David Robie also blogs at Café Pacific
From Pacific Media Watch
Global press freedom organisations have condemned the killing of two journalists in Gaza this week, who died in separate targeted airstrikes by the Israeli armed forces.
And protesters in Aotearoa New Zealand dedicated their week 77 rally and march in the heart of Auckland on Palestine Land Day to their memory, declaring “Journalism is not a crime”.
Hossam Shabat, a 23-year-old correspondent for the Al Jazeera Mubasher channel, was killed by an Israeli airstrike on his car in the eastern part of Beit Lahiya, media reports said.
- READ MORE: ‘Tell the world the truth,’ father tells dead son as Israel kills two journalists
- ‘Catastrophic’: Journalists say ethnic cleansing taking place in a news void in northern Gaza
- Other Gaza journalist reports
Video, reportedly from minutes after the airstrike, shows people gathering around the shattered and smoking car and pulling a body out of the wreckage.
Mohammed Mansour, a correspondent for Palestine Today television was killed earlier on Monday, reportedly along with his wife and son, in an Israeli airstrike on his home in south Khan Younis.
Ahlam Abuharbid, Shabat’s aunt from Beit Hanoun, Gaza, who migrated to New Zealand in 1986, said: “He dreamed of becoming a journalist and to tell the world the truth.
“But war doesn’t wait for dreams. He was only 23, and when the war began he left classes to give a voice to those who had none.”
Global media condemnation
In the hours after the deaths, the New York-based Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ) and Palestinian press freedom organisations released statements condemning the attacks.
“CPJ is appalled that we are once again seeing Palestinians weeping over the bodies of dead journalists in Gaza,” said Carlos Martínez de la Serna, CPJ’s programme director.
“This nightmare in Gaza has to end. The international community must act fast to ensure that journalists are kept safe and hold Israel to account for the deaths of Hossam Shabat and Mohammed Mansour.
“Journalists are civilians and it is illegal to attack them in a war zone.”
In a statement, the Israel Defence Forces (IDF) confirmed it had targeted and killed Shabat and Mansour and labelled them as “terrorists” — without any evidence to back their claim.
The IDF also said that it had struck Hamas and Islamic Jihad resistance fighters in Khan Younis, where Mohammed Mansour was killed.
In October 2024, the IDF had accused Shabat and five other Palestinian journalists working for Al Jazeera in Gaza of being members of the militant arm of Hamas and Islamic Jihad.
Israeli claims denied
Al Jazeera and Shabat denied Israel’s claims, with Shabat stating in an interview with the CPJ that “we are civilians … Our only crime is that we convey the image and the truth.”
In its statement condemning the deaths of Shabat and Mansour, the CPJ again called on Israel to “stop making unsubstantiated allegations to justify its killing and mistreatment of members of the press”.
The CPJ estimates that more than 170 journalists have been killed in Gaza since the war began in October 2023, making it the deadliest period for journalists since the organisation began gathering data in 1992.
Al Jazeera Published their FINAL Interview with Journalist Hossam Shabat
He spoke about the challenges of working while being targeted pic.twitter.com/tgcs3BE1z8
— Ryan Rozbiani (@RyanRozbiani) March 28, 2025
However, the Palestinian Journalists Syndicate says it believes the number is higher and, with the deaths of Shabat and Mansour, 208 journalists and other members of the press have been killed over the course of the conflict.
Under international law, journalists are protected civilians who must not be targeted by warring parties.
Israel has killed more than 50,000 Palestinians, mostly women and children, in its genocide in the blockaded enclave since October 7, 2023.
Vigil for Palestinian journalists in Gaza. Video: Aslam Qureshi
The Israeli carnage has reduced most of the Gaza to ruins and displaced almost the entire 2.3 million population, while causing a massive shortage of basic necessities.
The International Criminal Court (ICC) issued arrest warrants last November for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and his former defence minister Yoav Gallant for war crimes and crimes against humanity in Gaza.
Israel also faces a genocide case at the International Court of Justice (ICJ) for its war on the enclave.
Targeting of innocents, including innocent journalists, is a war crime. It is unacceptable just as Hamas’s murders and sexual abuses of civilians – both Jewish and Palestinian – is a war crime. Anyone from either “side” guilty of such things must go. Gazans marching in the streets against both Hamas and Netanyahu get it. So do Israelis protesring against Netanyahu and demanding the return of hostages. There are millions of innocent Palestinians and Jews in the region who need to live dignified safe lives as neighbours in their own states. Any other solution by definition would in fact create a genocide which is utterly intolerable.
“His story lives on” in the number of people he killed while he was a Hamas sniper. The tiniest amount of research when pulling up his name will show the extent in which this propaganda serves to disguise the roles of so called journalists, ambulance drivers etc. who are no more than terrorists taking a bit of time out between missions. I thought Dr Robie was a strong advocate of independent media yet he has been blindsided once again by another Al Jazeera biased report.
“I thought Dr Robie was a strong advocate of independent media”. Nope. Just another Far Lefter.
‘Global press freedom organisations have condemned the killing of two journalists in Gaza this week, who died in separate targeted airstrikes by the Israeli armed forces.’
Of course they do, right on wokies. No mention of Uday Rabie of course, a 22 year old Palestinian tortured to death by Hamas after critising the group. That’s what a real humanitarian looks like. Not some middle class twit on social media.
Comments are closed.