Similar Posts

- Advertisement -

24 Comments

  1. Cue pundits (Mi-cockskin, Soper & the rest) whimpering… “unfair to rich fat cats with 7 houses”…and blog commenters…but but…Labour won’t go there…

    Was weighing up TPM vs Greens for my valuable vote–now I have decided.

    The bigger the vote TPM & Greens get, the more likely this policy could be implemented. It is always better to vote for something you support than a grudging lesser evil vote.

  2. Two points.

    First: The Maori Party are already having an effect. To address the cost of iiving crisis, the Maori Party are demanding that GST be removed from food.

    Second: Labour fucks it up. Reluctantly dragged kicking and screaming part way there.

    Taking GST only off fruit and vegetables, as Labour is allegedly proposing, delivers the smallest benefit to the families stressed by the cost of living crisis.
    While delivering the smallest benefit to the family budget, overseas experience indicates that taking GST off only fruit and vegetables has proved to be confusing and overly complicated leading to expensive litigation and bureaucratic oversight.

    As Stuff.co.nz points out, while taking GST off all food though the simplest thing to do, with the biggest benefits to the household budget, it would need to be balanced by, wait for it, taxing the rich. Something Chris Hipkins is dead against.

    https://www.stuff.co.nz/business/money/300937406/how-much-difference-would-removing-gst-from-fruit-and-veg-really-make

    1. The idea of dropping GST off fruit and vege alone is insane.

      It’s like they’re trying to split the difference between appealing to people who are angry at the idea that them poors won’t have to pay GST on KFC, and some small couture of Wellington fruitarians.

    2. Heres the test. If you can eat it then no gst. 15% off food helps everyone in a cost of living crisis where food price increased 20%

  3. Love it! Was talking – very grimly – with friends about who to vote for this year and I said I’d check the actual policies on offer but whoever took GST off food and made cannabis legal would have my vote. Reading my mind…

  4. That’s JT anchoring his post election negotiating position. Labour just removing GST from food wont cut it with JT.

  5. ‘Labour is here to manage capitalism (and let the free market do the rest), the Greens are here to try and add the cost of pollution into the price (and let the free market do the rest) while the Māori Party are actually here to disrupt the Free Market!’

    Great statement above.

    Absolutely, Te Pati Maori all the way.
    A great policy except I think they should have a financial transactions tax in here as well.

    1. Ditch GST and bring in a comprehensive FTT tax on all transactions would be better than just taking gst off food.

  6. With GST a company can then claim back expenses. So if a company earns %100 from gst it will not be the full amount the consumer gets back. The company can then deduct expenses so if their expenses are $40.00 they can claim the gst off that which will mean that they pay less than $100.

    Just saying. But it is a good policy

  7. My (Maori) wahine was unsure who to vote for, till she saw this policy today. Now she is clear: TPM all the way. She wont be the only one among Maori who now have added reason to vote this year. It’s genuine progressive tax policy for a change.

    As an aside, if you dont have a TPM or Greens candidate in your local electorate, you can STILL vote TPM or Greens with your party vote (which is th eone tht actually decides the overall parliamentary make-up)

  8. One sentence for absolute failure – bureaucracy costs and business profiteering opportunity.

  9. The Maori party is the only party that would become more powerful the less party votes it gets by causing an electorate overhang.

    Imagine if Maori voters gave the greens their party votes and the Maori party their electorate votes, they’d cause a 2-4 seat overhang and make it impossible for anyone to govern without the Maori party.

    It’d be utterly hilarious to watch the rage if national and Labour get 51% of non wasted votes but labour/green/Maori govern on 49% due to MMP proportional overhangs.

  10. I bought a house 40 years ago for $100,000. It is now worth $1.3 million. When I retire, I intend to go overseas for 7-8 months to travel. Will I have to pay $400,000 tax?

  11. TPM Policy will kill development of any new company
    Rod Drury set up Xero.
    The value of the shares increased and he was a major shareholder. During the development phase the company was burning through cash and not making a profit
    The only way Drury could have paid the tax would have been by selling up to 8% of his shares per annum. He would have lost control of his own company very quickly
    Or he could have gone offshore and NZ would have got no tax at all and fewer high skilled well paying jobs
    I am curious how much you think entrepreneurs will pay per annum to stay in NZ ?

Comments are closed.