Similar Posts

- Advertisement -

17 Comments

  1. Inequality is growing inexorably throughout the Western world in particular, and has been since 1970..But John Minto is being too neo- liberal here. Given the finite resources of the planet,the wealth of the billionaires/Oligarchs/1% needs to be stripped from their grasping greedy hands and redistributed for the benefit of the people. What would our housing, hospitals, and schools look like if this was done? However ,I must admit what he proposes is a good interim step!!

  2. ‘Our lives have been hijacked by billionaires.’

    Our lives have been hijacked by sociopaths

    Our lives have been hijacked by economists.

    Our lives have been hijacked by banks.

    Sadly, the ‘submission’ process has also been hijacked or is totally ineffective, and ‘The billionaires have decided the policies before we even cast our votes’.

    Much as we would like to see equity and justice and sustainability, the system will not allow such things because it operates for the benefit of banks, corporations and billionaires.

    Good luck trying to change that. And good luck trying to wake people to their predicament.

  3. Sadly I think we are going to have to wait for the pitchforks to appear. The media is owned and the majority are watching MAFS or whatever shit is on the other channel. I’ll write a submission but it is another half hour of my life I won’t get back, probably be better off sharpening the pitchfork.

  4. Would it make sense if Financial Transactions Tax started on transactions of 5K and above?

  5. the middle class (income earners) have lot to answer to they are the ones doing the dirty work for the very rich

    1. ‘The greatest crimes of human history are made possible by the most colorless human beings. They are the careerists. The bureaucrats. The cynics. They do the little chores that make vast, complicated systems of exploitation and death a reality. They collect and read the personal data gathered on tens of millions of us by the security and surveillance state. They keep the accounts of ExxonMobil, BP and Goldman Sachs. They build or pilot aerial drones. They work in corporate advertising and public relations. They issue the forms. They process the papers. They deny food stamps to some and unemployment benefits or medical coverage to others. They enforce the laws and the regulations. And they do not ask questions……..’

      https://www.truthdig.com/articles/the-careerists/

  6. This reminds me of the game of monopoly. Once the other person has all the best real estate and train stations you are cast into debt forever and there is no way out. I hate monopoly.

  7. The UK has a system whereby all rich-listers are assigned a personal tax inspector in an attempt to get the billionaires to pay their fair share. Each tax inspector is transferred to a different rich-lister every two years to ensure that no unfair or biased relationships develop between the rich
    lister and their tax inspector.

    According to the UK IRD, the scheme has been a great success and has added billions of pounds to the UK Treasury for a relatively modest outlay. Why not try same scheme here in NZ? The idea that rich-listers are able to manipulate their declared incomes down to below $70,000 is an insult to all honest NZ taxpayers and shouldn’t be tolerated.

  8. A very thourough and useful set of constructive thinking on this subject:
    https://taxworkinggroup.govt.nz/…/twg-subm-bgrd-paper-mar18…
    and a good example of why we need a democracy such as we have in New Zealand to allow for this sort of process.
    Not many, I included, have either the time or the requisite knowledge to grapple with these issues substantively and so I will continue to vote for the politicians who allow this caliber of advisors to help filter the complexities honestly.
    Although John’s three tax suggestions sound very useful, they may miss the most important long-term issue the Government should seriously contemplate: a set of environmental taxes that discourage intensive farming. Not just Dairy but all exploitation of natural resources as monocultures, for example mussel farming and scallop dredging).

  9. The article isn’t cited. Anyone who owns a company pays themselves $70k. Why?
    It makes tax returns easier. Yes you can declare income subject to PAYE to be $70k. That doesn’t mean that is the only tax you pay.
    If a business makes money, 28% is paid in tax. If a business makes $5m in profit and distributed it to a single shareholder who also received a salary of $70k the owner would 1. Have already paid tax of 28% and 2. would compete a tax return and pay an extra 5% in tax because the effective tax rate as you approach $5m becomes ~33%.
    Acting like the rich capital owners do not pay tax is a blatant lie.
    The author of this article should be ashamed for spreading misinformation.

  10. What if the only way to keep 7.6(?) billion people alive is that we have to have all these utter bastards running the show?
    Like if the bastards weren’t screwing over most of the countries that have resources to extract IE – OUR fertilizer (think bird poo) to all the oil NZ uses to maintain our present living conditions (of which admittedly aren’t that shit hot for most of us).
    I mean what thanks have we given say the Iraqi’s ? No fing thanks, just aided the US to murder them instead.
    And if everyone had dollars to spend the environment would be even more screwed, picture 7.6 billion 20 degree C temp bedrooms, all with TVs and hot and cold water, and 3 cars in garage.
    3,858,000 vehicles in New Zealand in 2015, so for NZ that is nearly a vehicle per person times that by 7.6 billion?
    Environmentally it is better to have a few rich pricks driving around in $200,000.00 cars, than a bunch of broken arses in say 40 $5,000 cars, My van is worth $500.00 so that would be 400 vans = $200,000.00
    What if as Jack said “This is as good as it gets” … but no ifs really

  11. Any country that does not have a state bank as the main agency for issue of loans, is run by the international private banking cabal. The scourge of the Earth.

    NZ needs to bring back the State Advances agency as well as change the banking system.

    Such actions may bring the US frigates to our harbours, but solidarity of Kiwis can bring a change.

    We have to take media control out of private hands and dump RNZ right wing management which facilitates the steady stream of propaganda from US studios polluting out understanding of what is happening locally and internationally.

    Throwing off the shackles of myths and lies is the first step to understanding.

    1. Criminal activity disposing of our sovereign banks for a pittance, in the end the sale of the BNZ actually cost the country ? ie ……a loss on the sale ?

  12. Have a look at the Rich List in NZ and figure out how they got there, it definitely wasn’t through blood, sweat and tears ?

Comments are closed.