Young progressives, I’m sorry to tell you that you have lost a father figure this week. A father of your movement Chris Skytrotter was killed by an evil turncoat known as Darth Boomer.
Okay, okay, spoiler alert, skip to the end, Skytrotter is Darth Boomer. The real question is how did the progressive movement lose one of its best to the dark side? Thankfully we don’t need 3 prequels and a really gloopy love story to find out.
He started off such a promising young progressive commentator, fighting for a progressive, Scandinavian style democracy in New Zealand. But as time has gone on, Trotter like many baby boomers appears to have become corrupted by the dark side. He is now strangely conservative, desperate to protect the status quo. Why?
It is hard to tell exactly what Trotter is arguing, as it is mostly a ranting ad hominem attack rather than a discussion of ideas. He tries to portray Gareth as being a neoliberal to the right of ACT, but if he has actually looked at the policies then he clearly doesn’t know what he is talking about or understand the realities of the modern economy.
But occasionally he cobbles a coherent sentence together. He argues that because Key has done nothing, we are currently living in the New Zealand Clark and Cullen would have wanted. Nothing to see here, nothing to change. We should be happy and grateful.
Never mind the growing gap between rich and poor. The introduction of Working for Families by Clark and Cullen only slowed that, but Key’s refusal to control the property rort has opened it even wider. Never mind the growing numbers of struggling families, and children falling behind due to poor health, education or housing. Why give money to struggling families with young kiddies; Trotter is too worried about keeping his fat NZ Super check to do that.
And housing? Sure it is unaffordable, trapping young people out of the market. But heaven forbid someone wants to take away the gravy train of unearned capital gains. Trotter is starting to sound like he is blue through and through.
So what happened? We need to remember that Trotter is a baby boomer. He started out with ideals but his generation has benefitted from rising house prices, environmental destruction and cushy Super. It is hard to be progressive when you are on the side of the winners. He doesn’t care that the status quo is unaffordable and unsustainable.
The thing is that Trotter was not alone in the list of old progressives turning his back on progress. There are plenty of others, like Auckland Council’s Mike Lee who opposed the Unitary Plan to chase the votes of the NIMBY baby boomers. In fact, the core supporters of the Old Left look like Trotter and Lee, so they won’t be shaking up the status quo any time soon.
Both the major political parties know which side their bread is buttered on, and won’t think to question the Baby Boomer Empire for fear of losing their votes. National and Labour should get over this pretence of differences and come together in a Grand Baby Boomer Cartel, I mean Coalition.
Which in reality, is what we have had for 30 years. Trotter once railed against this cartel, but now he takes comfort in it, knowing it buffers him from scary changes and protects his interests. No wonder the young feel abandoned by the Left and are disengaging from politics.
So what do we learn from this, kids? The first is that if you are lucky to find yourself on the side of the winners, check to make sure you haven’t crossed to the dark side. The second is that the issues are no longer a matter of Left and Right, the dividing line is old and young. If young people want a fair go then they have to cast aside all the political choices the Establishment Empire is throwing up. Across the spectrum from Trotter and Co to Brash and Co – they are out to screw you and screw you properly.
Geoff Simmons
TOP Chief of Staff
First of all national income accountants who think a lot about the over all economy and how to measure it and structure the data, they have been struggling for decades about what to do with the economy because GDP is created by national income accountants by adding up value added activity and this is where GDP comes from – what is the value added to the maori economy? Answering the question of what value can be added to the economy is so difficult that essentially national accounting statisticians have to make up fictional value and just add it onto GDP figures. We can say this is what the economy maybe doing because essentially there is no value added, their is value extracted. So really you need to subtract value add from GDP figures.
We need to look at where the money is going and that makes the whole economy make sense. So if crown funds is extended for productive purposes we will be fine. That is simple credit guidance that says you can speculate but not with public funds.
Why no byline ?
your both wrong. who the hell am I going to vote for? its not baby boomers vs millenials, but we do need real change.
And he is not alone – plenty of so called “left” baby boomers sitting around complaining that their children didn’t get free university education, while taking the tax cuts, thinking it would be outrageous to pay capital gains on their houses and desperate to get everything they can out of super.
Plus in my view Working for Families is using tax redistribution to compensate for us having become a low wage country during the 90’s – tax “income earners” to enable company owners to make more profit – doesn’t deal with the underlying issue that many people’s wages are not enough to support a family.
Brilliant article I think, but (and I haven’t actually read Trotters criticisms to be fair so take this with a grain of salt) – I’d bet that his critique of TOP has far more to do with being captured by Identity Politics than him being a Boomer. He doesn’t strike me as someone who would give a toss about the privileges of being a Boomer. On the other hand, if your Ego and Identity are strongly tied up with being a Leftie (or a Rightie, Libertarian etc) of some particular stripe and something all new and scary (ie Sensible and Politically Unaligned) comes along… well, you might feel a bit threatened. You might be inclined to build a Strawman that looks a lot more like the familiar old enemies you’re used to facing off against and start hurling critiques at that instead…and quietly hope that no-one notices what you’re doing and, perhaps, how irrelevant… Well, I’ll just leave it there.
We need real alternative not another negative rant and rave about how bad the enemy is
Good post – but let’s see TOP get out there on the attack a bit more, you’re spending too much time under the radar.
[…] Simmons of TOP (the Opportunities Party) recently wrote a guest blog for TDB, in response to some rather harsh criticisms of TOP and its millionaire founder Gareth Morgan by […]
Comments are closed.