Researchers appalled at alcohol report – University of Auckland
An alcohol industry funded report that claims alcohol is not a cause of violence has been debunked by researchers in New Zealand and Australia.
The report (published in March 2015) from British anthropologist, Dr Anne Fox, focused on the causes of violence and anti-social behaviour in night-time entertainment areas in New Zealand and Australia.
Dr Fox claimed that alcohol consumption was not a cause of violence, but instead, that beliefs regarding acceptable behaviour when drinking were to blame.
She recommended that children were educated regarding proper behaviour when drinking, parents were taught how to talk to their children about alcohol, and the public educated about acceptable drinking behaviour via media campaigns.
Researchers Nicki Jackson from the University of Auckland and Professor Kypros Kypri from the University of Newcastle in Australia, were appalled at the report’s recommendations.
They have published a critique in the latest issue of the international peer-reviewed journal Addiction, addressing the key claims with reference to the scientific evidence.
Ms Jackson says that “these types of recommended approaches may modify a person’s knowledge or attitude, but rarely their behaviour.”
“The report is highly selective in the research used to support its recommendations. It fails to acknowledge the huge body of evidence concerning effective strategies for reducing violence, such as earlier cessation of sales in licensed premises,” she says.
“Despite failing to meet even basic standards of research the report cannot be ignored, because the findings are being used by the alcohol industry to overturn licensing decisions and in submissions on public policy,” says Professor Kypri.
“We believe this was simply an effort by the alcohol industry to raise doubts about the existing evidence, which is strong,” he says. “Employing ‘merchants of doubt’ is a strategy used by the fossil fuel industry to subvert science on global warming.”
“This report should be viewed in the same way.”
“these types of recommended approaches may modify a person’s knowledge or attitude, but rarely their behaviour.”
Disagree. Of course education and environment have a lot to do with it, and we do have a very rough culture regarding physical violence in New Zealand, and I would venture to say in Australia, also.
Having said that, this study is obviously wrong also. To blame it simply on that is ridiculous. Alcohol obviously plays a big role in violence in our society. Alcohol doesn’t “make” you violent, people are violent naturally, alcohol simply inhibits our impulse control. But it definitely does do that. Which obviously increases incidents of violence.