TV REVIEW: Wow – Best Q+A ever?

11
1

q_a_logo_2013_master

There are times when TVNZ and its true public broadcasting purpose shines so brightly you are reminded, ‘we should probably keep that as a public asset’.

Today’s Q+A was one of the best shows they’ve ever done.

Grant Duncan, Michelle Boag and First Union General Secretary Robert Reid were the panel, but the stories were absolutely brilliant.

Socio-economic critical analysis intelligently done in a manner that is not jargon ridden and locking out the audience???- I never thought I’d see it on TV.

The first story was the madness of our free market forestry industry that sees all our primary produce (logs) simply chopped down, shifted overseas, made into furniture and then imported back to us!

We only own 1% of our own forests? What madness is this? When we could be generating our own work force, we are simply rolling over for the cheapest cost capitalism model that drives wages lower and lower and lower while bastardising the craft.

The real kick in the teeth here is that when we sell the rights to our forests, overseas companies promise to build wood processing plants here for employment in NZ, and they don’t actually keep their part of the deal.

TDB Recommends NewzEngine.com

We are schmucks getting rolled by overseas forest companies. Hikurangi Forest Farms were supposed to provide a processing plant and they didn’t even bother doing that!

We need to re-nationalise our forests by those companies that have failed to live up to their contract. And the best place to get that money? The NZ Super fund!

Using the NZ Super fund as a means to fund our desperately needed economic and social upgrade is an idea the Left have championed, but has found no voice politically. The time for such timidness needs to end and Andrew Little and Grant Robertson should be sitting up and taking some notice.

Watching Michelle Boag panic over the obviousness of the free market failure in forestry is this best thing I’ve seen all year. Robert Reid wipes the floor with Michelle by consistently bringing the issue back to the failed neoliberal experiment that our economy has become.

Michelle keeps denigrating Robert by claiming Robert is living in the past, Robert counters, you need to learn from the past, especially when some refuse to learn.

She sat mumbling for a few minutes.

Michelle wasn’t expecting an actual debate on Q+A.

None of us were

But the cohesion of how they followed the issue was amazing.  Q+A highlighted what the problems are (privatising our forests), hey critiqued the structure in which has allowed this failure (it’s neoliberalism Michelle – neoliberalism), and it then moved to solutions with the head of the NZ Super fund.

Watching CEO Adrian Orr was a rare joy. A Public Servant in the truest sense, who has taken the obligation of NZs future and made ethical decisions that require rational compassion. The ability to fund and grow our own economy with such values holds hope and optimism like a huge burning Southern Cross in the sky.

At this stage, it’s difficult to see how this episode could get much better, but they really did leave the best till last with the wonderfully insightful Derek Handley.

Listening to his politics of compassion model, to use empathy and compassion in the values of decision making was the most refreshing politics I’ve seen on screen in 9 years. It was a positive millennial perspective that is rarely articulated in baby boomer gatekeeper media and if progressives are needing to look for a new core that can bring the divided houses of the Opposition together, then it is this Politics of Compassion.

Andre Little needs to watch this episode.

Helen Kelly’s final message to us was about kindness. A new type of political vision can be born here and Q+A managed to reflect this new momentum.

Excellent broadcasting.

11 COMMENTS

  1. Adrian Orr won’t divest NZSuper from Israeli killer corporations. In fact he quite nastily and smugly refused to consider it. So he’s not so shiny.

  2. Tvnz a public Asset? Look it up on the companies register. I found two 50% shareholders Julie Christie and ….don’t believe me, have a look for yourself. Naughty naughty Minister!

  3. Tvnz, a public Asset. Yeah right. Look it up on the companies register. The two 50% shareholders will surprise you. One is Julie Christie the other is also a minister of the crown. So look it it up yourself don’t listen to heresy.

      • Oops dunno where julie Christie came from brain fade? Bill English and Amy Adams are the natural persons listed as share holders, not Minister of finance bill English! Big difference.

      • Oops dunno where julie Christie came from brain fade? Bill English and Amy Adams are the natural persons listed as share holders, not Minister of finance bill English! Big difference.

    • Wonderfully clear brilliant piece of scriptured cover there Martyn.

      So easily absorbed across the white matter thanks.

      So I see that also the Chinese government have two years ago bought QUIETLY ALL OUR LARGEST WASTE COMPANY TRANSPAC TO!!!!

      F—-K!@#$$%^&*()_+_)(*&^%$#@!~ WHEN WILL ALL THIS SLASH & BURN STOP HERE FOR BLODDY HELLS SAKE.

      NOTHING IS LEFT FOR US NOW IT SEEMS.

  4. Yes, it was a somewhat interesting and good program on Q+A today, telling us a lot about what goes on in forestry, which I think is fair to presume, is also happening in some other industries.

    When we hear the government boasting about “manufacturing” data, I recommend looking up what Statistics NZ includes into the category of “manufacturing” activity. It appears to include peeling and cutting logs into larger pieces of timber logs, merely for raw low exports.

    Turning milk into milk powder is also “manufacturing”, by the way, so much is not at all technologically sophisticated activity, and has little value added to the rather raw, basic end product, going overseas.

    But re Q+A I am now careful to express praise, as I did after another program a long time ago. Soon after it was a rather poor program after another that followed, and next Sunday we may be back to the normal trivia and chat show, with little real info, insight and discussion of little substance.

    I note though, Jessica Mutch was absent this time, that may have “helped” pull this one through.

    • 100% Mike very true this is.

      This Government are true bull-shitters clearly and just use phoney statistics to rort the system and the MSM just sits in abeyance and lets them lie like creative accounting practices always does happen by unscrupulous Accountants.

    • New Zealands only hard hitting current affairs show !!! they brag.

      If thats it we are in serious trouble.

      The only” hard hitting” is reserved for the Left.

  5. This hopefully will be the first of many discussions on neoliberalism. Only issue is the Manderins in the highest levels of government that have been planted there to protect the establishment. They will need overthowing..

  6. I wish they would stop letting Boag out of her coffin.
    Its just the same tired old diatribe and deep inside she must realise that the neo lib approach is dying and we are not entitled to her opinion.

  7. I wish they would stop letting Boag out of her coffin.
    Its just the same tired old diatribe and deep inside she must realise that the neo lib approach is dying and we are not entitled to her opinion.

Comments are closed.