? We all watch with bated breath!

Comments are closed.