You are here:  Home  >  Raw News feed  >  Current Article

Transcript: PQT Commentary Tuesday July 2 With Gareth Hughes & Martyn Bradbury

By   /  July 3, 2013  /  Comments Off on Transcript: PQT Commentary Tuesday July 2 With Gareth Hughes & Martyn Bradbury

    Print       Email
Source: TDBLive Transcripts – Transcript of Live Event:

Headline: Transcript: PQT Commentary Tuesday July 2 With Gareth Hughes & Martyn Bradbury

TDB-Parl-Live-Coming-Up!5bAt 2pm Tuesday PQT host Martyn Bradbury was joined by MP Gareth Hughes: (direct from the debating chamber) to take part in TDB Live’s Parliamentary Question Time feature PQT. The following is a transcript of the commentary:

1:30 PM: Martyn Bradbury: It’s 14 degrees in Wellington

1:30 PM: Martyn Bradbury: Humidity is 76%

1:30 PM: Martyn Bradbury: a cool wind of 6km per hour wafts across Parliament lawns

1:31 PM: Martyn Bradbury: We are joined live from the debating chamber at question time today by Gareth Hughes who will be live commentating Parliament Question Time

1:35 PM Gareth Hughes: Looking forward to starting this at 2

1:58 PM : Gareth Hughes: Have just takwn my seat. MPs filing in

1:58 PM: Martyn Bradbury: Welcome

1:58 PM: Martyn Bradbury: Big day with Pita’s announcement

1:59 PM : Gareth Hughes: will have to apologise for spelling in advance. Im pretty bad at the best of times and will try and tap as fast as I can

1:59 PM : Gareth Hughes: Yup big day in Parliament, after a 1 week recess, just after Ikaroa Rawhiti, and lots happening.

2:00 PM: Martyn Bradbury: The Speaker entering the House

2:01 PM: Martyn Bradbury: Immediatly starts mauling the Maori language

2:03 PM : Gareth Hughes: Good to see some Reo in the House, but the big question is, did the Speaker practise…at all?

2:03 PM: Martyn Bradbury: …at

2:04 PM: Martyn Bradbury: all…..?

2:04 PM : Gareth Hughes: I’m not normlly here for the prayer, I find it terrible we have an Anglican prayer in NZs Parliament. I would prefer a nonreligious and definitley a non-sectarian acknowledgement, preferrably also in

2:04 PM : Gareth Hughes: Te Reo

2:05 PM : Gareth Hughes: Great to be here on this platofrm today. Thanks The Daily Blog for this piece of innovation

2:05 PM: Martyn Bradbury: Yes the prayer seems dated doesn’t it?

2:05 PM: Martyn Bradbury: Welcome, you of course are a veteran of online discussions

2:06 PM: Martyn Bradbury: The Greens lead at that type of online interaction with voters and should be saluted

2:06 PM : Gareth Hughes: I’m asking a question today at Q12 so I wont comment on that

2:06 PM: Martyn Bradbury: I’ll say eneough for both of us

2:06 PM: Martyn Bradbury: Question 1 Rt Hon WINSTON PETERS to the Prime Minister: Does he stand by all his statements?

2:06 PM : Gareth Hughes: Interesting the Govt just blocked a non-debatable motion on UN Security Council, given it had been negotiated and agreed to in advance

2:07 PM: Martyn Bradbury: Winston probing on the Kim Dotcom details

2:07 PM : Gareth Hughes: Peters asks the good ‘ol catch all question, that at least makes sure the PM doesn’t try and pass it on to another minister

2:08 PM: Martyn Bradbury: Mr Key giving him nothing

2:08 PM: Martyn Bradbury: DAVID SHEARER to the Prime Minister: Does he stand by all his statements?

2:09 PM: Martyn Bradbury: Key answers with a snip at Shearer’s leadership

2:09 PM : Gareth Hughes: Shearer versus Key on husing

2:09 PM: Martyn Bradbury: Shearer bounces back asking questiuons about home affordability

2:09 PM : Gareth Hughes: Im not sure if you can hear it on the telly or live stream Key has this wierd intake of air through his teeth after answering a question

2:10 PM: Martyn Bradbury: like a lizard man

2:10 PM : Gareth Hughes: Housing is a key political question facing our country and I doubt many Kiwis have confidence in National delivering

2:10 PM: Martyn Bradbury: Key is comfortable with it, shrugs off any real questions about housing affordability

2:11 PM : Gareth Hughes: It’s amazing how ‘relaxed’ he is about everything. More laid back than a Gisborne Sunday afternoon

2:12 PM: Martyn Bradbury: It plays to NZs anti-intellectualism doesn’t it though?

2:12 PM: Martyn Bradbury: If Key is comfortable all the time, there isn’t any reason to debate

2:12 PM : Gareth Hughes: yes, and I think he is a master at going over the press gallery direct to Kiwis

2:12 PM : Gareth Hughes: Labour now on capital gains tax

2:13 PM : Gareth Hughes: this is something you would expect National would support

2:13 PM: Martyn Bradbury: Capital Gains tax is hard isn’t it Gareth? Most NZers who own property have a false sense of wealth through their over valued property values

2:13 PM : Gareth Hughes: Goldsmith the new chair of Finance and Expenditure Committee asking on economy

2:13 PM: Martyn Bradbury: which politician will pop that delusion of wealth with a capital gains tax?

2:14 PM: Martyn Bradbury: Question 3 PAUL GOLDSMITH to the Minister of Finance: What reports has he received on business and economic conditions in New Zealand?

2:14 PM: Martyn Bradbury: Patsy from Goldsmith

2:14 PM: Martyn Bradbury: Bill English doing a good job of keeping Judith Collins at bay as the next leader

2:14 PM : Gareth Hughes: on CGT I want a fair, system that encourages productive investment not speculation in housing that pushes up the price of housing away from low and middle income Kiwis.

2:15 PM : Gareth Hughes: …you think English next leader?

2:15 PM : Gareth Hughes: I remember when he was last leader!

2:15 PM: Martyn Bradbury: But how do you sell that notion to a middle class whose only investment is inflated property prices?

2:15 PM: Martyn Bradbury: I don’t think Bill wants to sit on the throne of swords

2:15 PM: Martyn Bradbury: I think he likes being the Kings Hand

2:16 PM: Martyn Bradbury: It’s not Parliamentary Question Time commentary session without a GoT reference

2:16 PM : Gareth Hughes: nice analogy. So who are the Greens in GOT?

2:16 PM: Martyn Bradbury: oh that’s a good question

2:17 PM: Martyn Bradbury: The family who all got murdered at the wedding

2:17 PM: Martyn Bradbury: by the Labour Party

2:17 PM: Martyn Bradbury: David Parker pointing out the rising inequality

2:17 PM: Martyn Bradbury: Rising inequality the big issue for 2014 Gareth?

2:18 PM : Gareth Hughes: say it ‘aint so! The Wildings breaching The Wall maybe?

2:18 PM : Gareth Hughes: yes it is, asnd has been for a number of years. Good to see Labour asking about jobs. Its a huge problem.

2:18 PM: Martyn Bradbury: How are oil and gas a long term economic industry Gareth?

2:18 PM : Gareth Hughes: Fracking and risky deep sea drilling isn’t the answer

2:19 PM: Martyn Bradbury: Big Rus stepping up

2:19 PM : Gareth Hughes: It has lowest job producing potential of any sector in Taranaki economy, profits flow offshore, $46m in tax breaks this year and forth lowest royalty plus tax rate in the world

2:19 PM: Martyn Bradbury: Dr RUSSEL NORMAN to the Prime Minister: Does he stand by his answer to written question 07314 (2013) when he said: “The inquiry team, itself, did not seek permission from Peter Dunne before it obtaine

2:19 PM: Martyn Bradbury: obtained his email logs” and does he think it should have?

2:20 PM: Martyn Bradbury: Did Henry Inq. get persmission from Dunne for email logs?

2:20 PM: Martyn Bradbury: ‘need to check, best of my knolwdge no’ is the answer

2:20 PM : Gareth Hughes: Dodgy, dodgy saga for the Govt

2:20 PM: Martyn Bradbury: Where has Key gotten his authority to spy on Dunne

2:21 PM : Gareth Hughes: suprised he didnt say he was relaxed

2:22 PM: Martyn Bradbury: Looking for written questions – he’s on thin ice here

2:22 PM: Martyn Bradbury: Trying to use Russel’s demand for transperancy as a justifictation to spy on Peter Dunne’s emails – totally stagering

2:23 PM : Gareth Hughes: yeah amazing

2:23 PM : Gareth Hughes: key just goes on attack and wont front

2:23 PM: Martyn Bradbury: It obviously wasn’t ‘quite clear’ that Key spelt out he was going to invade a politicians privacu to view emails between them and a journalist

2:24 PM : Gareth Hughes: thats the key question, who gave Henry the authority to acess Dunne’s info?

2:24 PM: Martyn Bradbury: Who authorised Henry to do it? We can’t have the bloody PM authorizing these sort of things – he isn’t a King!

2:26 PM: Martyn Bradbury: Turning this on Russel is pretty absurd

2:26 PM: Martyn Bradbury: The PM has gone well beyond his powers here

2:27 PM : Gareth Hughes: Just another example of the anti-democratic, secretive and snooping instincs of this Govt

2:28 PM : Gareth Hughes: I dont like the idea the PM has the authority and has snopped on MPs meta data from Parliamentary servers

2:28 PM: Martyn Bradbury: Key is actually worse than Muldoon, not as bad as

2:28 PM: Martyn Bradbury: Question 5 SIMON O’CONNOR to the Minister of Transport: How will the Government progress the delivery of the next generation of transport projects for Auckland?

2:28 PM : Gareth Hughes: They both operated in different times and contexts but there is an authoritarian, corporate-style big Government similarity between the two

2:29 PM: Martyn Bradbury: As long as whatever public transport benefits SkyCity, National will back it

2:29 PM : Gareth Hughes: Funny watching Gerry back flip on loop

2:29 PM : Gareth Hughes: link, link, I always get emails when I call it the loop not the link

2:29 PM: Martyn Bradbury: If there was no SkyCity stop on the loop, there’s no way they would’ve bothered

2:30 PM: Martyn Bradbury: link

2:30 PM: Martyn Bradbury: Seeing as National are unlikely to be in power in 2020, promising to pay for it when they aren’t the ones paying is p[retty easy

2:30 PM : Gareth Hughes: Its going to be a transformative project for Ak and great they finally support but a little rich given their vehement opposition

2:31 PM : Gareth Hughes: Plenty of silly things Joyce and Brownlee have said about it to remind them of in QT

2:31 PM: Martyn Bradbury: If it’s such a good idea, why aren’t we starting it now?

2:31 PM: Martyn Bradbury: Not 2020

2:31 PM: Martyn Bradbury: Now

2:31 PM : Gareth Hughes: exactly, it’s going to take a while to build so lets get cracking. See I’m not against digging all hole, just the silly
holes for fracking and deep, deep at sea

2:32 PM: Martyn Bradbury: It’s a public transport carrot forever out of reach of Auckland

2:33 PM : Gareth Hughes: Point of Order battle. This Speaker has really reduced info being tabled in Parliament

2:33 PM: Martyn Bradbury: Trev having a go

2:33 PM : Gareth Hughes: I don’t get what the big problem sharing info with MPs is

2:34 PM: Martyn Bradbury: Question 6

2:34 PM : Gareth Hughes: ….sounds like a date after QT today?

2:34 PM: Martyn Bradbury: Hon DAVID PARKER to the Minister of Finance: Are the proceeds from selling power companies and other assets being used to pay down debt, to build schools and hospitals, to fund irrigation projects, to

2:34 PM: Martyn Bradbury: to rebuild Christchurch, or to fund Auckland transport projects?

2:35 PM: Martyn Bradbury: selling off public assets to buy new assets isn’t growing the pie, it’s hollowing out all the filling and leaving us with a dry crust

2:35 PM: Martyn Bradbury: Why are we investing in irrigation Gareth?

2:35 PM: Martyn Bradbury: Surely an industry like Dairy can afford their own irrigation program?

2:36 PM: Martyn Bradbury: David Parker swimming up hill here

2:36 PM : Gareth Hughes: well one sector of the NZ economy (that the Govt happens to like very much) wants taxpayer funds to help their profits

2:36 PM: Martyn Bradbury: English shrugging off the obvious flaws in all of this

2:36 PM : Gareth Hughes: its curious why the Govt subsidises intensive dairy and oil, when they are such profitable industries

2:37 PM: Martyn Bradbury: Exactly, why do we have to sell public assets to fund the Dairy industry who are making more from their product than at any other time?

2:38 PM: Martyn Bradbury: Isn’t this sort of corporate welfare the very worst Parliament has to offer?

2:38 PM : Gareth Hughes: English seems to be more combatitive in QT lately I think. He used to focus more on details in a measured manner and lay out the pro and con arguments.

2:38 PM : Gareth Hughes: Must of got a memo from Joyce to attack, attack and attack the Greens and progressive economic ideas some more

2:39 PM: Martyn Bradbury: National are running out of coalition partners, I’d be annoyed and angry as well

2:39 PM: Martyn Bradbury: Question 7: IAN McKELVIE to the Minister of Police: What updates has she received on how Police are using technology to prevent crime?

2:39 PM: Martyn Bradbury: I’m always dubious about expanding Police powers

2:39 PM : Gareth Hughes: GCSB the answer?

2:39 PM: Martyn Bradbury: there doesn’t seem to be any real oversight of their tactics or behaviour

2:40 PM : Gareth Hughes: No, unlike other countries we seem to have a very weak oversight. “She’ll be right” won’t always be right

2:40 PM: Martyn Bradbury: The question should be, how will we ensure this new technology won’t be abused?

2:41 PM : Gareth Hughes: Technology can help Govt services but no a silver bullet and there are fears how it will be used.

2:41 PM: Martyn Bradbury: With such a low crime rate why are we building more private prisons ?

2:42 PM: Martyn Bradbury: Kris brings up some issues about the devices that were censored before report was sent out

2:43 PM: Martyn Bradbury: Question 8 JACINDA ARDERN to the Minister of Finance: Does he agree with The Economist that “inequality is one of the biggest social, economic and political challenges of our time”; if so, what is his

2:43 PM: Martyn Bradbury: what is his Government doing to address the fact that New Zealand now has the widest income gap since detailed records began?

2:43 PM : Gareth Hughes: even I read the Economist!

2:43 PM: Martyn Bradbury: Who doesn’t read the Economist?

2:44 PM: Martyn Bradbury: This is always the problem for Labour when they bring up inequality isn’t it?

2:44 PM : Gareth Hughes: English is fudging and ignoring one of the biggest issues facing our country.

2:44 PM: Martyn Bradbury: Whenever you point out how inequality has grown, it also grew under Labour

2:44 PM : Gareth Hughes: yes, but Labour need to say we could of done more but have a good plan and are committedd to reducing inequaity

2:44 PM : Gareth Hughes: National have been in office a long time now and need to take this seriously

2:45 PM: Martyn Bradbury: We need political parties that will challenge dog whistle talkback rhetoric with real policy that helps the poor, rather than politicians who want to manage dog whistle talkback rhetoric

2:46 PM : Gareth Hughes: yeah. I believe all Kiwis support a fair go for everyone and we don’t have that in NZ in 2013.

2:46 PM: Martyn Bradbury: English in poverty denial now

2:47 PM: Martyn Bradbury: See no inequality. Hear no inequality. Speak no inequality isn’t much of a social policy is it?

2:47 PM : Gareth Hughes: I wonder if the years in a ministerial limo have reduced his access to Kiwis facing real poverty.

2:47 PM : Gareth Hughes: If you spent your time talking to Sky City, Anardarko and Warners I am sure you would have a different take on the world, different to that of a beneficary struggling

2:48 PM: Martyn Bradbury: National seem to think social mobility is being able to get facebook on your i-phone

2:48 PM : Gareth Hughes: ….or a parliamentary cleaner as Ardern points out

2:50 PM : Gareth Hughes: ooooh Collins is so nasty

2:50 PM: Martyn Bradbury: Question 9 PAUL FOSTER-BELL to the Minister of Justice: How is the Government improving its justice and other services to local communities?

2:50 PM : Gareth Hughes: even in patsy questions she can’t but help a nasty comment. She’s the same on Twitter

2:51 PM: Martyn Bradbury: She is to the right of Caligula

2:51 PM: Martyn Bradbury: Question 10 Hon LIANNE DALZIEL to the Minister for Canterbury Earthquake Recovery: When was he first made aware of the September IANZ report which warned the Christchurch City Council that “Continued

2:51 PM: Martyn Bradbury: accreditation beyond May 2013 will depend on a satisfactory outcome of that assessment” and was he advised by CERA or a Ministerial colleague?

2:51 PM: Martyn Bradbury: this is an incredible taking over of powers in Christchurch is it not Gareth?

2:52 PM : Gareth Hughes: this is a pretty incredible step taken by IANZ. Wonder what the Govts involvement was?

2:52 PM: Martyn Bradbury: Should Central Government do tis often? To step in and over ride the local authorities?

2:53 PM : Gareth Hughes: No they shouldn’t and it should only be in extraordinary circumstances. Its been used too many times by this Govt

2:53 PM: Martyn Bradbury: It’s a terrible slap in the face to the people of Christchurch is it not?

2:54 PM : Gareth Hughes: I may be wrong but I understand this was an independnet body that removed accreditation. Big question is, what did Govt do to support or work with IANZ

2:54 PM : Gareth Hughes: Is Brownlee now the biggest cheerleader os the man he once called a clown?

2:54 PM: Martyn Bradbury: An independent body answerable to the Government?

2:55 PM: Martyn Bradbury: Question 11 JONATHAN YOUNG to the Minister of Broadcasting: What progress has been made on the regional rollout of the digital switchover for New Zealand television viewers?

2:55 PM : Gareth Hughes: About to ask my Maui’s dolphin question. Catch you afterwards

2:56 PM: Martyn Bradbury: What happens to reginional TV after the switch over?

2:56 PM: Martyn Bradbury: Kordia have sold all the frequencies they were supposed to hold onto for regional TV

2:56 PM: Martyn Bradbury: And the Ministry of Culture doesn’t see to have any answers

2:57 PM: Martyn Bradbury: Question 1

2: GARETH HUGHES to the Minister of Conservation: Will he implement the recommendations to protect Maui’s dolphins contained in the report of this year’s meeting of the International Whaling

2:57 PM: Martyn Bradbury: Commission Scientific Committee; if not, why not?

2:58 PM: Martyn Bradbury: Good question

3:01 PM: Martyn Bradbury: Didn’t really answer the question did he?

3:02 PM : Gareth Hughes: So the Govt is sitting on their hands as this species goes extinct,

3:02 PM: Martyn Bradbury: I think that’s pretty much their response

3:02 PM : Gareth Hughes: its a real pitty the Speaker didnt make him answer the last question. On one area set net fishing is banned but not trawling, and I want ed to know if he would

3:03 PM: Martyn Bradbury: dolphins don’t vote for National

3:03 PM: Martyn Bradbury: Question to Members: JACINDA ARDERN to the Chairperson of the Social Services Committee: On which date and time, if any, did he receive the Minister for Social Development’s written responses to the

3:03 PM: Martyn Bradbury: pre-hearing questions for the 2013/14 Estimates review for Vote Social Development?

3:03 PM : Gareth Hughes: that’s true fishers may. The fact is, international consumers wont want to buy our seafood if the smallest and rarest dolphin goes extinct

3:03 PM: Martyn Bradbury: JACINDA ARDERN to the Chairperson of the Social Services Committee: On what date did the Minister for Social Development appear before the Committee to answer questions regarding the 2013/14 Estimates

3:04 PM: Martyn Bradbury: review for Vote Social Development?

3:04 PM : Gareth Hughes: Now on Questions for Members, they arent common but a good way to get info our of select committee chairs. Very tight question rules

3:05 PM: Martyn Bradbury: Dr MEGAN WOODS to the Chairperson of the Education and Science Committee: Did he consider inviting the Minister to appear again to answer questions around responses to questions on the 2013/14

3:05 PM: Martyn Bradbury: Estimates for Vote Education, if so, did he receive any advice about the Minister’s willingness to appear again?

3:05 PM : Gareth Hughes: Thanks very much for the oportunity to be part of this today.
Looking forward to it tomorrow.

3:06 PM: Martyn Bradbury: Thank you Gareth

3:06 PM: Martyn Bradbury: See you tomorrow at 2pm

3:06 PM : Gareth Hughes: I’ve got to go get my caucus prepared for the business of the house today then Business Commitee then speaking on the Royal Sucession Bill

3:06 PM : Gareth Hughes: see ya

The claims and opinions made in this statement are those of the release organisation and are not necessarily endorsed by, and are not necessarily those of, The Daily Blog. Also in no event shall The Daily Blog be responsible or liable, directly or indirectly, for any damage or loss caused or alleged to be caused by or in connection with the use of or reliance on the above release content.

Want to support this work? Donate today
Follow us on Twitter & Facebook
    Print       Email

You might also like...

JustSpeak responds to He Waka Roitmata

Read More →