Political Roundup: Why Jacinda Ardern said no to the Commonwealth, but yes to NATO

By Geoffrey Miller

Jacinda Ardern’s decision to attend the upcoming North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) summit in Spain – but to skip the Commonwealth Heads of Government Meeting (CHOGM) in Rwanda – symbolises the changes she is making to New Zealand foreign policy.

The Commonwealth Heads of Government Meeting (CHOGM) starts today in Kigali, while the NATO summit will be held in Madrid next week.

However, Jacinda Ardern is only attending the NATO summit. She is sending her foreign minister, Nanaia Mahuta, to attend the Commonwealth meeting in her place.

Ardern is hardly alone with her decision to stay away from CHOGM – so far, only 35 of 54 Commonwealth leaders have sent an RSVP. New Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese will be among the absentees – deputy Prime Minister (and defence minister) Richard Marles will go instead.

This is despite the fact that this year’s CHOGM is being held during the Queen’s Platinum Jubilee year and just over a month before the Commonwealth Games – the grouping’s sporting flagship. The summit will also be the first CHOGM since 2018, the first CHOGM in Africa since 2007 and the first to be hosted by a ‘new’ Commonwealth member – Rwanda was never a British colony, but voluntarily joined the Commonwealth in 2009.

Indeed, Rwanda’s hosting of the summit this year is not without controversy. Freedom House, a US-based think tank, calls the country ‘not free’, with a ranking of just 22 points out of 100 – placing it firmly in the bottom third of its global rankings, two places ahead of Russia.

Freedom House says the Rwandan regime – led by authoritarian President Paul Kagame – undertakes ‘pervasive surveillance, intimidation, torture, and renditions or suspected assassinations of exiled dissidents.’

- Advertisement -

This year’s CHOGM also threatens to be overshadowed by a UK plan to deport asylum-seekers to Rwanda. Prince Charles, who reportedly called the deal ‘appalling’, will be representing the Queen at the summit in Kigali.

Despite these two red flags, prominent human rights organisations are not calling for a boycott of the event. Rather, they want Commonwealth leaders to draw attention to the problems. Human Rights Watch, for instance, has asked leaders to voice their ‘grave concern to the [Rwandan] government on its human rights record’. And, in reference to the UK-Rwanda asylum-seeker deal, Amnesty International wants Commonwealth members to ‘seize the opportunity in Kigali to denounce this inhumane arrangement’.

Jacinda Ardern’s no-show at CHOGM is probably driven partly by domestic political considerations and timing. This Friday’s inaugural ‘Matariki’ public holiday, which marks the Māori New Year, was a key election campaign pledge by Ardern’s Labour Party in 2020 – and the Prime Minister is scheduled to attend a pre-dawn ceremony on the day.

Outside of the Commonwealth Games, the Commonwealth has a low profile – but it has a lot going for it. Few intergovernmental organisations can rival it for size – with the Commonwealth’s collective population reaching 2.6 billion, only the likes of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) forum and the United Nations (UN) represent more people.

Moreover, the Commonwealth has a particular strength in representing small states, especially island ones – 25 of the 54 members are classified as Small Island Developing States. This means the Commonwealth can be a particularly useful forum for discussing climate change and environmental issues. The results have included initiatives such as the Commonwealth Litter Programme, which has made real differences to countries such as Vanuatu in fighting plastic pollution.

The Commonwealth is more than just a talking shop, but the disparate nature of its membership is a major challenge. The Commonwealth includes wealthy, democratic countries such as New Zealand, Australia, Canada and the UK – but also poor, authoritarian ones such as Cameroon, Rwanda and Uganda. In between, there are also some rich authoritarian members (such as Brunei) and less well-off democracies (such as India)

Of course, there is still great value in an organisation that brings opposing sides together for a robust exchange of views – the new geopolitical faultline between the Global South and North over Ukraine is a case in point. While Western countries – including New Zealand – have provided strong support to Ukraine, most non-Western countries have not followed suit.

It would do Jacinda Ardern good to listen to the rationale that countries such as South Africa and Mozambique might have for not falling in line with the Western position. Countries perhaps learn best when they are not just surrounded by their like-minded friends.

However, in the new Cold War, ideology is back with a vengeance – and many countries are drifting away from pragmatic, inclusive groupings towards more ideologically-driven ones. For Australia, this means countering Chinese influence with the reinvigorated ‘Quad’ arrangement (with India, Japan and the US) and AUKUS (with the United Kingdom and the United States); for New Zealand, the Pacific Islands Forum and bilateral meetings with Australia and the United States have taken on greater significance.

All of this explains why Jacinda Ardern has accepted an invitation to attend NATO’s Madrid Summit next week. Jens Stoltenberg, the alliance’s Secretary General, has recently been at pains to highlight the invitation to the bloc’s ‘Asia-Pacific partners’ – Australia, Japan, New Zealand and South Korea. The reason is obvious – on Thursday, Stoltenberg specifically mentioned China as one of the priorities for the meeting, which will set out a new ‘Strategic Concept’ – effectively a blueprint for the future of NATO.

And while NATO’s main focus will remain on security in Europe, last year’s summit in Brussels – held well before Russia’s invasion of Ukraine – was noteworthy for making China its main priority. The summit’s communique made NATO’s position crystal-clear: ‘China’s stated ambitions and assertive behaviour present systemic challenges to the rules-based international order and to areas relevant to Alliance security’.

Jacinda Ardern’s invitation to attend the NATO’s 2022 Madrid Summit will also be something of a reward for aligning New Zealand’s foreign policy more closely with NATO – and the West generally – over the past few months. After all, Ardern has overhauled New Zealand’s foreign policy by introducing sanctions against Russia and sending military equipment and weapons to Ukraine – and by making a symbolic contribution of New Zealand troops to Europe to assist with the war effort.

But as Stoltenberg likes to say, security ‘does not come for free’ – and the meeting will undoubtedly also serve as an opportunity to put pressure on New Zealand to provide even more assistance. The NATO Secretary-General recently pointed out that there have been ‘seven consecutive years of rising defence investment across Europe and Canada’. New Zealand’s military spending shows a remarkably similar trajectory, with spending now at the 1.5% of GDP level– up from 1.1% in 2015, although still well below NATO’s target of 2%.

Like Jacinda Ardern, Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky will also be a guest of honour at the NATO summit. Anthony Albanese is also travelling to Madrid – and Zelensky has already invited the Australian PM to visit Kyiv.

If he accepts, Albanese would be following in the footsteps of many other NATO country leaders who have travelled to Ukraine in recent weeks, including the UK’s Boris Johnson, France’s Emmanuel Macron and Germany’s Olaf Scholz.

And given the focus on Western unity and solidarity in recent months, there’s every chance Jacinda Ardern would travel together with Anthony Albanese on any European side-trip to Ukraine – on a joint ANZAC solidarity mission.

Ardern is backing NATO over CHOGM.

She might be choosing Kyiv over Kigali.

Geoffrey Miller is the Democracy Project’s international analyst and writes on current New Zealand foreign policy and related geopolitical issues. He has lived in Germany and the Middle East and is a learner of Arabic and Russian.

Other items of interest and importance from the last week

Chris Trotter (Interest): Tauranga: A predictable result, with a warning attached
Claire Trevett (Herald): PM Jacinda Ardern may regret writing off the Tauranga byelection as a lost cause (paywalled)
Toby Manhire (Spinoff): Reading the weather of the Tauranga byelection
Te Aorewa Rolleston (Stuff): Uffindell makes first day of new role a day out in the sun
Richard Harman: The real winner in Tauranga (paywalled)
Sandra Conchie (Herald): Incoming Tauranga MP Sam Uffindell wants to tackle crime ang gangs, Port of Tauranga berth
Kiri Gillespie (Herald): Tauranga byelection: Former MP Simon Bridges’ message to successor Sam Uffindell
RNZ: Tauranga by-election: New MP Sam Uffindell’s priorities are tackling crime and gangs, easing cost of living
Matthew Hooton (Patreon): Tauranga: Bad for National, but catastrophic for Labour (and so good for National) (paywalled)
Matthew Hooton (Herald): Tauranga — bad news for everyone? (paywalled)
David Farrar (Patreon): How bad was the Tauranga result for the Government?(paywalled)
David Farrar: Uffindell wins huge
David Farrar: Meet the Labour law breakers
Mike Munro (Herald): Why you’ll fit in National’s caucus splendidly, Sam (paywalled)
Liam Hehir: Tauranga and Labour’s deadly political gravity (paywalled)
Brent Edwards (NBR): National should win Tauranga by-election, but by how much?(paywalled)
Richard Harman: The fight on the right in Tauranga (paywalled)

Andrea Vance (Stuff): Lobbyists, cash and Voldemort: political donations laid bare by trial
Andrea Vance (Stuff): Cash for access? The price tag to schmooze New Zealand’s political leaders
Andrea Vance (Stuff): National says political donations reform will have ‘chilling effect’ on NZ elections
Tim Murphy (Newsroom): SFO details not one, but two NZ First-linked funds
Matthew Scott (Newsroom): NZ’s richest man explains donation to NZ First
Matthew Scott and Tim Murphy (Newsroom): NZ First trial: ‘It’s too scary, my brother’
Matthew Scott and Tim Murphy (Newsroom): Apartments developer gave NZ First $150,000
Catrin Owen (Stuff): Former NZ First MP ‘gobsmacked’ at cost of fundraising software
Tim Murphy and Matthew Scott (Newsroom): Three NZ First insiders shine light on party secrets
No Right Turn: The stench of corruption

Chris Trotter: Jacinda Ardern’s radical reshuffle
Claire Trevett: The warning to ministers as Jacinda Ardern signals a mother of all reshuffles (paywalled)
Thomas Coughlan (Herald): The lesson for National in Labour’s reshuffle (paywalled)
Tova O’Brien (Today FM): Impeccably polished was Jacinda Ardern as she wielded her bloody axe in her velvet-gloved hand
Rachel Smalley (Today FM): Labour’s reshuffle reminded us just how poorly so many Ministers have been performing
Pattrick Smellie (BusinessDesk): A cute ‘minor’ reshuffle: more to come (paywalled)
Tim Watkin (RNZ): Cabinet reshuffle ‘a fresh lick of paint for Labour’
Luke Malpass (Stuff): Jacinda Ardern rings in cautious Cabinet changes – but will they be enough?
Toby Manhire (Spinoff): Notes on a pretty darned big minor reshuffle
Mike Hosking (Herald): Reshuffle showed how short of talent the Government really is(paywalled)
Herald: Editorial: Cabinet shuffles former main players into back drawers (paywalled)
Martyn Bradbury (Daily Blog): Cabinet Reshuffle: Winners, Losers & Predictions
Michael Bassett: Shuffling de-faced cards: Jacinda’s “new” cabinet
Jo Moir (Newsroom): Jacinda Ardern’s not so minor Cabinet reshuffle
Thomas Coughlan (Herald): Jacinda Ardern proves she’s listening, but it’s the next reshuffle that matters (paywalled)
Richard Harman: The big losers in the Cabinet reshuffle (paywalled)
1News: Analysis: Ardern’s Cabinet reshuffle ‘neutralises’ 3 issues
John Roughan (Herald): Labour’s go-to guy Chris Hipkins proved his worth in Covid, now to lead police (paywalled)
Craig McCulloch (RNZ): ‘I enjoy a challenge’ – incoming Minister of Police Chris Hipkins dispels workload concerns
Leighton Heikell (Newshub): New Police Minister Chris Hipkins admits more needed to tackle crime, but tough talk won’t work
ODT: Editorial – Shifting the furniture
Herald: On the Tiles: Hayden Munro analyses Labour’s Cabinet reshuffle
Tom Peters (World socialist website): New Zealand: Change of police minister signals shift to the right
Stefan Dimitrof (Māori TV): Cabinet reshuffle injects new Māori blood into senior leadership
Tim Dower (Newstalk): Out of 65 MPs, where’s the inspiration?
Andrew Dickens (Newstalk): Cabinet reshuffle shows a lack of talent in Labour pool
Francesca Rudkin (Newstalk): A sensible reshuffle from the Prime Minister
Herald: Willie Jackson has grown up since Roast Busters broadcast furore, Women’s Refuge boss says
Greg Presland (The Standards): The Cabinet reshuffle
RNZ: Chris Hipkins as Police Minister may be ‘window dressing for the public’ – Mark Mitchell
Mark Quinlivan (Newshub): Cabinet reshuffle: Shifting the problem doesn’t always fix it, political commentator says
Brent Edwards (NBR): Cabinet reshuffle prompted by resignation and political pressure(paywalled)
Will Trafford (Māori TV): Māori in high-profile roles as Mallard, Faafoi exit parliament, PM reshuffles cabinet
Anna Whyte (1News): Cabinet reshuffle: The ups, the downs and the ins and outs
Thomas Manch (Stuff): Labour’s new Cabinet – who’s in, who’s out, as Trevor Mallard and Kris Faafoi resign
Rachel Sadler (Newshub): ACT, National decry Cabinet reshuffle, say it won’t change Government’s ‘lack of delivery’
Michael Neilson (Herald): Chris Hipkins new Police Minister as PM says Poto Williams ‘lost focus’
Bridie Witton (Stuff): PM Jacinda Ardern’s Cabinet reshuffle puts focus on combatting crime
Anneke Smith (RNZ): New Minister for Justice pledges ‘victim-centric’ approach
Lloyd Burr (Today FM): Is Poto Williams the right person to be Minister for Disability Issues?

Heather du Plessis-Allan (Newstalk): Should Trevor Mallard get rewarded for being a bad boy?
Heather du Plessis-Allan (Herald): European posting for Trevor Mallard wouldn’t be diplomatic (paywalled)
John MacDonald (Herald): Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern’s ‘outrageous’ reward for Trevor Mallard
Audrey Young (Herald): Believe it or not, Trevor Mallard will make a fine diplomat(paywalled)
Oscar Jackson (Today FM): ‘Are you calling the Prime Minister a liar?’ – Tova grills Winston Peters on Mallard ‘cover-up’
Emma Bernard (Herald): Te Tai Hauāuru MP Adrian Rurawhe nominated to be new Speaker of the House
Deena Coster (Stuff): MP Adrian Rurawhe on move to become next Speaker: ‘Biggest honour of my life’
Tom McRae (Newshub): Trevor Mallard retires: A look back at the long-time MP’s career in Parliament
Moana Ellis (Local Democracy Reporting): ‘A real honour’: Māori MP tipped for top constitutional role
Irra Lee (1News): Winston Peters says Trevor Mallard ‘unfit’ for diplomat job

Luke Malpass (Stuff): Ardern’s Government risks drifting. Does it have the ability to right the ship?
Peter Dunne (Newsroom): Labour needs to get on top of cost of living and law and order
Janet Wilson (Stuff): Jacinda Ardern is having her own Obama moment
Damien Grant (Stuff): The Ardern Government is in a death spiral with no hope… or is it?
Chris Trotter (Daily Blog): Mistrusting the majority
Rachel Sadler (Newshub): Kiri Allan hits out at ‘tokenistic use’ of te reo Māori after DoC email said she wanted English used in most circumstances
Karanama Ruru (Stuff): Kiri Allan says Doc email ending te reo Māori use in materials doesn’t reflect her view on language ‘tokenism’
Kate Green (Stuff): Price tag for Transmission Gully’s opening ceremony nears $337,000
Katie Doyle (Stuff): Children’s Commissioner slams select committee over Oranga Tamariki oversight Bill
André Chumko (Stuff): Contract of NZSO board chairperson not renewed after Taxpayers’ Union appointment
Tim Hurdle (Stuff): History has proven the problems and pitfalls of centralisation
Liz Davies (Herald): What is fuelling the racial backlash to co-governance? (paywalled)
Paul Goldsmith (Kiwiblog): Please ask before changing our democracy
Ryan Anderson (Stuff): Labour Party president Claire Szabó to stand down in November
Tom Kitchin (RNZ): Provincial Growth Fund rollout hindered by communication failings, review finds
Nicky Pellegrino (Women’s Day; Herald): MP Kiri Allan reflects on ‘rebirth’ followng cancer battle

David Farrar: Taxpayers’ Union Curia poll June 2022
Thomas Manch (Stuff): What the polls show: National nears pre-pandemic support, Labour’s reign vulnerable
Rosie Gordon (RNZ): MP’s use of parliamentary resources questioned amid mayoralty bid speculation
Toby Manhire (Spinoff): ‘50 years on they still haven’t been around the cabinet table’: Gareth Hughes on the Greens and Jeanette Fitzsimons
Erin Gourley (Stuff): MP Paul Eagle’s survey labelled ‘suspicious’ in light of mayoralty rumours
Mike Houlahan (ODT): Party planning at provincial AGM
Martyn Bradbury (Daily Blog): Winners & Losers in latest Taxpayers’ Union Curia Poll: NZ Political Spectrum is splintering
Herald: Kaumātua questions Christopher Luxon’s Māoridom guidance after potential tikanga breach
Bernard Orsman (Herald): Former NZ First MP Richard Prosser’s death: Sister recalls ‘bright light in our world’

Morgan Godfery (Guardian): New Zealand must engage in Pacific with humility, not entitlement
Jayden Holmes (Today FM): Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern invited to attend latest NATO meeting
Gordon Campbell: On the price tag for closer US military ties
Caitlin Rawling (Newshub): Defence Minister Peeni Henare makes it clear Pacific is number one priority for security
Kelvin McDonald (Māori TV): Defence Minister satisfied he has looked after Pacific nations
Katie Scotcher (RNZ): Jacinda Ardern first New Zealander to be invited to speak at NATO Leaders Summit
Audrey Young (Herald): Why Australia’s Penny Wong will be a good friend to NZ(paywalled)
Bridie Witton (Stuff): Australia’s foreign minister talks up ‘close friendship’ with New Zealand
Gordon Campbell: On the Penny Wong visit
Michael Neilson (Herald): Australia’s Foreign Minister Penny Wong putting Nanaia Mahuta ‘to shame’ with Solomons trip – Act
RNZ: Pacific security should be a matter for ‘Pacific family’ – Australian Foreign Minister Penny Wong
Thomas Manch (Stuff): As nuclear nations build weapons, New Zealand seeks an outright ban on the bomb
Thomas Manch (Stuff): Navy’s largest ship heads to major US-led RIMPAC military exercise, will spend months abroad
Tess McClure (Guardian): New Zealand to boost maritime security with Solomon Islands amid China focus on Pacific
Jeremy Wilkinson (Herald): ‘The same as how Australia treats the 501s’: Samoan deportee calls Government hypocritical
Sam Sachdeva (Newsroom): Wong turns the page as trans-Tasman ministers face regional challenges
Richard Harman: Mates once more (paywalled)
John Weekes (Herald): Russia-Ukraine war: Ron Mark describes war horror and ‘hypocrisy’ of New Zealand

Peter Dunne: Labour and National both “window dressing” on policing
Tim Dower (Newstalk): Nothing radical in National’s gang policy, but it’s something
Jonathan Killick (Stuff): ‘Blankets, not bollards’ the solution to Auckland’s ramraid problem
John MacDonald (Herald): Chris Luxon’s table thumping is just vote-catching noise
Rachel Smalley (Today FM): It’s time to take our country back from gangs
David Farrar: A very rare poll on a judicial decision
Dave Armstrong (Stuff): There are no miracle solutions for our gang problem
1News: New Police Minister Chris Hipkins comes out swinging at critics
RNZ: National leader Christopher Luxon seeks to rein in gangs promoting their lifestyle on social media
Jared Savage (Herald): Auckland gang shootings: Truce called between Killer Beez and Tribesmen after weeks of escalating gang war
Marty Sharpe (Stuff): Call made for international jurist to inquire into NZ’s judicial independence
John Bishop (Stuff): Have these firearm laws made us any safer? I don’t think so

David Farrar: We should oppose disproportionally sized electorates
Maiki Sherman (1News): Race for Māori electorate seats could be in for shakeup
Brigitte Morten (NBR): Switching between Māori and general roll no silver bullet(paywalled)

Damien Venuto (Herald): Fair Pay Agreements explained – business bogeyman or helping NZ’s poor?
Tamsyn Parker (Herald): The Great Resignation: Who is winning from the labour market squeeze? (paywalled)
Jacob Flanagan (Spinoff): Why everyone’s so mad with BusinessNZ over fair pay agreements
Conor Knell (Stuff): Tight labour market means a struggle to find staff
Cameron Smith (Herald): The Great Resignation ‘tidal wave’ hits NZ – what it means for workers (paywalled)
Damien Venuto (Herald): The four-day work week revolution – Is New Zealand being left behind?
Brent Edwards (NBR): Sledgehammer for a walnut: no agreement on fair pay agreements(paywalled)
Brent Edwards (NBR): The great divide on fair pay agreements (paywalled)
Hayden Donnell (RNZ): Media grapples with misinformation in Fair Pay fight

Tom Pullar-Strecker (Stuff): ‘GDP’ is down but should we worry?
Liam Dann (Herald): Amid the carnage one market just won’t fall … and it’s killing us(paywalled)
Steven Cowan: Adrian Orr: We’re all Maori capitalists now
Susan St John (Newsroom): The only trade-off that matters
Audrey Young (Herald): Reserve Bank Governor Adrian Orr shares Māori perspectives with central bankers
Heather du Plessis-Allan (Newstalk): Until you deal with inflation, you probably don’t want to be a tree

Liam Dann (Herald): GDP slump: Why we’re not halfway to recession … yet (paywalled)
Herald: Editorial: Hang in there Kiwis, the long cold winter is here (paywalled)
Herald: GDP falls: Finance Minister Grant Robertson says shrinking economy sign of difficult year ahead
Mike Hosking (Newstalk): Gloomy economic days are just beginning
Liam Dann (Herald): GDP preview: Did Omicron flatten economic growth? (paywalled)
Jenny Ruth (BusinessDesk): Government favours Fonterra’s commercial interests: MPI(paywalled)
Charlie Mitchell (Stuff): Fonterra asked the Government to change the law. In doing so, it risks increasing both pollution and milk prices
Brian Fallow (Herald): Clean, green — and a bit too pure (paywalled)
Bill Ralston (Listener/Herald): Talk is cheap, food isn’t – it’s time to hit supermarkets where it hurts (paywalled)
Jenée Tibshraeny (Herald): NZ all talk, no action on diversifying exports beyond China(paywalled)
Tom Pullar-Strecker (Stuff): MPs share ‘deep concern’ supermarkets may seek to profit from axing of covenants
Michael Neilson (Herald): MSD ramps up wage subsidy fraud investigations, nearly $800m recouped

Ian Powell (Stuff): Is the health system an electoral Sword of Damocles for Labour?
Rowan Quinn (RNZ): Hospital pressure: Counties Manukau DHB pays GPs up to $350 per patient for consultations
Francesca Rudkin (Newstalk): Healthcare will be a major election issue next year
Rachel Thomas (Stuff): Hospital short-staffing leads to Wellington woman waiting two days to deliver dead baby
Rachel Smalley (Today FM): This woman should not have died
RNZ: Nurses warn more lives at risk if health staffing crisis not addressed
Kethaki Masilamani (Newshub): Auckland’s medical school says Government won’t let them increase student numbers to fill dire shortages
Emma Russel (Herald): Nearly all NZ hospitals failing to meet Govt’s ED wait time targets
David Farrar: Targets for ED waiting times saves lives
Benn Bathgate (Stuff): Hospitals under pressure but health system ‘coping’, Health Minister Andrew Little says
Hannah Martin (Stuff): DHBs short medical specialists they need amid ‘dire’ staff shortages – survey
Hannah Martin (Stuff): Auckland Uni calls for more medical student places to help ease doctor shortage
Phil Pennington (RNZ): Waiting lists: Wellington Hospital scanning failures lead to big spends on private providers
Sophie Harris (Stuff): Minister Little reiterates confidence in health system despite Middlemore death
Heather du Plessis-Allan (Newstalk): I’m not sure the Health Minister’s office has its priorities right
Hannah Martin (Stuff): How New Zealand’s health system is changing
Ian Powell (BusinessDesk): Māori Health Authority – good call but not a magic bullet
Katie Todd (RNZ): GP crisis: About half NZ’s clinics not taking new patients
Julia Gabel (Herald): Nursing shortage: Nurses ‘broken’ while sector faces thousands of vacancies
Finn Blackwell (RNZ): Free doctors’ visits attempt to alleviate hospital strain
Ian Powell: Epiphanies and health system improvement
Ireland Hendry-Tennent (Newshub): Andrew Little says Government is doing everything it can to address nurse shortage as hospitals struggle with immense demand
RNZ: Limited GP access a concern for those with chronic diseases
1News: Review finds ACC privacy policies outdated, poorly understood
David Farrar: NZ needs a men’s health strategy
James Pocock (Herald): New Ngāti Kahungunu iwi Māori health board appointed ahead of national health reform

Derek Cheng (Herald): The Covid-19 hospital numbers that challenge the Government’s pro-equity claims (paywalled)
Derek Cheng (Herald): Another review, same old ‘under-prepared’ story (paywalled)
Marc Daalder (Newsroom): Covid isn’t over, it’s just getting started
Sam Sachdeva (Newsroom): The ‘noise’ behind NZ’s Covid testing failure
Adam Pearse (Herald): Health Ministry failures revealed in PCR Covid test debacle review
RNZ: Ministry of Health Delta response lacked pro-equity focus, review finds


  1. what level of shame and lunacy is this ? That our Politicians would stand with operatives of Bandera, in Kiev !
    Until the people of Ukraine and Europe rise against NATO warmonger power, we are lost in the mist.

  2. Labour is back to its old tricks. In the nineteen eighties neo-liberal economic reform was never in their election manifesto, yet it was delivered to the people of New Zealand in spades. Now they have made the Realm of New Zealand a partner of the NATO nuclear military alliance, and signaled the end of New Zealand’s nuclear free and “independent” foreign policy. In other words, they have introduced all the policies that Don Brash would have liked to bring in, but could not in the face of overwhelming public opposition.
    Jacinda Ardern argues that the NATO partnership dates back to the days of John Key’s government. She may well be right, but Key had to act surreptitiously. He would not have chosen to flagrantly defy the will of the people as Jacinda has.
    So now Labour is the primary threat to New Zealand’s security, prosperity, and (largely self-promoted and undeserved) international reputation as an honest broker and voice for peace. In 1990, after two terms of neo-liberal economics which were tough on New Zealand workers and New Zealand industries and had primarily benefited foreign investors, Labour naturally enough took a drubbing at the polls.
    A similar scenario will play out next year. Jacinda Ardern has decided to do the bidding of her imperial masters with cavalier disregard for the feelings of New Zealanders and the massive adverse consequences for the economy. She and her party will be quite properly punished for that. How many outside the ranks of TDB are gushing praise for “political rock star” Jacinda Ardern now?

Comments are closed.