GUEST BLOG: Greg Barns SC and Craig Tuck: Asylum for Assange – How the NZ government can lead the way home for the world’s highest profile political prisoner


Julian Assange is facing politically motivated criminal charges, laid by the Trump Administration. These charges reflect an abuse of process, designed to silence Assange, and to gag media freedom. Assange’s case has profound implications for the right of the public to know the truth about government wrongdoing – particularly abroad.  In late October a court in London heard argument in an appeal by the US against a decision in January this year by Judge Vanessa Baraitser not extradite Assange.

New Zealand – as a responsible member of the international community – must stand on the side of fairness and transparency by offering Assange asylum.

While the legal process continues Assange is being kept in limbo: held in Belmarsh prison while he awaits a decision as to whether he will be deported from the UK to the United States where he faces 175 years in prison for alleged breaches of espionage laws. The evidence against him concerns the publication in 2010 and 2011 of materials (including a chilling video showing US troops killing civilians in Iraq) about the US and its allies’ tactics and war crimes there and in Afghanistan. We now know that in 2017 CIA wanted to “take him out”, or kill him, according to revelations published by Yahoo News.

The essence of the case can be summarised this way: Assange, an Australian citizen, is being prosecuted by the United States for speaking truth to power (by providing a window into nefarious activities of the military industrial complex). His motivation was the pursuit of transparency, justice, and ultimately peace.

These pursuits are central to the job of any journalist. In publishing this material, Julian Assange was doing his job – as a journalist and as a citizen. However, he has been cast adrift by the Australian government, despite it professing to be committed to values like freedom of speech and a free media. This refusal by Canberra to speak frankly to its number one friend in Washington and demand the end of the persecution of its citizen Assange provides an opportunity for New Zealand. The opportunity to uphold the human rights values which are at stake here and use its renowned independence and sense of principle to support Assange.

New Zealand has built its reputation as being at the forefront of human rights advancement, dignity and responsible citizenship – it is trusted internationally as being fair (and kind). It is in many respects a diplomatic powerhouse able to achieve agreements and navigate contentious political waters when others can’t.

Assange has always stated “The goal is justice, the method is transparency . . . . If wars can be started by lies, peace can be started by truth.” This is a totally consistent position with New Zealand’s stance on peaceful diplomacy, from Nuclear Free NZ, to the successful ‘Soldiers Without Guns’ peace mission in Bougainville.

The other reason for New Zealand involving itself in the Assange case is because of the extraordinarily dangerous precedent this case sets for journalists anywhere in the world. By way of background, the Obama administration initially declined to prosecute Assange due to what it called the “New York Times problem”—the dilemma of indicting Assange for the very same kind of investigative journalism that mainstream media practices. However under President Trump the Justice Department indicted Assange under espionage legislation.

TDB Recommends

No media outlet or journalist has ever been successfully prosecuted under the espionage laws Act for publishing truthful information in the public interest, which is protected by the First Amendment.

But the message from the US to all journalists and citizens, no matter where in the world they are, is if you publish material which Washington wishes to keep secret then you can be the subject of an extradition request.

The Assange case is not simply a bilateral issue between the US and UK or the US and Australia. It is about critical democratic values being put at risk by a dominant world power. On this basis it is time for New Zealand, with its respected voice on human rights to make a stand.

New Zealand has long established relationships with the US, UK and Australia. The persecution and plots of assassination against a South Pacific journalist for revealing war crimes, demands a clear response. New Zealand can use its position as a small principled nation to stand for its values and offer Julian Assange asylum.


Greg Barns SC and Craig Tuck – Human Rights lawyers from Australia and New Zealand.


  1. Journalists around the world are frequently detained, kidnapped and even killed – simply for reporting the news.

    In the past 30 years, at least 1,400 journalists have been killed. Yet most of those responsible for their deaths have faced no accountability.

    Unfortunately things are getting worse for Journalists everywhere but esp. in countries like The Philippine’s and Mexico

    • @Festus. Totally agree but do you mind if I expand your comment – “Unfortunately things are getting worse for Journalists everywhere but esp. in countries like The Philippine’s and Mexico”. I think the “esp. in countries like The Philipine’s and Mexico” part should specifically include the USA, now that we know that the CIA plotted to kill Mr Assange.

      Truth and accountability are concepts which are either disregarded or only paid lip service to by many countries including New Zealand and state organisations in those countries including state organisations in New Zealand.

    • And NZ governments are terrified their our own secret services. Gough Whitlam’s fate taught that lesson.
      Recall that Helen Clark repeatedly swallowed their BS over Ahmed Zaoui.

      • Great example.. . because NZ did the right thing in the end… Clark eventually withdrew that position. It took collective work to have justice done. You can either say it’s impossible, and resign yourself to do nothing, and get a predictable result… or you can join a group of people committed to making it a reality:

  2. This would be an excellent way of getting some stored cred and directing attention away from other tetchy subjects. Go for it NZ – it’s in our best interests as supposed truth-tellers and persons of integrity. We don’t want our western ideals further besmirched by the neolib dissemblers in our wonderful allies that we are accumulating like fleas. Not good this Itchy and Scratchy feeling.

  3. I agree let’s give this great man of our time, sanctuary.
    But remember our fiasco, and don’t over play the ‘how decent are we’ card. Our blotter is NOT perfectly clean.

  4. For the past year corporate media have not reported on Julian Assange and the US assault on press freedom. To offer asylum for Assange in NZ would be a grand gesture for human rights and improve our standing in the world – as did our nuclear-free stance. A good summary of the persecution of Assange. Much appreciated.

  5. Yes, asylum for Julian Assange and for his financée and 2 children.
    His ongoing treatment, torture really as the UN Rapporteur on Torture Nils Melzer tells us, is a warning to journalists everywhere.
    Very disturbing!

Comments are closed.