Ian Powell – It’s not just the money! It’s also how to get a better return for the health dollar

Ron Burgess was a much respected and loved leader of the union movement in Aotearoa New Zealand, including the former Post Office Union. He also became the first Secretary of the Council of Trade Unions (CTU) in 1987.
In this latter role he addressed the first annual conference of the newly formed Association of Salaried Medical Specialists (ASMS) in 1989.
During a typically precise presentation he brought the ‘house down’ with laughter when he said that money was not the only important thing but it was well ahead of whatever was in second place.

Ron Burgess – a reassuring and humorous voice
The following year ASMS voted overwhelmingly at its annual conference to affiliate to the CTU. Ron Burgess was a reassuring voice that helped enable this.
As the then ASMS executive director it is also a decision I was particularly proud off and continues to be so today.
Meanwhile, after his retirement, Burgess became the ASMS elections returning officer for several years (he used this small income to shout our office admin staff lunch after each election).
The need for trust and confidence between HNZ leadership and its workforce
On 3 September I published a blog post arguing the precariousness of Health New Zealand (HNZ) – Te Whatu Ora not being on the same page as its workforce: HNZ and workforce on different pages. By HNZ I primarily meant its political leadership but also its board and highest level of management.
Subsequently, a month later (4 October), I published a blog post on the importance of HNZ establishing a mutual trust and confidence relationship with its workforce as a prerequisite for earning the trust and confidence of patients and the public: Workforce needs trust and confidence in HNZ.

My salient points on achieving trust and confidence
In noting that there had not been this trust and confidence relationship since HNZ’s formation in July 2022, my salient points in this latter post were:
- Recognising that the leadership of Te Whatu Ora will not win the trust and confidence of patients, families and the wider public until it first wins the trust and confidence of its workforce.
- Recognising that a pervasive culture of proactive engagement in which decision-making is distributed as close to the workplace as practically possible is the most decisive driver of the effectiveness and innovation of a health system.
- Recognising that workforce empowerment is the strongest foundation for driving innovation and sustainable system improvement.
- Recognising the importance of addressing workforce shortages (specifically doctors, nurses, and allied health professionals and practitioners) through applicable recruitment and retention strategies in order to both overcome fatigue and burnout and establish the capacity for workforce empowerment.
- Recognising the importance of seeing this workforce as an investment rather than a balance sheet cost or liability.
- Recognising that increasing acute patient hospital admissions is one of the two biggest pressures on the health system, including public hospitals (the other big pressure is workforce shortages).
No, it’s “just the money”
This second above post received a quick response from one reader:
It’s just the money. Truly. It would get the unemployed nurses back into the wards, keep doctors this side of the Tasman (both in practice and in hospitals), and fund more wards and equipment. Then you would see morale jump in consequence. Just the money.
It is not difficult to relate to this view; especially when it is read in the context of the steady stream of media reporting of the reality for those working in the clinical frontline of public hospitals.

Working in an emergency department is like “working in a war zone”
A case in point is the paywalled article on nurse shortages by Harriet Laughton in The Post (9 October) comparing this reality with a war zone: Working in a war zone.
Her opening paragraph said:
Four emergency departments have declared a “state of emergency” with Health NZ in the past two months, with one likening shifts to a “war zone” as nurses are forced to focus solely on lifesaving care.
Certainly if funding was increased simply to overcome workforce shortages this would be positive. But we can do much better than this.
Health funding requires a sensible discussion
Unfortunately a sensible discussion on this subject is not helped by the current government claiming that it is funding the health system at a record level. Technically correct but in practice dishonest.

Health Minister Simeon Brown technically correct but in practice dishonest over health funding
One probably has to go back to the Depression of the 1930s when health funding was less than the previous year.
Well before I starting working for the Association of Salaried Medical Specialists (ASMS), health funding increased every year regardless of who the government was.
Every government could have technically claimed record health funding. In fact, it would be technically correct to increase health funding by only one dollar and to then state that funding was at a record level.
The real issue was not whether health funding had increased but instead whether or not it was a relative increase; that is, more or less than cost increases.
A sensible discussion would also involve whether year-to-year or longer historical funding comparisons should be used to help assess the adequacy of health funding. At the moment this prevails because of a lack of an alternative.
While I was with ASMS we worked collaboratively with the Council of Trade Unions to analyse Vote Health in each year’s Budget.
Past funding history was an important factor in this work and it was good quality work (other factors just as cost pressures were also used).
But, because of the necessity of producing a Budget analysis and the immediate focus of other debates on aggregated funding, it did not drill down into whether and how a better return for the health dollar might be achieved.
This is important the health system is highly complex, dynamic, labour intensive, and consequently requires ongoing sustainable and innovative process improvement. It is a sector where today’s silo was yesterday’s innovation.
Worthy attempt at a better return from the health dollar
Securing a Sustainable Senior Medical and Dental Workforce in New Zealand was a joint effort between ASMS and the 20 district health boards (DHBs) published in November 2010. I was centrally involved in this initiative.
Owing to its context it was commonly known as the ‘Business Case’: Investing in hospital specialist workforce to secure sustainability and systems improvements.
The context was the dramatic effect of a significant increase in specialist salaries in Queensland in response to critical shortages. This then spread in various ways to the other states.

New Zealand is forced to compete in Australia’s medical labour market
The effect in the late 2000s was to lead to a big increase in specialists in New Zealand leaving for Australia; roughly one specialist a month; significant when scale is considered.
This migration, which was only one way, was helped by Australia’s relative proximity and shared medical training programmes.

Then ASMS President, Palmerston North paediatrician Dr Jeff Brown, played a decisive leadership role in the development of the joint business case with the DHBs
The motivation to produce the joint document (67 pages) was two-fold:
- to improve the ability of DHBs to recruit and retain specialists with more competitive remuneration; and
- to create the capacity to use the considerable complexity skills of this workforce to innovatively improve system processes in order to improve the quality of patient care and reduce large financial wastage.
At this time other parts of the health professional workforce were not in the same position as hospital specialists. This was partly because they did not fact the same level of an ‘Australian threat’.
Further, not long before work on the Business Case began, the Nurses Organisation had successfully achieved a national parity settlement (the police were an integral comparator) through collective bargaining with the DHBs.
The document was called the ‘Business Case’ because the objective was to get government approval for funding to help enable the DHBs to invest in the specialist workforce.
It began with a firm statement made the previous month from then Health Minister Tony Ryall that hospital specialist shortages was a crisis.
A joint ASMS-DHBs team developed the Business Case. It was endorsed by the ASMS as a whole while the DHBs endorsed it in principle.
Regrettably, however, and without prior discussion, the DHBs subsequently and unexpectedly did a u-turn.

Then health minister Tony Ryall is believed to have indirectly or directly persuaded the DHBs to walk away from joint Business Case
The reason for this was never explained and even today remains unclear. It appears there was ministerial pressure involved in some way. I do recall personal apologies from some embarrassed DHB chief executives.
The DHBs’ unilateral u-turn also occurred at a time when health minister Tony Ryall had stopped referring to specialist shortages as a crisis.
A lost opportunity but much can be learnt from it
The experience became a lost opportunity and our health system could have been in a much better position had it been implemented. But the thinking behind it remains valid today.

The abandonment of the Business Case was a lost opportunity by government for the health system
The most effective way to improve the accessibility and quality of healthcare and getting a much better return for the health dollar, is through investing in the health professional workforce in order to use its expertise and experience to drive innovation and systems improvement.
In the absence of this, the debate on health funding has to be narrowed down to historical baselines and relative underfunding.
Our health system, our committed workforce and, above all, patients and loved ones deserve much better than this.
Ian Powell was Executive Director of the Association of Salaried Medical Specialists, the professional union representing senior doctors and dentists in New Zealand, for over 30 years, until December 2019. He is now a health systems, labour market, and political commentator living in the small river estuary community of Otaihanga (the place by the tide). First published at Otaihanga Second Opinion.





