Online Gambling Across the Tasman: What New Zealand Can Learn From Australia’s Offshore Problem

Whatever happens on election night, the next government will inherit a policy question that rarely makes the leaders’ debates: what to do about online gambling. It is not a glamorous topic. It does not fit neatly on a billboard. But it touches on almost everything the campaign has been about, from the cost of living and community health to tax revenue and who gets to profit from New Zealanders’ spare dollars. And the best case study for getting it right, or wrong, sits just across the ditch.
Australia: Prohibition That Never Quite Worked
Australia’s approach to online casinos has been, on paper, one of the strictest in the developed world. The Interactive Gambling Act makes it illegal for operators to offer online casino games such as pokies and roulette to people in Australia. Online sports betting is legal and heavily advertised, but the casino side of the market is supposed to be closed.
In practice, that has not stopped Australians from playing. Offshore operators licensed in places like Curaçao or Malta continue to market to Australian customers, and search interest tells its own story. Queries such as Zoome Casino Australia and dozens of similar brand-plus-country searches show that a large number of Australians are actively looking for offshore online casino sites, regardless of what Canberra says.
The regulator, ACMA, has responded by ordering internet providers to block hundreds of illegal gambling websites. But blocking is a game of whack-a-mole. Mirror domains appear overnight, with a new number or suffix attached to the old brand name, and the money still flows offshore. Australians who play on these sites have no local consumer protection, no domestic dispute resolution and contribute nothing to the public purse.
New Zealand: A Different Path
New Zealand has historically sat in an odd position. It has been illegal for overseas operators to advertise online casinos here, but not illegal for New Zealanders to play on overseas sites. The result was similar to Australia’s: a large, untaxed, largely unregulated market running in parallel with the TAB and Lotto, the only domestic online gambling options.
The Online Casino Gambling Bill set out to change that by creating a licensing system with a limited number of licences, rules on advertising and obligations around harm minimisation. Supporters argue it brings an existing activity into the light, where it can be taxed and controlled. Critics, including public health advocates, warn that licensing will normalise online pokies and lead to an explosion of advertising aimed at exactly the communities already hit hardest by gambling harm.
Both sides have a point, and that is why the details matter.
Who Pays the Price
Gambling harm in New Zealand is not evenly distributed. Pokie machines in pubs and clubs have long been concentrated in lower-income neighbourhoods, and research consistently shows Māori and Pasifika communities bear a disproportionate share of the harm. Moving that harm onto phones, available 24 hours a day, without the friction of walking into a venue, is not a small risk.
At the same time, pretending the offshore market does not exist protects no one. A person losing their rent money on an unlicensed site gets no help from the operator, no mandatory limits and no route to complain. A regulated system can at least require identity checks, deposit limits, self-exclusion tools and proper funding for treatment services.
Lessons From Across the Ditch
If New Zealand wants to avoid Australia’s mistakes, a few lessons stand out:
- Prohibition without enforcement is just a gift to offshore operators. If the law cannot actually stop the activity, it ends up exporting the profits and keeping the harm.
- Advertising is the real battleground. Australia’s flood of sports betting ads has created a public backlash and repeated calls for bans. New Zealand has the chance to set strict limits from day one.
- Revenue must be ringfenced. If the state is going to collect tax from online gambling, a meaningful share should go directly to harm prevention and community services, not disappear into the general budget.
- Harm minimisation should be mandatory, not voluntary. Deposit limits, cooling-off periods and cross-operator self-exclusion work best when every licensed operator has to offer them.
- Data should be public. Regulators should publish regular figures on spending, problem gambling rates and enforcement, so voters can judge whether the system is working.
The Political Question
Gambling policy has a habit of crossing party lines in unexpected ways. Some on the right see licensing as a sensible, market-based fix. Some on the left see it as a moral failure that hands vulnerable people over to global corporations. Others see it as pragmatism: the activity is happening anyway, so the state might as well regulate and tax it.
Whoever forms the next government will have to decide where they stand, and how hard they are willing to push on advertising, tax and harm prevention. The pressure from the industry will be intense. The pressure from communities hurt by gambling should be just as loud.
Beyond the Ballot Box
Ultimately, online gambling is a test of whether policy can keep up with technology. Smartphones have made it possible to place a bet or spin a reel anywhere, anytime. Laws written for a world of physical venues and printed tickets are struggling to cope. Australia’s experience shows that simply saying no is not enough. New Zealand has a rare chance to design something better, but only if it learns from what has already gone wrong next door.






