Political Roundup: Was New Zealand’s deployment to Iraq worth it?

3
200
By Geoffrey Miller

After more than seven years, the end is finally in sight for New Zealand’s anti-Isis deployment in Iraq.

The Government recently announced that the remaining two personnel deployed to Iraq and Kuwait as part of the Global Coalition to Defeat the Islamic State of Iraq and Syria will be withdrawn by the end of June 2023.

The mission has lasted far longer than the original two years that were planned.

John Key, New Zealand’s then National Party Prime Minister, initiated New Zealand’s contribution towards the multilateral coalition when he sent 143 soldiers to Iraq in February 2015.

Upon committing the troops, Key famously challenged other parties in Parliament to ‘get some guts and join the right side’ by supporting the deployment.

At the time, New Zealand’s involvement in the anti-Isis mission was opposed by the Labour, Green and New Zealand First parties that were then in opposition.

Key was initially adamant that the deployment would end within the two-year period – but Andrew Little, Labour’s leader at the time and now the minister in charge of intelligence services, warned of the potential for ‘mission creep’.

- Advertisement -

Little’s warning turned out to be prescient.

Jacinda Ardern, who succeeded Little as Labour leader shortly before she became Prime Minister after the 2017 election, extended the mission in 2018. The extension came despite Isis losing all territory it had previously held in Iraq by the end of 2017.

To be fair, the number of New Zealand troops deployed to Iraq gradually fell over time. And the last remaining 45 New Zealand soldiers who were directly involved in training Iraqi soldiers at the Taji military base, near Baghdad, were withdrawn in early 2020.

New Zealand’s embassy in Baghdad, opened in 2015 to support the deployment, also closed in 2020. But the Government seemed unwilling to pull the plug on the operation altogether. A handful of New Zealand troops based in Iraq, Kuwait and Qatar continued to be deployed to the anti-Isis mission.

Some parallels might be drawn with New Zealand’s deployment in Afghanistan, which lasted for 20 years and finally ended with the withdrawal of the remaining six soldiers in 2021.

New Zealand’s role in Afghanistan began with the deployment of elite Special Air Service (SAS) troops for a 12-month mission in late 2001, followed by a Provincial Reconstruction Team (PRT) in 2003.

As with Iraq, the mission was repeatedly extended by various New Zealand governments – always with the view that the job was not quite done.

Ardern’s ‘Isis remains a threat’ justification from September 2018 was a case in point.

Of course, there were differences with Afghanistan too. While ten NZDF soldiers died in Afghanistan, no New Zealand lives were lost in Iraq. There was also no equivalent to the controversial October 2010 incident known as ‘Operation Burnham’ that caused the death of five Afghan civilians.

This is something to be thankful for. To some extent this can be explained by the fact that New Zealand soldiers largely operated ‘behind the wire’ training Iraqis at Camp Taji.

But New Zealand’s mission was far from risk-free.

Citing Kurdish sources, The Guardian reported in 2016 that New Zealand SAS soldiers were also deployed in Iraq. The claim was met with only a qualified denial from Gerry Brownlee, the defence minister in the National-led government in power at the time.

Moreover, Camp Taji itself came under repeated rocket attacks in early 2020, killing two US troops and a British medic. The attacks were thought to have been conducted by Iran-backed groups in retaliation for the killing by the US of top Iranian commander Qasem Soleimani in January of that year.

After losing all of its territory in Iraq by 2017, Isis faced a similar defeat in Syria in 2019.

But like al-Qaeda before it, Isis has also inspired an ideology. To some extent, this ideology has inspired sympathisers to commit terrorist attacks well beyond Iraq’s borders.

While most of these were in Europe, this past weekend marked the first anniversary of an Isis-inspired stabbing attack that left eight wounded at an Auckland supermarket.

The perpetrator, Ahamed Samsudeen, was a Sri Lankan national who had come to New Zealand as a student in 2011. He later gained refugee status, although this was later revoked.

While in New Zealand, Samsudeen apparently self-radicalised with the help of Isis propaganda. He was arrested at Auckland Airport in 2017, from where authorities believed he was attempting to travel to Syria.

Samsudeen was held in prison on remand for a total of four years on relatively minor charges, before being released and shadowed by police in 2021 who shot and killed him during his knife attack.

New Zealand passed new counter-terrorism laws after the Countdown supermarket stabbings which criminalised the plotting of terrorist attacks.

In Iraq itself, the past week has illustrated that huge challenges remain despite Isis’s defeat.

Baghdad saw some of the worst violence it has seen in years, after supporters of Shiite cleric Muqtada al-Sadr and rival Shiite groups loosely backed by Iran battled each other in the capital’s fortified Green Zone. The clashes resulted in 30 deaths, along with hundreds of injuries.

Iraq has been without a government since elections in October 2021, in which al-Sadr’s party won the largest number of seats – but not a majority. Al-Sadr’s announcement last week that he would leave politics essentially triggered the violence, while his pleas for calm a day later largely stopped it.

It remains to be seen whether the political deadlock can be broken, but civil war is not off the table if clashes between the groups resume.

In themselves, Iraq’s domestic political problems have little direct relation with either Isis or with New Zealand.

But the country’s ongoing political crisis, combined with an economic malaise that was only exacerbated by Covid-19 – youth unemployment reached a record 27 per cent last year – provides a recipe for discontent.

New Zealand appears to have some awareness of this: while the military deployment is ending, the Government is pledging to ‘refocus’ the commitment to ‘non-military workstreams…to continue the fight against violent extremism and address the longer-term security and humanitarian challenges faced by the Government and people of Iraq’.

These are fine words, but the extent of New Zealand’s future assistance seems to be limited to a small, $NZ4m contribution over the next three years – which is unlikely to go far, given the scale of the challenges that Iraq faces.

Any notion that New Zealand is leaving Iraq for good needs to be set against the fact that the anti-Isis contribution that John Key originally announced in 2015 was New Zealand’s third Iraq-related mission in 30 years.

It followed missions to support the Gulf War in 1991 and the dispatch of New Zealand Defence Force engineers following the US-led invasion of the country in 2003.

This may be the end of the road for New Zealand’s military deployment to defeat Isis.

But it is unlikely to be the last Kiwi mission to Iraq.

Geoffrey Miller is the Democracy Project’s international analyst and writes on current New Zealand foreign policy and related geopolitical issues. He has lived in Germany and the Middle East and is a learner of Arabic and Russian.

Other items of interest and importance today

HOMELESSNESS AND HOUSING
Kristin Hall (1News): Undercover report: Rotorua’s emergency housing crisis exposed
Steven Walton (Stuff): 500 children living in Christchurch motels as city’s housing list quadruples
Duncan Garner (Today FM): People living in motels jumps almost 400 percent under Labour
Kelly Makiha (Herald): Rotorua’s homeless and emergency housing story: The past, the present and the people
David Farrar: Kiwibuild on track for 2313
Thomas Coughlan (Herald): Auckland Council villa protections may break law – Government
Geraden Cann (Stuff): Regulator and real estate body coordinated on journalists’ inquiries
Herald Editorial: Twenty-five per cent house price drop forecast by 2023/24 in new report – what that means (paywalled)
RNZ: Master Builders says building consents system is ‘broken’
Esther Taunton (Stuff): What could NZ learn from the post-war housing movement that helped shape Norway?

INTEGRITY AND TRANSPARENCY
Anneke Smith (RNZ): New Zealand democracy on ‘shaky foundations’: Electoral law ripe for change
Audrey Young (Herald): Auditor-General John Ryan puts his stamp on the job(paywalled)
Jenée Tibshraeny (Herald): The Opposition’s warning about ‘dubious’ Reserve Bank board appointments (paywalled)

GOVERNMENT AND PARLIAMENT
Luke Malpass (Stuff): What’s happened to Labour’s political radar?
Claire Trevett (Herald): A tax backdown and cost of living skewering – is Labour’s political antenna broken? (paywalled)
Eric Crampton (Stuff): Excessive government: Is it time for Labour to rein it in?
Thomas Coughlan (Herald): Beehive Diaries: How to win a Covid meat pack (paywalled)
Rachel Sadler (Newshub): Jacinda Ardern to attend UN General Assembly, also promote trade, investment, tourism while in New York
RNZ: Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern to travel to New York for United Nations meeting
Kathy Spencer (Herald): Cost of living payment is a fiasco and Labour was warned(paywalled)
Rachel Smalley (Today FM): Christopher Luxon got there in the end
Henry Cooke (The Guardian): Blunt, passionate and sometimes reckless, New Zealand’s newest ambassador has rarely been diplomatic
Stephen Minto (Daily Blog): Labour’s achilles heel
Martyn Bradbury (Daily Blog): Labour rage against the Ministry Spin Machines – the war against a self serving Public Service
Brad Lewis (Today FM): Kim Dotcom hints at revival of Internet Party and political comeback for 2023 election
Johnny Blades (RNZ): Bringing Parliament and more to the people: PTV
Stuff: Important reading and writing questions for ex politician and memoir writer Chris Finlayson

KIWISAVER FEE TAX BACKDOWN
Heather du Plessis-Allan (Herald): Labour has broken its promise with KiwiSaver tax escapade (paywalled)
Janet Wilson (Stuff): Labour finds itself in ‘a conflagration of its own making’
Tracy Watkins (Stuff): KiwiSaver naivety taxes our credulity
Richard Harman: So what did the PM know and when did she know it? (paywalled)
Steven Joyce (Herald): What KiwiSaver stuff-up says about the state of the Government(paywalled)
Calida Stuart-Menteath and Hamish McNicol (NBR): Govt suffered unneccesary whiplash on ‘KiwiSaver tax’ (paywalled)
Herald: What was Government thinking with the ‘KiwiSaver tax’
Janine Starks (Stuff): No GST on KiwiSaver, what about charging it on mortgages?
Hayden Munro (Herald): Labour and the great Kiwisaver U-turn (paywalled)
Victor Billot (Newsroom): An Ode for .. David ‘U-turned’ Parker

ECONOMY, EMPLOYMENT AND INEQUALITY
Bernard Hickey: What Adrian Orr learned at Jackson Hole
Liam Dann (Herald): Running hot – what if the economy won’t slow down? (paywalled)
Rebecca Macfie (Newsroom): Courier dream becomes a nightmare
Amanda Cropp (Stuff): Temp workers are making hay as businesses struggle to fill jobs while waiting for migrant labour to return
Hayden Donnell (RNZ): Taking a more sceptical stance for business
1News: Inflation, low unemployment behind strike action wave – historian
Daniel Smith (Stuff): How does inflation affect five Kiwi families?

LOCAL GOVERNMENT, THREE WATERS, AND ELECTIONS
Tom Hunt (Stuff): By-election likely to cost $1.2m if Paul Eagle wins Wellington mayoralty
Andrea Vance (Stuff): Wake up, sheeple! Disinformation is the greatest conspiracy of all
Toby Manhire (Spinoff): Ways to work out who – and what – you’re voting for these local elections
Joel Maxwell (Stuff): Does your mayoral candidate know the mana whenua in their council turf?
Stuff: ‘Be aware of who you’re voting for’: Voters keep close eye on local candidates
Logan Savory (Stuff): The knight, broadcaster, and deputies: Inside Invercargill’s intriguing mayoral race
Tina Law (Stuff): Boos, an eviction and a disruptive slime monster: Christchurch’s mayoral race heats up
No Right Turn: Still against a four year term
Maree Mahony (RNZ): Local body elections are looming – how to vote and why they matter
Jonathan Milne (Newsroom): Bed taxes and road pricing get green light from Govt review panel
Stephen Ward (Stuff): Gallagher hopes ‘worst fears’ for Aotearoa’s democracy are not realised
Nicholas Boyack (Stuff): Time for Upper Hutt to talk mergers, housing and its tired CBD
RNZ: More than a billion dollars needed to fix Lower Hutt’s water infrastructure
Gerry Brownlee (Herald): Christchurch ratepayers will pay much more for water and water services

HEALTH
Rachel Thomas (Stuff): Thousands ‘getting progressively sicker’ as surgeries pushed back further
Nicole Bremner (1News): Health sector special: Extent of staffing issues revealed
Ian Powell: It started with a quip and ended with corporation culture
Damien Grant (Stuff): Every life is worth the same, but maybe not at Pharmac
Bryce Wilkinson: The shocking absence of accurate diagnosis for health policy
Katie Harris (Herald): The quiet shift to more inclusive pregnancy language and the long road toward systemic change
1News: Disability ministry head wants change in attitudes

LAW AND JUSTICE
Jarrod Gilbert (Herald): Why we need to shine a brighter light on white-collar criminals(paywalled)
Claire Trevett (Herald): Government to announce law changes to help police stop criminal groups from hiding assets
Luke Malpass (Stuff): Government to toughen laws on illegally gained wealth of criminals

TREATY
Te Aniwa Hurihanganui (1News): Govt accused of ‘rushing’ Treaty settlement to avoid returning $800m in assets
Audrey Young (Herald): Treaty of Waitangi revisited – Ned Fletcher challenges accepted wisdom on sovereignty (paywalled)
Philip Matthews (Stuff): The lawyer and the Treaty: An ‘optimistic’ view of troubled history

MEDIA
Alexander Gillespie and Claire Breen (The Conversation): The merger of TVNZ and RNZ needs to build trust in public media – 3 things the law change must get right
Anna Fifield (Stuff): Letter from the DomPost editor: Moving past combative to constructive
Colin Peacock (RNZ): On the outside of the public media push
ODT: We tell the stories that matter – yours

OTHER
Guyon Espiner (RNZ): Lotto stores in poorest half of NZ account for 70% of sales
David Fisher (Herald): The bureaucratic box-tick that could kill a woman’s family – and the lives that sit in Phil Twyford’s hands (paywalled)
Lois Williams (Newsroom): ‘Outstanding’ land stewards spark conservation clash
Helen Clark (Stuff): Time for New Zealand to lead again – on drug policy
William Hewett and Alexa Cook (Newshub): Former Prime Minister Helen Clark calls for new approaches to tackle methamphetamine harm in New Zealand
Charlotte Graham-McLay (Guardian): New Zealand’s shadow foreign affairs spokesperson faces criticism for response to UN report on Uyghurs
David Fisher (Herald): Police seeking ‘mole’ who leaked sensitive email to right-wing blogger (paywalled)
Marc Daalder (Newsroom): Spies: Extremist citizen’s arrests could end in violence
Graeme Tuckett (Stuff): Fire and Fury is a tough, brave, accessible piece of work that needs to be seen
Glenn McConnell (Stuff): The new chief censor is watching New Zealand’s horrific uncensorable underbelly
Simon Bridges (Herald): We need a smarter response to transport emissions(paywalled)
Tim O’Loan (Herald): Our ageing population and immigration settings are bad for all of us

3 COMMENTS

  1. and our dead terrorist in the ukraine wasn’t ‘operational’ cos ron (getting the truth is like pulling teeth) marks says so….

  2. As it was in support of the American mission, which it is well documented was intended to support ISIS, rather than fight against it, the deployment was worse than useless. We assisted evil.

    Only through the establishment of the Populist Mobilization Forces with the help of the Iranian people and the elite IRGC was ISIS defeated in Iraq. Indeed, the Americans did their best to enable ISIS to attack, rape and kill members of minority communities like the Yezidis who did not support their Kurdish traitor allies.

    In Syria, ISIS was stopped by a coalition between the Syrian government, militias supported by Syria and Iran, and the might of the Russian military. America did nothing to attack ISIS, unless they threatened the oilfields that their Kurdish proxies were squatting on, stealing from the Syrian people.

Comments are closed.