Raped women punished, 18month olds living in shelters & hidden suicide rates – stare the horror of the mass surveillance neoliberal welfare state in the face


We are no longer citizens with rights, we are consumers with choices 

I challenge you to stare the horror of the neoliberal welfare state in the face and recognise it for the abomination that it has become and to demand radical change within our public services.

Before the neoliberal revolution of 1984,  NZs public services and massive welfare departments were the foundations of the egalitarianism that made New Zealand special. These agencies were funded and empowered to genuinely give a damn about the welfare of the citizens they were responsible for.

These agencies were built up post Second World War 2 when Governments acknowledged and understood that the inequalities within capitalism would always make the promise of democracy empty and open to the extremes of communism and fascism. These agencies were essential to help knit the democratic society together so that all could share in the fruits of civil society.

That dramatically changed in NZ when the neoliberal economic, cultural and political revolution erupted in 1984.

These welfare agencies that were the very foundations of the egalitarian democracy we cherished were mutated from the noble aims of caring for the poor into a neoliberal welfare state whose role is not to give a damn about the most vulnerable they are tasked with helping.

For the last 35 years, these once great public services have become a cruel joke, a stick with which to beat anyone unfortunate enough to fall down the cliff.

TDB Recommends NewzEngine.com

60% of beneficiaries owe money to WINZ because WINZ refuse to tell beneficiaries what a ‘relationship’ means. WINZ then catch beneficiaries out with having a ‘relationship’ and claim that and any other overpayment from incompetence is fraud and in turn the beneficiary is hit with the costs of their ‘fraud’…

More than half of all beneficiaries owe Work and Income money

More than half of all beneficiaries now owe Work and Income money, and their debts have increased in every region over the last year.

…most beneficiaries will die before they ever pay that debt off.

That isn’t a welfare state that is helping the most vulnerable, that’s a neoliberal welfare state that is actively punishing anyone who needs help by using deceptive policy designed to entrap.

Here is an 18month old child living in deplorable shelters…

18-month-old Julia, the innocent face of modern NZ’s brutal, archaic boarding houses

Eighteen-month-old Julia Alatina is smiley, snotty-nosed, and dotted with flea bites.

She’s trusting; exchanging her toy broom, made of sticks, for a stranger’s hand to toddle off down the bloodstained hallway of a south Auckland lodge for the down and out.

There are six prams in that hallway, more in others. Julia’s not the only child sharing a bed with her parents in what is essentially a halfway house.

… and here is a rape victim who was denied welfare because she didn’t put the name of the rapist on her child’s birth certificate…

Rape victim has benefit docked by WINZ

A young rape victim who became pregnant to her attacker had her benefit docked by Work and Income New Zealand (WINZ) – because she refused to name the father of her child.

But after a lengthy battle, the government agency has finally admitted it got it wrong.

The woman – known only as Laura for privacy reasons – had the money deducted even though the law provides an exemption to the sanction if the child is born of sexual assault or incest.

The details of Laura’s first pregnancy don’t make for a pretty picture.

“I was 13 and I gave birth at 14,” she says. “I was sexually assaulted.”

She wanted to erase that memory and the culprit’s name with it.

“I don’t want to put that person on my son’s birth certificate cause I don’t want him to be known as a product of rape,” she says.

But because she wouldn’t name the father WINZ started cutting her benefit by $22 a week, rising to $28 a week.

The deductions lasted about two-and-a-half years.

…these 3 examples join hundreds of others that highlight a public service staffed by sadists who enjoy the petty power they have over the lives of others. These aren’t just policy failings, these are staff culture failures. There are debt collectors and repo agents who are employed on  the front lines of WINZ – these are not the type of human beings you want to be involved in the delicate vulnerabilities of those in need.

If Labour become the backbone of the next Government, they must be focused on purging the Public Service of these types of staff and must empower NGOs with the ability to critique and criticise these Public Service monoliths who are damaging the lives of so many.

The problem with hoping Labour will actually stand up for the weakest members of our society who are forced to put up with the cruelties of the neoliberal welfare  is Labour’s total subservience to the PSA Union.

This gutless spinelessness from Labour is the reason no reform is coming.

As well as the ongoing abuse to beneficiaries, prisoners and the most vulnerable, our Public Service are guilty of historic abuse that the Government are covering up…

‘Never again’ – HRC calls for state abuse inquiry

The Human Rights Commission is calling for the government to hold an inquiry and apologise for abuse and neglect in state institutions.

…and these neoliberal welfare state agencies are the new frontline of the mass surveillance state over beneficiaries because beneficiaries have so little power…

‘Blank cheque’ to share private information: Privacy Commissioner warning

The Privacy Commissioner has again strongly criticised legislation as giving wide-ranging and unwarranted powers to officials to share Kiwis’ private information.

John Edwards said as currently drafted anti-money laundering legislation would give officials “blank cheques” to share private information, without proper oversight.

Edwards told a Parliamentary committee today that there were a number of problems in how the Anti-Money Laundering and Countering Financing of Terrorism Amendment Bill proposed to control information sharing between government agencies and departments.

One new section in the legislation states that in the absence of regulations, information sharing can be authorised by a written agreement between agencies.

…and the Government can’t even look after the mass surveillance of beneficiaries they are collecting…

Ministry of Social Development deputy chief executive steps aside after blunder in data collection project

A high-ranking public servant is stepping aside following a review into a Ministry of Social Development blunder involving client information in a controversial information-sharing programme.

The review was into an April incident in which one organisation was able to access an organisation’s folder on a new IT system for social services providers to share personal client data with the Government.

Neoliberal mythology needs to explain the grotesque inequalities free market capitalism creates, and it explains that by telling individuals that there are no hegemonic structures of power, no class, no racism, no sexism – there is just the individual and that if you as an individual do well in life then you deserve that but if you do badly in life you also choose that.

Our neoliberal welfare agencies are there to make life so difficult for beneficiaries that they ‘choose’ not be in need or end up punishing those who do need help.

The biggest abuser of people in this country is our very own neoliberal welfare state, Labour either wake up and force change or they risk the fury of those who are forced to live under the cruelty of that neoliberal welfare state empowering a movement that will.

35 years on from the economic, political and cultural neoliberal revolution our suicide rates are possibly 3 times higher than officials admit, quarter of a million kids live in poverty and we have a prison population higher than at any other time in history.

Something has to snap.


  1. Totally agree with all this.Every time you write “neoliberal welfare” I see “neoliberal warfare” and have to look again to check.
    D J S

  2. We have a golden opportunity to change all this for better in less than four months.
    Will we be motivated enough to do that?

    • I wouldn’t hold my breath waiting for labour to change anything, they still follow the neoliberal ideology,

  3. You can change it. Vote Green. Tweedledum and tweedledee. National and Labour are happy to continue the establishment position.
    Though I have high hopes about the compassion of some of the new youngsters’ in Labour. So long as they do not get caught in the groupthink.

  4. I am still waiting for that mass uprising, even just a large enough protest, or something of that sorts, I cannot see or hear it, here in Auckland so many simply do not seem to care a fuck anymore, except for what they can get into their pockets or on their plate.

    • Yeah Mike a mass uprising is possible. But the most likely scenario is a major economic crash not seen since the depression. This would be like pushing the reset button on society. Politicians would need to look at progressive policy and the punters out there in most economic classes would support it. I believe this crash coming and will start with a major correction in the dow jones before every other market follows suit. Our housing will collapse as well. We will just have to wait and see. But reading a number of respected commentators including Steve Keen it is on the cards.

      • you have to wonder if the reason so many own money is that winz is cooking the books by booking the so called debts as an asset
        as for an uprising it could happen in a crash if thousands of middle ma and pa homeowners find themselves virtually bankrupt with unplayable debts foreclosure loss of kiwi saver.after listening to Steve keens interview on rnz its highly likely new zealand is on his list of zombie economy’s fueled by massive private debt. now 180 percent of GDP

        professor keen has some progressive ideas regarding a debt jubilee
        what ever happens the status quo is already a zombie wrecking havoc across society

    • Maybe the super wealthy, academic, liberal, elite are too busy renovating their multiple homes and booking their Business Class air tickets to protest seriously.

  5. I would support a debt write-off by Work and Income towards beneficiaries. Even if it’s targetted for the most hard struck citizens only, perhaps those with other significant debts or that have been on benefits for a prolonged period of time. The social security net transforming into a debtor’s prison system must be stopped.

    “the [privacy] legislation states that in the absence of regulations, information sharing can be authorised by a written agreement between agencies.” That is outrageous.

    “Laura” should not have to fight for close to a decade to get money entitled to her by WINZ. She might finally get the $4500 owed to her, but after so many years of stress, fight, and struggle? If you put all the hours she probably struggled and fought, and she was able to spend just some of those hours at a minimum wage job, she and the economy would be far better off. There is no reason for this. Punishing the poor hurts all of us. It’s just insane levels of cruelty.

    It’s also worth noting that people like the rape victim, “Laura” – 13! – and the child Julia in the halfway house, do not simply recover from these experiences. They usually end up struggling through extremely damaged lives, and prison, alcohol, and health problems of all kinds end up being very likely. For people in these positions, there is often just no place in their lives that is safe, stable, secure, dry, clean, quiet – the kinds of things we all take for granted when we come home and hop into bed at night. And these faces, they’re just the tip of the iceberg.

  6. You have to see to believe the load of hate mongering diatribe from the rabid right on get stuffed.co.nz and Facebook on this topic.
    All the usual rubbish about how parents make bad choices so if the kids suffer, its not my fault, I’m alright Jack and similar sentiments.
    If you ask the right whether the kids choose this or not they avoid the question and robotically repeat their stock answers.
    Fact: National doesn’t give a f.. about children living in poverty.
    Fact: giving Shonkey a Queen’s birthday honour is more important than the health of New Zealanders.
    The National government is a bunch of scumbags.
    There should be a special place on Tyburn Hill reserved for a lot of these self-serving porkers.

    • Yep i agree with you make me feel sick to read these comments knowing the agenda is always jack is no longer as good as his master…

    • Yep i agree with you make me feel sick to read these comments knowing the agenda is always jack is no longer as good as his master…

Comments are closed.