Details of Dunedin Hospital cost blow-out can’t be revealed due to ‘commercial sensitivity’
A question mark hangs over exactly how the cost of the new Dunedin Hospital has blown out, with the Government refusing to reveal exact details of how the project could cost $3b, citing commercially sensitivity.
The Dunedin Mayor has attacked these new supposed cost blow outs as a “smokescreen”…
“They’ve added in extra costs to try and cloud the issue. For a start, refurbishment. No one’s ever talked about refurbishment being in the scope of this project, refurbishment of old blocks. I mean, they re talking hundreds of millions for that. ‘They’re talking about car parks – car parks have been long since taken out of the scope of this project… ‘And pathology is the other one that they’re talking about – [it] has already been taken out of scope by the previous government and agreed to by this government when they were in opposition. So it’s a smokescreen.'”
…they are lying about the Dunedin Hospital cost blow out…
the remainder of the projected blow-out – about $700m – are shrouded in secrecy, as the Government says commercial sensitivities mean it cannot disclose further details.
Infrastructure Minister Chris Bishop previously said construction costs were driven up by issues such as “contaminated ground, piling difficulty, flood level risk, and an extremely constrained construction site”, making it an unattractive project….
But Labour associate health spokesperson Tracey McLellan has accused the ministers of adding “every optional extra under the sun to drive the cost up to suit their narrative”.
“A car park and pathology service were not part of the publicly funded scope.”
…so as to manufacture a crisis to justify privatisation…
Health NZ urges Govt to consider privately-run public hospitals
The health agency is suggesting the Government to consider allowing private companies to build – and potentially run – the country’s public hospitals.
…despite saying this at the time…
…this is the game the Right are playing…
…and you are dumb enough to believe them
This Government lies and lies and lies to justify their radical privatisation agenda and because the Fourth Estate Media is dying, the Government don’t get called on their lies…
PM Christopher Luxon’s second fumble on benefit numbers
-
-
- The prime minister has mixed up his numbers in a TV interview about the government’s welfare changes
- It marks the second misstep this week after Luxon was earlier unable to say how much a Jobseeker benefit was
- Labour says it proves the prime minister is “removed from the reality” of those in poverty
-
Actually, it’s more than 2 lies now…
…they lie and lie and lie and the media allow them to get away with it!
Increasingly having independent opinion in a mainstream media environment which mostly echo one another has become more important than ever, so if you value having an independent voice – please donate here.
JMO Like the 1984 Roger nightmare this government is behaving criminally foisting a cruel heartless privatisation policy on kiwi people who reject THIS MADNESS! Basically this shower have no concept of being servants to the people not to greedy profit shareholder rich scum. They will destroy New Zealand what’s left of it. Our young people will leave to find better lives elsewhere. They can’t even buy a house now without a lifetime of mortgage slavery to the rich mediated by foreign banks who loan the money to them.
People like Trevor, BTF, and Jonzie appear dumb enough to believe them. I suspect however it’s more a case of them being too stubborn to admit this coalition is built on lies. Not everyone of a right a leaning persuasion is a lying arsehole. Unfortunately this particular bunch of politicians are. I am not really sure what Peters is. Maybe they are liars and labels have nothing to do with it.
Privatization doesn’t worry me because I assume we have an opposition bloc that are fighting tooth and nail against it on top of committing themselves to reversing such horrid measures should they ever be implemented. How about our elected representatives of the people leading the resistance or….
The right wing coalition is simply doing what they said they would do.
Give their White right wing voters everything they want and bash the left wing.
So huge tax breaks for the rich (ACT National)
Allow farmers, mining/fossil fuel companies,and manufacturers to pollute and destroy the environment at will to increase profits. (National ACT)
Promote tobacco (NZF)
Prescription medicine sales to help their multinatinal friends (National ACT)
Create a huge pool of unemployed to drive down wages and increase profits. (National ACT)
Bash minorities espcially Maori, (ACT, National) Bash Immigrants (NZF)womens groups,(Naional) Gays (Christians) environmentalists academics (National)
Basically any one who refuses to lick right wing White arse hole will be attacked.
Its how the right wing rolls.
And Dunedin always vote Labour so of course they have to be bashed.
So just downgrade their hospital.
We can only hope the returning left wing Govt in 2029 overturns all this right wing shit.
As I have commented on many times ” commercial sensitivity ” allows for the government and the private sector to hide behind when they want to supress or conceal corrupt practices or information that would be negative or unpopular or reveal what their intention really is allowing them to control the agenda and narrative.
Even the official information act is not immune and No Right turn’s Idiot Savant regularly come up against legally perverting the course of democracy and transperiency when attempting to access the O.I.A.
Its tax payers money they are responsible for and at the very least they should show the real costs in this project so the public can decide if tax cuts are worth paying for rather than investing in public health and infrastructure.
Where are the budgets to show that the hospital will cost 3 billion ?Bishop once again has spouted without the paper trail to prove his mantra .Till they are produced its just more bull shit .In twelve months this government has spouted more bovine shit than the entire dairy industry in the same time .
National have financially mismanaged health alongside everything else all for the totally unnecessary tax cuts…
https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/politics/health-nzs-near-1b-deficit-worse-than-expected-health-minister-shane-reti/4SGKWTGX3BC37OUVCK2RRN73RM/
Former Health NZ Chair: Government has manufactured a crisis to privatise health
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2UCu0vkkOME
We as a country really need to get our sh*t together on Health, Education & Housing they are bottom line Human Needs, Maslow Hierachy of Needs details this. Or do we just hand the country over to David Seymore and the Atlas Network to run the country, which appears to be what is happening ???
If anyone in the south island votes for this government in the next election they would have to be completely insane. Cut off at the knees with the ferries now fucking with health care both with the aim of privatisation. The government are proven to be blatent liers how come this isn’t illegal and especially in the case of Costello banging on about an independent authority she can’t name, to justify her wicked policies around heated tobacco and hand ous to Phillip Morris. It’s really disgusting that there is no accountability. Why? How? Labour are fucking useless.
If anyone in the south island votes for this government in the next election they would have to be completely insane. Cut off at the knees with the ferries now fucking with health care both with the aim of privatisation. The government are proven to be blatent liers how come this isn’t illegal and especially in the case of Costello banging on about an independent authority she can’t name, to justify her wicked policies around heated tobacco and hand ous to Phillip Morris. It’s really disgusting that there is no accountability. Why? How? Labour are fucking useless.
Your last sentence is on target.
Luxon also promised to fund health to the level needed and factor in inflation, but he will say, I didn’t realize the state the books were in” He thinks we are all dumb we are not all trevors, I’m right or andrews.
The government won’t support the health system but are willing to underwrite new housing development, the next change will be allowing more wealthy immigrants to buy the houses built as they attempt to keep the property housing Ponzi rolling. Things can only get worse with this lot making such loopy decisions.
@ jay11. You write
” …Like the 1984 Roger nightmare this government …”
But the nightmare lives on. [It] never went away. The Nightmare on Roger Street lives breaths and steals your precious time on earth and it denies you your right to live a happy life on your beautiful Aotearoa / New Zealand and if anyone must ask how then you’d better pay closer attention to the details than you have been.
Roger started his little parasitic life up and inside old Labour as a two term finance minister. What better way to get to know your target prey?
Then, once he, douglas, knew he and his cronies had control of Labour’s caucus they struck! Lange quit as PM and by quit I mean he was pushed by stealth because douglas had already gathered about his his cohorts.
The book Someone Else’s Country by Alistair Barry goes further in to what happened. https://www.nzonscreen.com/title/someone-elses-country-1996
( The reason for such treachery is simpler to explain than to understand.
The reason for such treachery was because of the money. Not only because of the money stolen from our primary industry but of the money that was about to BE stolen from our primary industry and it was that basic premise that lead to neo-liberalism because once public property, assets and amenities were privatised it was far easier to hide any dirt swept under their already dirty little rugs. Think of neo-liberalism as being a change of policy. Steal something that belongs to the public, as was our resources and assets could be described as illegal to steal and that can be called theft. Steal something that WAS illegal to steal but has now been ‘privatised’ can be called privatisation and so comes under an entirely new set of laws. It’s called Rogernomics. The art of theft.
Now. Today. We have no politic. Our various political parties are all the same thing. They’re not political parties at all generally writing. They’re crooks taking part in crooked shit and we swallow their shit hook line and sinker.
AO/NZ = 5.2 million people. AO/NZ = 3 million able to vote thus work.
Minus the elderly @ 880,000 = 2,912,000. Of that 2,912,000 50,000 people are farmers who earn 100% of our income and the National Party have almost all of them gaslighted and Labour hates farmers and tells us that it is the working classes who earn our exports derived income. Our ONLY income. Don’t dare suggest it’s fucking tourism.
In short: Not only are they lying about an entry level hospital upgrade but they’re lying about our entire economy, our entire history and are throwing us under a 40 ton B train.
NB. As an example: The trucks that rip the shit out of public taxes paid for roading while much of our rail infrastructure got literally pulled up to enable an urban cabal of dodgy fuckers gain a monopoly on road transport after using their all bought and paid for MSM to sell us the logical-fallacy benefits of tourism. Aye boys?
Solution: A royal commission of inquiry up and into every cent spent from 1936. ( Prior too that would also be fascinating.)
Warning! As I see it, I see our economy is being deliberately tanked. The factory-fication of udders has seen a sobering rise in a mono agrarian economy which means it can be switched off should searching inquiry get too close. Well, how’s this for too close fuckers? Never pick a fight with someone who’s got nothing left to lose.
Our Ports are slowed down to a standstill, our private debt has been conned upwards by four australian owned banks who made themselves, in that process, the second most profitable banks in the world next only to Canada. Australia, our exports competitors and our politicians who more resemble cheap crooks in ugly suits hovering around the low end gaming tables in the cheaper casinos in Las Vegas.
Luxon has no Class. At all. Beware the greedy cunt who has no Class.
ideological fundamentalists – and the right has the temerity to label LINO socialists – this lot are nepotistic oligarchs of the highest order otherwise known as gangsters – the only thing missing is the violence to accompany the stand-overs – but it will come.
Now the government is going into building private houses and clearly are looking to privatize all school buildings .In the mean time they are increasing unemployment and lowering the tax take .I also the magic 3 billion figure has been rolled out again with regard to the school buildings .We need 3000 new class rooms so how much do they expect it to cost .So now we have 3 billion for the ferries ,hospital and now school buildings .But we gave 3 billion to land lords which would have built that hospital as well as the one at nelson