Similar Posts

- Advertisement -

11 Comments

  1. Our of idle curiosity, just how might New Zealand “urgently decouple economically from China.”?

  2. Well in terms of primary produce exports having more agricultural diversity would help. The Dairy and Beef sector basically wanted us to hold out on a deal with the EU at the expense of the other NZ producers that got something. Holding out for something that will never happen. It’s all very well producing mountains of milk powder and beef but if major markets are essentially closed off what’s the point?Agriculture needs more balance. If we can’t break into these markets with cow power grow alternative crops that can.

  3. More hyperemotional nonsense from Bradbury. He is forgetting that China is aggressive and has been aggressive only within its own boundaries (apart from a spat with Vietnam) – remembering that it considers Taiwan to be part of China. Yes, it is not a wonderful democratic regime, but that is their own business – by all means make protesting noises, but don’t get carried away by ones self-rightsciousness. That is how international relations work, or rather should work: meanwhile the US wants to impose their brand of everything on everyone. As to Xinjiang, the US was meddling in there and training terrorists long ago. We can believe the worst of what is happening there, but how do you disentangle truth from Western propaganda. China suffered massively under the heel of Imperial British gunboat diplomacy, and has made huge improvements against all odds. New Zealand must look to its own interests, and I believe that they do not reside with an over cosy relationship with anyone, least of all the US. We need to be carefully realistic.

  4. China is looking at technology that Amazon developed and that supermarkets in New Zealand have already implemented? How thoroughly dystopian, clearly their functioning society is much worse than our entirely failed state.

  5. I agree there are a “bewildering amount of apologists for China in NZ”. Some of these apologists from the left and right seem to view morals/ethics as optional extras that can be dispensed with for ‘realpolitik’ or financial reasons.

    Maybe. Yet what if the unethical behaviour is a ‘tell’ or giveaway that the state/leader is psychopathic? Becoming financially dependent on psychopaths doesn’t end well. Imagine a potential partner – steady job and income; but wants to control your phone, puts GPS trackers on their family’s cars, and some of their ex’s disappeared. I suggest running very far away!

    Maybe ethics can be a practical guide to survival. Maybe ignoring genocide and 1984 surveillance isn’t so tough or smart after all.

  6. From our cave-dwelling forebears to today’s electronic entrepreneurs the use of devices to “persuade” is as old as time itself. And if the Chinese have developed a new way of pre-determining a political outcome that seems Orwellian, so too was what Cambridge Analytica did for Trump and for the outcome of the Brexit vote, a short while ago?

  7. The problem is this:
    Europe: Protectionist
    North America: Protectionist
    India: Protectionist
    South America: Protectionist
    Japan: Protectionist

    Because of capital accumulation, every country on the planet wants to be an exporting nation. None want to be a net importing nation.

    The UK want to export, The US want to export, China, Russia, Japan all want to be export nations and run a trading surplus in their favour compared to their competitors.

    In the old days of the British Empire this trade imbalance between countries was imposed by force.
    The economies of the colonies were not allowed to develop manufacturing, their only exports were raw materials taken back to England worked into finished goods and exported back to the colonies. Buying cheap and selling dear, is the capitalist dream, the British Empire did this very successfully at the point of gun.

    For a small capitalist country, New Zealand has been extremely lucky. We gain over $20 billion in export earnings from China, while only buying about $10 billion off China. This is because of two things: 1/ NZ is such a small country and economy a trade imbalance in NZ’s favour is small potatoes to the Chinese
    2/ We had something the Chinese badly wanted and needed – baby formula. As China industrialised many working mothers were called into the factories and the grandparents were left to raise the babies.

    But on the world stage competition between the rival political economic blocs is are starting to come to a head.
    In the tussle for control of trade routes raw materials and markets between the large rival capitalist powers, New Zealand is being forced to pick a side. It won’t be pretty.

Comments are closed.