Transcript: PQT Commentary Wednesday July 3 With Gareth Hughes & Martyn Bradbury

By   /   July 3, 2013  /   Comments Off on Transcript: PQT Commentary Wednesday July 3 With Gareth Hughes & Martyn Bradbury

TDB recommends Voyager - Unlimited internet @home as fast as you can get

At 2pm Wednesday PQT host Martyn Bradbury was joined by MP Gareth Hughes: (direct from the debating chamber) to take part in TDB Live’s Parliamentary Question Time feature PQT.

Source: TDBLive Transcripts –

Headline: Transcript: PQT Commentary Wednesday July 3 With Gareth Hughes & Martyn Bradbury

TDB-Parl-Live-Coming-Up!5bAt 2pm Wednesday PQT host Martyn Bradbury was joined by MP Gareth Hughes: (direct from the debating chamber) to take part in TDB Live’s Parliamentary Question Time feature PQT.

The following is a transcript of the commentary:

1:40 PM Martyn Bradbury: It’s 16 degrees in Wellington today

1:44 PM Martyn Bradbury: 77% humidity

1:45 PM Martyn Bradbury: a friendly 19km/h wind greets vistors to the Capital today

1:45 PM Martyn Bradbury: Gareth Hughes is our guest MP live from the debating chamber today at 2pm

2:00 PM Martyn Bradbury: Question 1 DAVID SHEARER to the Prime Minister: Does he stand by all his statements and have confidence in the statements of all his Ministers?

2:01 PM Gareth Hughes: Question Time kicks off.

2:01 PM Gareth Hughes: No prayer today because we are in urgency and in Parliamentary terms it is Tuesday

2:02 PM Martyn Bradbury: Key pushes off questions about electricity costs – points out Labour had its share

2:02 PM Martyn Bradbury: Labour could counter that they have learned the hard way and that’s why we need the Green/Labour policy on electricity

2:02 PM Gareth Hughes: its true but at least Labour has acknolwedged the current flaws and have a good plan for cheaper power – very similar to ours!

2:03 PM Martyn Bradbury: Key claims ‘Stalinism’

2:03 PM Gareth Hughes: Key tying himself in knots, can’t say if current prices are fair or not

2:03 PM Martyn Bradbury: I don’t think Key would have a grip on Satlinism if Stalin rose from the grave and bit him

2:04 PM Martyn Bradbury: Key doing a poor job of answering any questions – just school yard teasing

2:05 PM Gareth Hughes: shows how the response strategy is illogical attack

2:06 PM Martyn Bradbury: Metiria Turei questioning Key on pimping for a Casino

2:07 PM Martyn Bradbury: Met calling the deal dirty

2:08 PM Gareth Hughes: no personal/conscience vote on Sky City

2:08 PM Martyn Bradbury: Metiria showing how an Opposition asks questions

2:09 PM Gareth Hughes: calling it as it is

2:09 PM Martyn Bradbury: METIRIA TUREI to the Minister for Economic Development: Does he stand by the Prime Minister’s statement “the Government has been very transparent about its dealings with SkyCity”?

2:09 PM Gareth Hughes: PM refused to answer Metiria’s primary question, so he transfered it

2:10 PM Martyn Bradbury: Gerry is scrambling

2:12 PM Gareth Hughes: Key is trying to avoid answering on his own statement!

2:13 PM Martyn Bradbury: How hard do the greens have to work to just get a straight answer out of the Prime Minister!

2:14 PM Gareth Hughes: Quite a fair point from Metiria, what is Key’s reason?

2:15 PM Martyn Bradbury: Metiria schooling the Speaker

2:16 PM Gareth Hughes: Yeah the Speaker has made it harder to get straight answers

2:16 PM Gareth Hughes: I think it’s a few bad calls

2:17 PM Martyn Bradbury: Key avoids answering any questions about how corrupt or not his Sky City deal is

2:18 PM Gareth Hughes: The Speaker calls it ridiculous but thisis important – whether the opposition can ask the PM questions without them just being transferred away

2:19 PM Gareth Hughes: Metiria voluntararily withdraws her primary question because the PM won’t front and answer it

2:20 PM Martyn Bradbury: If Key has nothing to hide, he should front on it

2:20 PM Martyn Bradbury: Question 3 ALFRED NGARO to the Minister of Finance: What recent developments have further contributed to building the closer economic market between New Zealand and Australia?

2:21 PM Martyn Bradbury: I don’t know about you Gareth, but NZ neveer seems to get its fair share out the NZ/Australia relationship

2:22 PM Gareth Hughes: It is dissapointing a question has to be given up in protest but shows Green strength of feeling that we should be able t ask the PM a straight question on an important public issue

2:22 PM Martyn Bradbury: NZers don’t have access to social services in Australia, we still have issues flying domestically inside Australia and we only just got our apples in

2:22 PM Gareth Hughes: Sorry, had to duck off the computer to move around our supplementary question allocation.

2:22 PM Martyn Bradbury: Her withdrawel of the question was the honourable thing to do

2:23 PM Gareth Hughes: sounds like good PhD thesis ‘ what has NZ got out of Trans-Tasman relationship

2:23 PM Martyn Bradbury: Question 4 GRANT ROBERTSON to the Minister of Education: Does she stand by all her statements?

2:23 PM Gareth Hughes: Parata answering questions is always interesting

2:24 PM Martyn Bradbury: I have grown to like Grant Robertson more and more

2:24 PM Martyn Bradbury: He is very good in the house

2:24 PM Gareth Hughes: ….when she actually answers them!

2:25 PM Gareth Hughes: Yeah I agree

2:26 PM Martyn Bradbury: Cutting money for industry training in a recession as steep as the one we have faced seems like economic vandalism

2:27 PM Gareth Hughes: They should have increased training to help us have a more skilled workforce and prosper when we came out of recession

2:28 PM Martyn Bradbury: $83million taken out of Polytechs – ouch. How can National rage against Uni education whil cutting trades courses? When was education a hate crime?

2:28 PM Gareth Hughes: Robertson says 5 years under National and they should take responsibility for lack of tradespeople, Parata just passes the buck saying it’s not her portfolio

2:28 PM Martyn Bradbury: Question 5 Peseta SAM LOTU-IIGA to the Minister of Science and Innovation: What investment is the Government making in business-related science, innovation and research?

2:29 PM Gareth Hughes: Another patsy question no doubt written by Minister’s office

2:30 PM Martyn Bradbury: Steven Joyce as Minsiter of Science and Innovation – he’s like Dr Evil minus the phd

2:30 PM Martyn Bradbury: Where would investment go for a green economy Gareth?

2:31 PM Gareth Hughes: I’ve always wondered where the innovation was happening?

2:32 PM Gareth Hughes: Bit of a zinger from Joyce, just reminded me of Key forgetting Na’s name

2:32 PM Martyn Bradbury: Who would fund R&D under a green Government?

2:33 PM Gareth Hughes: do you mean Govt agency or public/private split?

2:33 PM Martyn Bradbury: both

2:34 PM Gareth Hughes: We took a plan for an extra $1B in Govt R&D funding over 3 years last election which I think was popular.

2:34 PM Martyn Bradbury: Question 6 Hon DAVID PARKER to the Minister of Finance: How much have investors lost on the value of their Mighty River Power shares compared with the price at float on May 10 and what effect will

2:34 PM Martyn Bradbury: this have on the price the Government expects to receive if it proceeds with the partial float of Meridian?

2:34 PM Gareth Hughes: We really do lag behind other countries in terms of public and private R&D and the Govt can show leadership and help build a smarter more prosperous economy

2:35 PM Martyn Bradbury: Where is the justice in just 2.5% of NZers owning assets that we once all owned?

2:35 PM Gareth Hughes: Merdian sale will be a lot harder than MRP for the Govt. They should just flag it and keep it Kiwi.

2:36 PM Gareth Hughes: No justice, just another hand-out to a small minority

2:37 PM Gareth Hughes: Parker rightfully points out how many times the asset money has been allocated to different projects

2:37 PM Martyn Bradbury: Nice dig by Parker

2:38 PM Martyn Bradbury: Shouldn’t the cost of the new assets like schools and public transport be paid through taxation as opposed to selling off our energy assets?

2:39 PM Martyn Bradbury: Parker pointing out the many mouths the National Party has spoken out of to explain where the money is going

2:39 PM Gareth Hughes: absolutely, they’ve been earning healthy returns and allow us to drive cheaper, cleaner power for Kiwis so it’s like buring the furniture to keep warm

2:40 PM Martyn Bradbury: Question 7 Dr CAM CALDER to the Minister of Education: What reports has she received on the NCEA Level 2 results of last year’s school leavers?

2:41 PM Martyn Bradbury: Can not believe Hekia is holding up the successes of the very same public education system she is trying to dismantal

2:42 PM Martyn Bradbury: So what Hekia is saying is that our Public Education isn’t the terrible beast she’s trying to slay after all

2:42 PM Martyn Bradbury: Question 8 DARIEN FENTON to the Minister of Labour: Does he stand by all his statements on safety in the forestry industry?

2:44 PM Martyn Bradbury: Darien pointing out the Minister isn’t listening to the real dangers within Forestry

2:45 PM Martyn Bradbury: Simon Bridges angry

2:45 PM Gareth Hughes: Terrible little episode, Bridge’s outburst about workplace deaths

2:45 PM Gareth Hughes: I’d rather a Minister angry and fired up about workplace safey not partisan point scoring in Parliament.

2:45 PM Martyn Bradbury: Attacking Helen Kelly doesn’t seem like a smart move

2:46 PM Martyn Bradbury: Question 9 DENIS O’ROURKE to the Minister for Social Development: Does she consider the direct deduction policy of overseas pensions from New Zealand Superannuation under section 70 of the Social

2:46 PM Martyn Bradbury: Security Act 1964, to be fair and consistent?

2:46 PM Gareth Hughes: yes, I question a lot of what Bridge’s does. Seriously what has he done that is positive as a Minister, attacking protests, cosying up to oil, weakening industrial legislation….

2:47 PM Martyn Bradbury: National and NZ First squabbling over who loves elderly voters the most

2:47 PM Gareth Hughes: Interesting that Peters isn’t asking the NZ First primary question today

2:49 PM Martyn Bradbury: Question 10: CHRIS HIPKINS to the Minister of Education: Has she read and understood each Cabinet paper she has signed off as Minister of Education?

2:49 PM Martyn Bradbury: This looks

2:49 PM Martyn Bradbury: Hekia only replying in Maori

2:50 PM Gareth Hughes: Great to see Te Reo in the House

2:51 PM Martyn Bradbury: Hekia looks like she has been caught out here

2:51 PM Martyn Bradbury: That will be interesting

2:51 PM Martyn Bradbury: Question 1

1: EUGENIE SAGE to the Associate Minister Health: Is the Minister concerned that in 2011/12 92,000 New Zealanders relied on drinking water supplies with an excessive number of E. coli breach

2:51 PM Martyn Bradbury: which are a marker of faecal contamination, and if not, why not?

2:52 PM Gareth Hughes: good Minister is concerned over faecies in our water

2:52 PM Martyn Bradbury: I saw an interesting interview with Fed Famers on Firstline

2:52 PM Martyn Bradbury: they said it had NOTHING to do with cow waste into water, he said it was the urban areas that were the problems

2:52 PM Gareth Hughes: An extra 20,000 Kiwis saw dodgy water!

2:52 PM Martyn Bradbury: counter comments to that Gareth?

2:54 PM Gareth Hughes: Less money for cleaner water under National but lots more for dairy intensification

2:55 PM Gareth Hughes: i haven’t read the report but I think we need to up our game on rural and urban water supplies

2:56 PM Martyn Bradbury: If we make a huge amount from Dairy, and there is a never ending thirst for a western diet rich in dairy, how do we riegn those interests in for the environment?

2:57 PM Martyn Bradbury: Final question COLIN KING to the Associate Minister Education: What recent announcements have been made to support digital literacy, particularly in low-income communities?

2:57 PM Gareth Hughes: we make sure we do it well. We ill never win racing other countries to damage our environment faster than they are, through things like cramming more cows on paddocks.

2:58 PM Gareth Hughes: we need to focus on valuable NZ clean green brand, value-add, niches to return higher returns

2:58 PM Martyn Bradbury: Nikki Kaye working hard here, most of these initiatives are positive?

2:58 PM Gareth Hughes: Digital literacy and the digital divide big issue facing NZ, the Govt just a drop in the bucket

2:59 PM Martyn Bradbury: Cheers Gareth – see you tomorrow at 2pm

2:59 PM Gareth Hughes: That’s it for today, back to Urgency. Thanks again for the opportunity.

The claims and opinions made in this statement are those of the release organisation and are not necessarily endorsed by, and are not necessarily those of, The Daily Blog. Also in no event shall The Daily Blog be responsible or liable, directly or indirectly, for any damage or loss caused or alleged to be caused by or in connection with the use of or reliance on the above release content.

Want to support this work? Donate today
Follow us on Twitter & Facebook

Authorised by Martyn Bradbury, The Editor, TheDailyBlog,