Ian Powell – Will National and/or Labour ‘fix’ Aotearoa New Zealand’s health system

In an earlier life Kathy Spencer was a deputy director-general in the Ministry of Health. This included some of the time I was Executive Director of the Association of Salaried Medical Specialists.
The nature of our quite different roles meant that there was little interaction. My rather vague recollection was that she was principled, considered and intelligent.
Since that time she has done other interesting things including in the Accident Compensation Commission and Treasury.

Kathy Spencer: an experienced and perceptive health commentator
In recent years she has been a regular columnist in the mainstream media, usually on health system related subjects. Reading her columns has confirmed that my ‘vague recollection’ was spot on.
Healthcare a big concern for the public
This confirmation is reinforced by Kathy Spencer’s latest column published in The Post (20 October; paywalled) under the challenging heading ‘The major parties both say they’re fixing health – but are they serious about it?’: Are major parties fixing health?
It is such an insightful piece that I will discuss it further below. But first I go to her answer to the question which is at the end of her column.
In a nutshell (and in my words) she advises that National is nowhere near fixing health while Labour is short of fixing but does have some encouraging policies. This is a summation that broadly resonates with me.
Spencer begins by referring to the concern of most people over the state of the public health system as revealed in the recent The Post/Freshwater Strategy survey of 1,000 New Zealanders. Specifically:
- 74% think that the public health system is no longer able to provide timely care when people need it (only 7% disagreed and the other 19% were neutral or unsure);
- improving healthcare ranked as the second priority for voters, after addressing the cost of living; and
- 75% think that too little funding is going into the system.
National Party: “smokes and mirrors”
In discussing the National Party’s health policy Kathy Spencer identifies her “…significant problem with each part of” a statement in its election pamphlet which asserts that:
…our record investment means patients spending less time in emergency departments and facing shorter wait times for elective surgeries like hip, knee and cataract operations.

Spencer describes National’s health policy as “smoke and mirrors”
Starting with the “record investment” she clarifies the reality:
It is a longstanding practice for governments to include “cost pressure funding” in Vote Health for the coming year – this funding is aimed at maintaining the status quo in the face of increasing costs, mainly due to inflation and a population that is growing and ageing.
Compensating for these factors requires annual increases of 5% – 6% in operating funding for Health NZ. So, when Vote Health increases from one year to the next, it is nothing out of the ordinary, and nothing to crow about.
Spencer then adds:
In 2024, the current government decided to cobble-up an absurdly large figure by announcing three Budgets’ worth of cost pressure funding at once. It added the figures up over multiple years and called it the biggest investment ever.
Next she dissects National’s claims that patients are spending less time in emergency departments.
This is true when it is compared with last year but very wrong when compared with 10 years ago when 91% of people attending EDs were either admitted, discharged or transferred from the department within six hours. In contrast the current performance is dismal with only 76% of attendees getting out of the ED within six hours.

Health Minister Simeon Brown performative rather than substantive
Finally she drills down into the National’s election pamphlet claims that people are facing shorter waits for planned surgeries. She describes the real situation in this way:
These are surgeries that don’t have to be done within seven days and include hip and knee replacements, heart valve replacements and heart bypass surgery.
Only 73% of people are waiting less than four months for these procedures. Again, that’s far worse than the performance 10 years ago, when the figure was 98%.
As for Labour’s health policy
While Kathy Spencer’s strongest criticisms are of National’s health policy and she is positive about Labour’s policy, she does not believe that Labour’s it will even “come close” to ‘fixing health’.

Labour health spokesperson Ayesha Verrall good on primary care but more is required to fix health (Stuff)
She notes approvingly Labour’s commitment to fund “..three free GP visits, various mechanisms to support GPs and free-up appointments, free maternity scans, and a return to free prescriptions.”
In her view:
Labour’s emphasis on primary care will help to get health conditions treated earlier, and should reduce demand at emergency departments.
On the right track but…
There is a lot more that could be said on ‘fixing health’. For example, the falseness of the narrative that health targets are the silver bullet solution to fixing the health system as repeatedly claimed by the health minister..
A solution that only focusses on those things that are easier and convenient to count (and excludes those that are more critical such as increasing acute admissions) is the kind of solution one has when one does not have a solution.
However, this is not a criticism of Spencer’s column. There is only so much one can say or expand on when one is governed by word limits in a publication that is not yours.

Kathy Spencer is largely on the right track
According to the polling she draws upon “…a majority of New Zealanders want a public health system that provides timely care when people need it.”
This is the threshold she uses to conclude that while National’s health policy is “smoke and mirrors” while Labour’s falls well short of reaching.
It is a good threshold. I also agree with her conclusion; she is largely on the right track. However, her column also suggests that genuine (not “smoke and mirrors”) funding is the fixing solution.
This is where I shift to a different track. There is no solution without realistic funding. But, more so, the health system needs what it presently does not have. That is:
- A trust and confidence relationship between the health system’s leadership and its workforce.
- An entrenched culture of pro-active engagement that recognises this workforce more than anything else knows best how to achieve systems improvement.
This is discussed further in the first and fourth past blog posts listed immediately below. Just saying!
In the meantime, keep writing Kathy Spencer. The public health system and the public itself needs this.
Ian Powell was Executive Director of the Association of Salaried Medical Specialists, the professional union representing senior doctors and dentists in New Zealand, for over 30 years, until December 2019. He is now a health systems, labour market, and political commentator living in the small river estuary community of Otaihanga (the place by the tide). First published at Otaihanga Second Opinion.





Based on the last 3 years, National will CONTINUE to destroy our health system. Expect more avoidable deaths.