Allan Alach – Shouldn’t Erica Stanford Be Leading By Example?

As the voting has now started, I’m making a few more attempts over the next few days to convince any doubters about Erica Stanford’s incompetence, dishonesty and outright manipulation as Minister of Education. If the speculation is correct and National are considering rolling Luxon after the election and replacing him with Stanford, heaven help us. Unlike most of her ministerial colleagues, who are merely incompetent, Stanford is devious.
Let’s start, as I often do, with Brie Elliott. Brie has obviously succeeded in rattling the right wing, going by the personal attacks on her on various social media, especially Facebook, and the sudden cancellation of her Instagram account. You must remember that any talk from the right about freedom of speech (e.g., the so called Free Speech Union) is pure male bovine excrement. The only ‘free speech’ they accept is that which fits their ideological view of the world. Anything else is heresy as far as the right are concerned. The very concept of discussing and debating differing opinions is beyond them – one only has to read some of the comments on my articles to see that.
Brie writes,
‘ERICA STANFORD HAS SOME NERVE, that’s for damn sure.
A damning report finds that the Teaching Council should have struck convicted sex offender Timothy Fisher off a decade before he was finally convicted of horrific offences against children.
And Erica Stanford’s response?
Blame the unions. Blame elected teacher representatives. Declare the Council’s culture was “infected by the unions”. Then publicly question whether NZEI president Ripeka Lessels should even remain in her job.
What the fuck?
A woman who spent years involved with the Teaching Council is now having her professional standing publicly questioned by the Education Minister.
I find that particularly disturbing. The willingness to use the power of a ministerial platform to publicly undermine an individual’s standing when that person is politically inconvenient.
You can scrutinise someone’s record without trying to destroy their reputation. You can demand accountability without turning a person into a public target.
And you can discuss serious safeguarding failures without using them as an opportunity to attack a union leader. It’s yuck behaviour.
I’ve experienced Stanford publicly targeting me, so perhaps this hits a nerve. But I know what it feels like to have someone with enormous political power talk about you in a way that invites everyone else to pile on.’
And:
‘What I find particularly ugly about Stanford’s approach is the decision to make this personal – publicly questioning a woman’s right to remain in her job – rather than sticking to the evidence and explaining exactly who was responsible for what.
This is the same minister who has publicly characterised women who challenge her, including me, rather than simply addressing the substance of the issues raised.
There is a difference between accountability and publicly undermining an individual’s standing.
And if accountability is genuinely the objective, it cannot depend on whether someone is a union leader Stanford dislikes or a man she personally appointed.’
Further,
‘How many people does Erica Stanford, our education minister, get to publicly target before we have a conversation about her conduct?
I’m genuinely starting to lose count.
There is a growing list of incidents in which Erica Stanford has gone beyond debating the issues and made the people challenging her, the story.
Let’s look at some examples.
- JAN TINETTI – “STUPID BITCH”
In Parliament in November 2024, Stanford called Labour MP Jan Tinetti a “stupid bitch” during a dispute over rural school bus routes. She subsequently withdrew the remark and apologised.
A sitting Education Minister directing that language at a female opposition MP. In Parliament.
- ME — THE DOM HARVEY PODCAST
Stanford publicly referred to me as “this awful woman” while discussing my online activity, and made an allegation concerning a dyslexia charity’s website that I challenged.
I’m a member of the public commenting on education policy. She is a Cabinet minister with a vastly larger platform.
She could have addressed my arguments. Instead, she made me the subject of personal commentary.
- RIPEKA LESSELS – QUESTIONING HER POSITION AS UNION PRESIDENT
After the damning Fisher report into the Teaching Council’s handling of convicted sex offender Timothy Fisher, Stanford publicly questioned whether NZEI president Ripeka Lessels’ position was tenable because of her previous involvement with the Council.
The report raised serious questions about institutional failures. Those failures deserve scrutiny.
But what specific evidence did Stanford present to justify questioning Ripeka’s position as union president?
- JASON MILES – THE PRINCIPALS’ CONFERENCE DISPUTE
When the New Zealand Principals’ Federation criticised Stanford’s conference speech, she described its president’s behaviour as “rude, aggressive and unprofessional”.
Again, the public debate moved beyond the substance of the criticism and towards the conduct and character of the person delivering it.
- THE EDUCATION WHISTLEBLOWER
When allegations emerged that Ministry staff had been discouraged from putting curriculum-related discussions in writing, Stanford publicly characterised the anonymous source as “ideologically-driven”.
- HOBSON’S PLEDGE – “FROTHING AT THE MOUTH WITH HATRED”
Stanford used the phrase “frothing at the mouth with hatred” when criticising the advocacy group’s response to her education-policy position.
This is another example of the heated language she uses when responding to people and organisations challenging her.
- NZEI – ACCUSATIONS OF BULLYING ITS OWN MEMBERS
During the dispute over strike action, Stanford accused NZEI of bullying its own members and suggested members were afraid to speak out against the union’s demands. That is a serious allegation about an organisation representing thousands of educators. What evidence supports it, and how was it substantiated?
- CURRICULUM CRITICS – DISMISSING OPPOSITION AS A VOCAL MINORITY
When subject associations challenged the Government’s draft curriculum, Stanford characterised opposition as coming from a “quite vocal minority” and questioned whether some critics had properly read the documents. Professional criticism deserves a substantive response. Dismissing the people raising concerns does not resolve those concerns.’
Lovely person, don’t you think? Resorting to name calling (ad hominen attacks) is the lowest form of argument, usually because it means there is no other rational argument available. It’s a sign of weakness, not strength.
Brie concludes,
‘How does Stanford respond to parents who challenge her?
Teachers? Academics? Whistleblowers? Members of the public who question her reforms? Does she address their arguments, or does she make the individual the story?
Because the Education Minister should be able to defend her policies on their merits without resorting to personal attacks.
If Erica Stanford expects accountability from everyone else in education, surely her own conduct is fair game for scrutiny, too’
Dr Sarah Aiono has also written on this:
A Rotten Culture? Accountability Must Start at the Top
‘Education Minister Erica Stanford has launched an extraordinary attack on the Teaching Council, describing its organisational culture as “rotten” and claiming it had been “infected by the unions”.
Speaking to RNZ following a report concerning the Council’s handling of a sex offender case, Stanford argued that union representation had created conflicts of interest within the organisation.
She went further, singling out NZEI Te Riu Roa president Ripeka Lessels, a former deputy chair and long-serving Council member, and questioning whether her position as union president remained tenable.
These are serious accusations from a Minister of Education.
There can be no question that the Teaching Council must be held accountable for failures in its regulatory responsibilities. The safety of children is paramount, and where systems have failed to protect children, those failures must be thoroughly investigated, addressed and prevented from recurring.
But serious regulatory failures require serious examination of their causes. They cannot simply be attributed to union involvement without compelling evidence establishing that connection.
And if the Minister believes organisational culture is grounds for questioning an individual’s continued leadership, then an equally important question arises.
What standards of accountability should apply to the Minister herself?’
In Stanford’s mind it appears the answer is none.
‘Stanford’s response goes considerably further than questioning regulatory performance. She has characterised the Teaching Council’s culture as “rotten”, attributed that culture to union influence, and publicly questioned the position of a sitting union president.
These are political claims directed at organisations and individuals who represent the teaching profession. But where is the evidence connecting union representation to the regulatory failures identified? What evidence establishes that removing elected representation would have prevented those failures? And how will exclusive ministerial appointments provide stronger safeguards against future failures?
Without clear answers, there is a legitimate concern that an appalling child protection failure is being used to justify a wider political objective: reducing the independent influence of the teaching profession over its own regulator.
That possibility should concern everyone, regardless of their views about unions.’
Indeed. As we know, one of Stanford’s dictatorial moves, based on an underlying anti-union agenda, was to remove elected teacher representation from the Teaching Council, and replace these with her own appointees.
Why is the right afraid of unions?
‘The teaching profession and the unions that represent some of its members are not one and the same.
Yet the Minister’s comments appear to blur that distinction, treating professional representation and union influence as though they are interchangeable. They are not. Teachers bring professional knowledge, experience and perspectives to governance, regardless of their union affiliation.
Removing elected teacher representation from the Teaching Council does not simply reduce union influence. It also removes a direct avenue through which the profession has a voice in the governance of its own regulator.’
Put workers in their place, that’s the message.
Maybe if all was well in Stanford’s Ministry of Education, we could turn a blind eye to these matters. But as has been well covered, the culture in the Ministry is badly damaged. Seems Stanford is very good on the ‘do as I say’ and rather poor on doing the right thing in her own department.
‘A Ministry under investigation
There is also a striking contrast between the Minister’s willingness to publicly attribute responsibility to individuals within the Teaching Council and the questions of institutional accountability currently facing her own education portfolio.
In September 2026, the Chief Ombudsman announced a formal investigation into concerns about practices within the Ministry of Education, including allegations of attempts to circumvent the Official Information Act.
These are allegations under investigation, not established findings. Nor does the announcement establish personal wrongdoing by the Minister.
Nevertheless, the investigation raises serious questions about transparency, institutional practices and the systems of accountability operating within the education portfolio.
The Official Information Act is fundamental to democratic accountability. It allows the public, journalists and education professionals to scrutinise decisions made on their behalf.
When concerns about compliance with that legislation are sufficiently serious to warrant a formal investigation, they deserve the same attention to organisational culture, governance and leadership responsibility that the Minister demands of the Teaching Council.’
And so it continues. Sarah covers these and other issues in depth so please click on the link above and read her article for yourself.
She concludes,
‘Do as I say, not as I do?
The Minister has made her expectations of accountability clear when it comes to the Teaching Council and those who have served on its governing body.
But what happens when we apply those same expectations to the Minister’s own leadership?
At a time when teachers and school leaders are being subjected to increasing prescription, scrutiny and accountability, questions are also being raised about how education policy itself is developed, justified and implemented.
The Teaching Council must be accountable for its regulatory responsibilities.
Unions must be accountable to their members and for the responsibilities their representatives undertake.
The Ministry of Education must be accountable for the integrity and transparency of its processes.
And the Minister must be accountable for the decisions, governance arrangements and reform processes undertaken within her portfolio.
These responsibilities are not identical, and accountability does not automatically mean resignation. But the principles of transparency, evidence, integrity and leadership responsibility should apply consistently.
It is entirely reasonable for a Minister to demand high standards from a professional regulator.
It is equally reasonable for the public to demand high standards from the Minister.’
In other words Stanford should be leading by example, setting the standard for others to follow.
No evidence of that.






Considering Stanford was unable to succeed in her coup attempts earlier this year, it suggests she doesn’t have overwhelming support from her colleagues who don’t see her as a future prime minister.
It suggests she’s over-confident and they don’t want her in the top job. They know her better than us and better than business leaders.
CB is right. ‘We’re in a dark place occupied by would be trump-clones.’ What an achievement from a once independent and free-thinking little nation.
We have a beautiful country and a couple of million weak-minded dolts influenced so badly by social media that they have no personal opinions that haven’t been forced into their tiny brains by people with the worst kind of global agendas.
Everyone I know is sick of the sleazy, selfish, degrading argy-bargy that’s been going on for a few years now.
Somehow, it’s more important that someone said hi to their cousin who is in a gang than is it that Stanford, Brown and Luxon and others are giving away our money, denigrating our beautiful, unique culture to please some foreign manipulators purposes and plan to continue doing all that and more.
Nothing the Left could dream up could come close for blatant Sleaze or Treason. It’s not just one person, it’s the whole lot of them.
” As the voting has now started, I’m making a few more attempts over the next few days to convince any doubters about Erica Stanford’s incompetence, dishonesty and outright manipulation as Minister of Education. ”
As a simple fucker from a simple past with simple means and needs floating up in the *high hopes and thin air of the lunacy of a small yet rich country but with spindly legs trying to carry the weight of institutionalised lies, corruption, misappropriation, missing billions, squandered opportunities and on a gorgeous few islands as a second comer human, human being I’m desperately trying, daily, not to be drawn into the temptation to emigrate to flat smelly australia just to get a sniff of air not polluted by dirty, white, well kissed Kiwi arseholes. We’re now in a dark place occupied by political trump clones who’s lies and deceit demand our attention from a corrupted, rotting-corpse MSM. My reality is now mine. I no longer rely on the MSM to do its honourable job. I don’t trust many, if any, so how do I roll like this? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5lVdaWBjiLM . Our bullying politicians and their privateer overlords use arrogance and bluff to keep us on the ropes and if we manage to stand up with our defences in place to come back, they find new ways to keep their boots on our necks. Fake, outrageous house prices against worlds highest mortgage costs and worlds most profitable retail banking while using poor health to justify benign control over our working people sold to us by a new populace of cowering politicians with less bottle than a feather pillow who take, from us, $ix figure$ plu$ expen$e$ to tell us what to expect rather than to do what we tell them to. Neoliberalism armed with MMP is a war crime and we’re getting picked off. *https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PxWS1ufr5xI&list=RDPxWS1ufr5xI&start_radio=1