Shane Te Pou – The māmā no one listened to

I’m always behind on the news from home. Time difference, a busy life, and things slip past me. Most of the time my TikTok feed is rubbish, but every now and then it gets one right, and this time it served up a clip from Gone By Lunchtime, the Spinoff politics show with Toby Manhire, Annabelle Lee-Mather and Ben Thomas. So I watched the whole episode, properly. It went to air in mid-September. It’s now October.
Like a lot of us, I’d filed the Phillips case away as a story with an ending. So I went and read the independent inquiry. I was wrong about the ending.
It was led by Justice Simon Moore KC. He found Police and Oranga Tamariki underplayed, minimised or overlooked what Tom Phillips was doing by isolating his kids, and that concerns from the children’s mother and her whānau were often written off as a parenting dispute. A parenting dispute. That’s what they called a mum saying her kids were in danger.
Mihingarangi Forbes and Annabelle Lee-Mather had been telling us this for years on Mata Reports on RNZ. They stayed with the kids’ māmā when no one was watching, when no one was listening.
Phillips took the children into the bush for 18 days in September 2021, then again in December, and stayed hidden for nearly four years, until he was killed in a shootout with Police. Two chances to get it right.
Oranga Tamariki never met with her, and never treated her concerns as a formal report of concern. In October 2021, between the two disappearances, it told the Family Court the children were “completely fine”, and didn’t mention the worries of Police or the maternal family. A sister swore an affidavit about abuse, and the inquiry found it appeared no one read it.
The gone by lunchtime hosts asked whether we have what’s called an “accountability sink”. That’s a system built so that when something goes horribly wrong, no one really wants to own it. The only people who did were the mum and the sisters, up against huge institutions with an army of managers and media minders. David and Goliath. In the Bible, David wins. In real life, it’s usually Goliath.
A senior Oranga Tamariki social worker even wondered whether the narrative around the maternal whānau changed how the children’s sister was seen. The report agreed. The mother is Māori. Phillips and his family are Pākehā. A calm dad gets believed. A scared Māori māmā gets called difficult. That’s what unconscious bias looks like, and institutions have to cast it aside.
And I wonder whether it worked the other way too. After his death, social media filled with comments painting Phillips as a wronged father fighting a Family Court that discriminates against dads. He was no hero. He took those kids from their sisters, their mother, their whānau, their schools, and left them in cold, wet, unsafe conditions through winters in the bush. That’s not a loving father. That’s a man who only thought about himself.
A Spinoff Bulletin piece ran under the headline “police get defensive”. That’s the feeling I got too. To be fair, the Commissioner called the missed 2023 sighting a “significant missed opportunity”. But he also said Police “acted commendably” in making their report of concern. Yet a woman had Phillips in her car, took his photo, and nobody turned up. That sounds like a force justifying itself, not reflecting.
And here’s something else that sticks in my throat. Police had a formal agreement with a production company to film a Netflix documentary on the hunt. On the morning Phillips was shot, they texted the production company’s boss at about quarter past six. RNZ reported the kids’ mum wasn’t told until after eight. She’d said she didn’t consent to the documentary, and says she was told police didn’t need her permission. I can’t tell you who got more phone calls. But I know who got the first text.
Here’s what I can’t get past. Nobody has paid for this. The Police Commissioner and the Oranga Tamariki chief executive both said they haven’t offered their resignations, and no one in their agencies has been held accountable. The inquiry named no one, and can’t impose penalties. An apology isn’t a consequence.
In October 2021, one of the sisters asked Oranga Tamariki whether it would be held responsible if the children went missing again. Surely someone has to put up their hand and say, I got it wrong. And surely someone, ultimately, loses their job. When children’s lives are put at risk for four years and basic processes aren’t followed, there has to be a price, and a big one. It’s how the next person in that chair learns what the job carries.
One more thing: public media. Work like Mata Reports takes time, trust and money. Public media gives it room to stay on a story after the cameras leave. That’s every New Zealand taxpayer chipping in.
And a word for Mihi and Annabelle. Ironically, Mihi is no longer on RNZ’s Saturday Morning show. But what she and Annabelle have done on this story only strengthens their name. Dogged. Thorough. Passionate about their craft. They remind us what journalism is for, and why the craft of it matters.
Thank you both. And to the kids’ māmā and the sisters, my heart goes out to you. That mum was never quiet. We just weren’t listening.
Shane Te Pou is a political commentator and Māori broadcaster. It is TDBs privilege to platform his political analysis for the Election.





Well said.
Yes, the children’s mother and sisters deserve some sort of recognition, somehow.
Where’s some generous person with a large house, in a nice holiday location, where the family could have a decent holiday together and can OT and the FC leave them alone to be a family again.
Anyone with half a brain would seem ‘difficult’ if they tried to get sense out of a govt. agency that would never admit it was wrong. We get the impression Cat is still having to justify herself to the family court.
The little we saw of her, she seemed very level-headed and patient, endlessly patient.
p.s. Whoever signed off on the documentary idea should be fired immediately and we’re very disappointed and disturbed that it hasn’t happened. Any one of us could find ourselves the subject of a documentary if certain people have their way. Cat and her family didn’t ask for such notoriety. There is no justification for that intrusion into their privacy.
Yes so true. That poor mother and sisters beating their head against a brick wall for years and so many aspersions cast against the mother throughout. It’s a wonder she has survived. Clearly that father should have been arrested after abandoning the car on the beach and abducting the children, the FIRST time he did it. How the hell he got a second chance to do the same thing is beyond belief and a complete tragedy. The Netflix documentary is literally the last straw of disrespect to the mother and yet another example of her powerlessness being ground into her face by the establishment which is so completely bizarre in its nightmarishness Kafka would tip his hat if it were fiction. But it was real, not some made up story. You are right heads should roll here instead all you get a mutterings and everything swept under the carpet. Disgusting. Where is the justice for the mother and sisters, let alone the children who endured god knows what in their most formative years.