Similar Posts

10 Comments

  1. “Winnie Madikizela-Mandela wasn’t perfect. She was flawed.”

    You’re right about that Hone. But I guess we can forgive someone who murdered children in the most gruesome and agonising way possible as long as they fought the good fight huh?

    And as for these crimes only being “alleged” – that certainly wasn’t what the Truth and Reconciliation Commission found to be the case.

  2. It’s just that she also murdered people, had some poor souls driven to mine shafts and dropped in alive. She wasn’t convicted of these crimes or the killing of Stompi, her most famous murder, a child. That she did these things is not disputed, witnesses confessed and Tutu made her apologize. She also enriched herself, she was powerful and people needed a symbol like you describe here. Her crimes wete forgiven for the public role she assumed, and the sacrifices she made for being the face of ANC but this role and power corrupted her. Only corrupt people can commit crimes like that.. The brutality she encouraged and participated in is a degree beyond politicking and if she was an ordinary person not Mandela’s wife she would not have hot away with it.

  3. Yeah Hone, as other have already noted, you really should have researched Winnie better before writing this piece. Her heinous crimes can’t be easily glossed over, despite her good deeds.

  4. the comments above demonstrate Hone’s point–it is easy for the safe and comfortable to judge others caught up in one of the worst 20th century human tragedies

    ending Apartheid was never going to be pretty, up against a brutal regime that shot school children, peaceful/passive resistance was never going to win that struggle

    Winnie’s positive contributions should be remembered not just the occasions when she went too far, there is nothing worse than a scab, undermining or selling out the people, so violent actions should be considered in context

    but really the number of Safas that have come out of the woodwork in NZ online forums to chime in with criticism of Winnie show what some of the critics agenda is–they still resent the ending of Apartheid and will remain filthy racists to the end

Comments are closed.