WAATEA NEWS COLUMN: The cruelty of our benefit sanctions

By
Martyn Bradbury
-
10
427

The number of benefits cut in the September quarter rose 133% to 14,409, mainly due to missed appointments, just think about that for a moment.

14 409 beneficiaries with benefits cut for missing an appointment.

How does that level of cruelty help those people?

How does harassing beneficiaries like this help the economy?

How does it help our community?

- Sponsor Promotion -

A record nearly 400,000 people are on some form of benefit – almost the same proportion of the population as after the Global Financial Crisis (GFC) and that is happening as unemployment is rising.

We know that Māori unemployment is 3 times higher than the baseline unemployment rate, we know these sanctions hit Māori hardest and we know the political value of bashing beneficiaries and Māori for the right.

Is this draconian welfare punishment legitimate social policy or a revenge fantasy for reactionary right wing voters?

Taking from hungry desperate people is nothing short of state sanctioned cruelty and the ease with which this Government implements this cruelty should frighten the electorate.

This Government isn’t serving the people, it’s punishing the minority for the entertainment of the majority!

This is gladiatorial culture wars, not Governance.

Meanwhile the most vulnerable amongst us are forced to suffer more than they should just to make National Party voters feel better about their bruised privilege.

 

10 COMMENTS

    • Perhaps we have less beneficiaries in the first place. Highest unemployment in history because of a right wing government hellbent on a low wage economy and ministers who believe others to be losers.
      Our biggest beneficiaries belong to this government.
      You should walk in beneficiaries shoes before passing judgement. I have seen first hand the punitive approach taken by Winz caseworkers with beneficiaries. No wonder they don’t turn up.

      • Highest unemployment in history?
        Haaahaa not even close!
        Govt depts needed to cut the excessive staff.
        Are you aware the amount of new govt staff taken on by Labour govt in last 8mths of their 6 year fiasco STILL does not amount to the amount already laid off by this new govt.
        Amazing eh

    • Problems arise when people can’t get time off from low paid work to attend the appointment. The benefit top up is needed to attain a decent standard of living. Not ideal but less benefits more wage subsidy.

    • Perhaps your holyness could take some time out and pray for the people that have caused us to have beneficiaries in the first place .They are the problem not the beneficiaries.

    • @PP2 – I have read some dumb comments from you before. Does someone pay you to put them up as talking points? Appointments can be made arbitrarily by MSD or WINZ or LOOZ and as they don’t want to see you anyway they do stuff over the phone, so they will send a message setting a time. If you aren’t there after they have rung 3 or? times they say you have missed the appointment. That’s as I have had it explained.
      WILL SOMEONE WHO SPEAKS FROM KNOWLEDGE AND OR EXPERIENCE PLEASE INDICATE THE PROCEDURE TO AFFIRM ABOVE.

      We need to actually read and understand and remember and consider then communicate about this. This is 18th century attitudes and they are not what my father died for in WW2. Disgraceful treatment of people on benefits and disgraceful wilful ignorance of puffed up self-loving twerps.

  2. I am still receiving mail for a MSD client who lived at my address 8 years ago. This despite numerous calls explaining that this address is incorrect. I wonder how many of those missed appointments are because MSD don’t have their shit together. (perhaps they needed those backroom staff after all)
    The comment from Pope Punitivillianous misses the point. Starving the children of someone who misses an appointment while crowing about personal responsibility is obscene.

  3. ‘If beneficiaries want to keep their benefits, maybe they should turn up for appointments.’
    Spoken by someone who never had to deal with MSD.
    Personal experience: Benefit cancelled without warning. Telephone no use. Go to inquire at local office, Nobody knows, must ask Wellington.
    A week later benefit resumes, computer error( bullshit! computers are machines, people make errors).
    Later my neighbour comes to me in panic. Her benefit stopped without explanation. Her English is poor so she asks me to help her talk to MSD.
    Her benefit is stopped because she failed to keep an appointment. Frantically she tells me she knows nothing about an appointment. Turns out MSD never told her she had an appointment.
    I work with a volunteer group and I can tell you about many cases where notices of appointment for the 17th of the month arrive on the 21st or even later. Where MSD ignore reasons for non-attendance, such as medical reasons, childcare, study.
    MSD is staffed by unfortunates who cannot get jobs anywhere else and there is a high turnover of frontline staff as soon as they can get less stressful work somewhere else. Government Public service cuts have worsened the situation by reducing MSD staff and placing a greater workload on those staffers who actually have to work with the public.
    Kiss my ring Pope! Now tell us how a celibate cleric lectures people about divorce, birth control and sexuality while supporting pedophiles.

Comments are closed.