If TOP go to the Right they will be destroyed in the 2029 election

Lot of noise from the establishment Left criticising TOP and claiming that they will side with NZF, ACT and National.
Couple of thoughts.
First up, I’m a working class socialist so I am NOT voting for TOP, but TDB was the first to recognise that TOP would break the 5% threshold this year and that’s why I’ve written so many blogs on TOP and why I have had Qiulae on The Bradbury Group more than anyone else.
I don’t even think the mainstream media in NZ covered when TOP broke the 5% threshold in the first Roy Morgan Poll.
TOP appeals to second generation migrant communities who want to be Kiwis yet feel alienated by the major parties, Qiulae’s optimism appeals to them and TOP policy appeals to all those Gen Xers who don’t own property. They are too rich to vote Labour and not Māori enough to vote Green.
Now.
I have been fortunate enough to talk to Qiulae privately many times and here is my assessment of her and TOP.
They are disrupters and believe in the reform they are promoting.
The difference between TOP and National, ACT and NZF is that they actually take climate change seriously, and it is essentially this issue that I believe makes it impossible for them to find common ground with National, ACT and NZF who at heart are all climate denial parties.
National is so in the pocket of the Big Polluters that they take secret direction when passing laws FFS.
That is an anathema to TOP.
In the background of TOP you have former National MP Jackie Blue who was scathing on the Coalition Governments pay parity kneecapping and Ian Lees-Galloway who is a former Labour MP.
Also look at the analysis of where TOP are picking up support is from Green and Labour supporters who want the Party to go with the Left, not the Right.
If the establishment Left don’t like the rise of TOP, perhaps they should reflect on the current state of the NZ Left?
Te Pati Māori ripped itself to pieces with internal strife.
The Greens spent most of the last 3 years fighting their own internal woke factions.
Labour’s election policy is, ‘we are slightly less cruel than National’.
Look. I am going to use my 2 votes for either Labour, Greens or TPM so TOP ain’t my block of cheese, but the best outcome for the Left is a Labour/Green/TPM/TOP Government if we can’t get a Labour/Green/TPM Government.
To ensure TOP don’t rob TPM of any political leverage, the Kakariki Alliance between Greens/TPM must be in effect to guarantee the united negotiating front from Greens/TPM so TOP don’t simply push out TPM.
I want National, NZF and ACT out of power and if TOP can be allies in building a better NZ, I welcome them to the fold.
What can the Left offer TOP if Labour + Green + TPM + TOP = 51%?
In think there are 3 very quick wins that could be offered to TOP.
1 – Free Public Transport for Students, the disabled, beneficiaries and pensioners with everyone else using Labours Public Transport Fare Cap.
2 – UBI for all Tertiary students.
3 – Feasibility study on Land tax. The current land tax proposal would see $17 500 from a million dollar valued land, (which works if UBI is used for everyone) but if you are only limiting UBI to tertiary students, that land tax is simply too high, but if if was .01 instead of 1.75, $1750 extra annually is far more palatable than $17 500.
TOP could gain a UBI for tertiary students, free public transport for everyone not covered by Labour fare cap and a Land Tax.
Those are wins TOP could bank and build upon.
They are also wins Labour, Greens and TPM could live with.
If TOP decide however to hitch their wagon to National, they will see first hand how tribal politics really is because National will not and can not provide TOP with the climate change disruption they are promising, and dashed electoral hopes will sink TOP raising above 5% again.
If TOP go to the Right they will be destroyed in the 2029 election.
Independent Media is more important than ever, especially in the lead up to the Election. TDB is the largest Left Wing Blog in NZ and we have been operating for 13 years. We get zero funding from NZonAir and we don’t have no rich backers. If you can donate please do so here or directly into our account –12-3065-0133561-56





” The Teal party was created by Gareth Morgan who you could never claim was someone who had so much money he got bored and decided to set up a political party just for the hell of it was in any way an advocate for progressive policies that would address the huge inequality that when publicized frightened the financially well off comfortable residents and their manufactured conscience.
” If TOP go to the Right they will be destroyed in the 2029 election ”
They are already dead in the water !
The Teal party is a blip in the 2020s cycle of political turmoil. Like Peter the prostitute of the United party ( early 2000s ) who would go with anyone who furthered his own political interests and benefits then fell from favour once people worked out he was a complete waste of oxygen folded when he was no longer important.
The Teal party was created by Gareth Morgan who you could never claim was someone who had so much money he got bored and decided to set up a political party just for the hell of it.
TOP is the recipient of people who vote RIGHT not left and are in denial that by voting Teal they will bring the Nasty Natz back from the brink and provide the comfortable conservatism they are desperate for.
” the political voice of the urban professional class, packaged as common sense ”
” At the end of the day, TOP represents a very modern brand of progressive managerialism. It speaks directly to high-earning, socially liberal professionals who are frustrated by the present political gridlock but who have too much skin in the game to ever challenge the underlying structures of a market-driven economy. They want to fix the system’s rough edges, not overthrow it ”
https://nzagainstthecurrent.blogspot.com/2026/10/the-opportunities-party-spreadsheet.html
The Opportunities Party … Oh my God. How naff. They should be labeled the Perfumed Bullshit Party. They’re just another twinkling-bauble distraction party born of roger douglas’s neoliberal clockwork crime spree. It was right wing natzo opportunists ‘back in the day’ who founded the * spritely pig sticker and his cavalcade of snuffling snouts still found jostling around the barren trough.
Vote for Chloe Swarbrick. She’s encouraging greed to be overcome by common sense and good intentions. A rare thing.
TOP would be well advised to study the history of the Social Credit Party in 1981 and !982. Due to widespread dissatisfaction with Muldoon they were on a roll, winning over 20% of the vote in the 1981 election. Due to FPP voting this only earned them two seats but this was enough to put them in a strong position in the parliament. They ran on a policy of using their balance of power responsibly to ensure good govt – National needed their two votes to pass legislation. The big issue of the time was building the Clyde Dam – this divided opinions and the significant proportion of the country was against it. Initially, so was Social Credit, but Muldoon leaned on them as only he could, and they folded, voting for the dam to proceed. That was the effective end of Social Credit, their popularity plummeted and next election they were gone. I foresee the same happening to TOP if they support the three headed gorgon.
If you’re a lefty you want TOP to usurp NZ First as the the centrist party.
If you’re TOP you’ve seen what happens to the Green’s who have no option other than Labour for a coalition partner – and you try to give the impression that you might go right so you have some bargaining power.
Personally I don’t think they could stomach being part of this coalition – and Martyn is right, if they go right at this election it’ll end them. But they have to look like they might do it
I no longer trust Wong’s motives. Has she been introduced by the RW to distract us while giving the Left false hope. If so, then Hipkins is not falling for it. It’s more sensible than coming out and making a definite decision. Luxon could yet have to eat his words. Of course he would do an about-face if it meant he could go back in – perish the thought! There is nothing wrong with most of TOP’s policies and they certainly align more with the Left than the Right. Yes, going with National could bring about the demise of TOP.
TOP is backed by big money and it is obvious they are falling over themselves to be excepted by National. Why would any Party that want to advance their cause hook up with a bunch of tired losers with yesterday’s policies
If TOP go with the right they would be 10 times smarter than the dumb Greens. By forever hitching themselves to Labour and by become a radical social justice party,the Greens have lost their true purpose. They could have been part of govt long ago, and had some of their environment policies realised, had they been a bit more pragmatic and practical. What a stupid bunch.
No one wants the Greens especially Labour but National would have gone with them in2018 to stay in power
If TOP go with the right they would be 10 times smarter than the dumb Greens. By forever hitching themselves to Labour and by become a radical social justice party,the Greens have lost their true purpose. They could have been part of govt long ago, and had some of their environment policies realised, had they been a bit more pragmatic and practical. What a stupid bunch.
Opportunity need to present as centrist for the ‘horsetrading’ that will occur after the election. There is nothing wrong with what they are doing….it’s called politics. The week after Nov 7th will be one of the most interesting in NZ political history
This is exactly what I needed today 🙌 Really appreciate you posting this
Opp are trying to have their cake and eat it. The wishy washy, tootsie game with the coalition parties has put me off completely. I get the sense that behind the veil of progressive, left-wing policies – these are pure career politicians looking for a break and they’ll take any offer that comes their way. As hard as it is too see policy alignment between the coalition and Opp I now think they are a serious risk for the left. The polls indicate it is Labour that is losing votes to Opp, not National.
Why would anyone involved care? You seem to be assuming that the supposed ‘leader’ cares about a sustainable political party, politics, New Zealanders, etc etc.
No, she was employed on a six month contract, extensible by three years if she managed to pull it off for her (mainly foreign freaks like Brian Cartmell) bosses. There was never any expectation of the job lasting past that.
For a little perspective.
We know what National, ACT and NZ First have in store for us if they triumph – gang rape might be an accurate term.
We are not sure what TOP will do, but common sense suggests they will be either a moderating force on the right wing loons, or more hopefully a progressive force in a coalition with Labour and the Greens.
Either way, they have a positive influence, I believe.
https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/national-winks-to-opportunity-promising-to-review-bottom-trawling-and-create-new-waiheke-reserve/UNKWHWZZJCI662OX47YAZCP5SY/
Won’t happen Martyn. TOP definitely going right and Luxon has already weakened to them as we all New he would.
What Op are selling, apart from a now shelved UBI and Land tax, is so similar to Labour/Greens why would anyone on the Left bother. If Op attract votes from the Left and get over 5% and join National or get just 4.9% and fail then either way the Left have been shafted.