Why Tracey Watkins is wrong and why Labour will sell us out on mass surveillance

9
3

1184824_637422929614022_1705681326_n

 

Tracy Watkins thinks Metiria Turei can’t be on the Intelligence review committee because she has a loud belly laugh.

Welcome to the lowest point in NZ Political Journalism.

I don’t have time to count the ways Tracey is wrong, but I do want to focus on her most appalling claim…

Given that our intelligence agencies have gained an almost comic reputation over the years, most Kiwis probably struggle to picture our spies getting up to anything very sinister, the Dotcom debacle notwithstanding.

…this is Tracey’s worst crime in a column so pandering it makes Fox News look credible. The SIS and GCSB have both been caught acting illegally. The GCSB has been caught illegally spying on over 80 NZers and they went to the NSA and told them secretly that the legislation Key was telling NZers would prevent mass surveillance will actually allow it.

The SIS has been caught colluding with the PMs Office to smear the Leader of the Opposition with falsified information months before the 2011 election.

Both departments have been given vast new powers and budgets and can now spy on anyone for 24 hours without a warrant.

TDB Recommends NewzEngine.com

Adding the revelations Edward Snowden has made, the nonchalance that Watkins articulates is so spineless it gives an example of why the NZ electorate are such sleepy hobbits. If this is political opinion from the mainstream, it’s lap dog journalism as opposed to a watch dog journalism.

Watkins does however add some insight with her views on why Labour betrayed the Greens. Now Labour are chasing the middle, they need to over compensate on national security issues, and placing Shearer in there as opposed to Metiria means the Intelligence Agencies will be given a free ride rather than genuine oversight. Shearer tried to secretly cut a deal with Key on the GCSB legislation. While he was publicly turning up to meetings to denounce the law, he was also privately meeting with Key to try and find a way to vote for it.

Labour won’t protect us from these Intelligence Agencies, they will quietly sell us out so that they can convince the authority worshipping sleepy hobbits of muddle Nu Zilind that they are tough on National Security.

If this is how gutless Labour intend to be for American interests, there is little doubt they will roll over on the TPPA as well.

Claiming Metiria’s belly laugh somehow rules her out from providing oversight on an agency that has proven itself corrupt only proves the biased view of the mainstream media are part of the problem.

9 COMMENTS

  1. So Labour are part of the National Party game to spy on NZs and introduce the TPP,thats probably why David Cunliffe didn’t want support partners in the election ,he didn’t want to win ! David Shearer acted the part of gentleman and let Key get away with everything without a fight because shearer was going behind closed doors,Keys mate by the sound of it ,if this article is to be believed.
    Not sure about Little but wasn’t it said somewhere he was in favour of TPP.Who can we trust?
    What a state NZ is in !!!
    Everything Key is gossiped about is allowed to be a fizzer ,a few words of outrage by opposition mps then nothing ,no wonder Key is so arrogant,he knows there is no one to really challenge him.
    Follow the money is the answer maybe,all bought and paid for.

  2. I used to know a cell of radicals – they may have even been revolutionaries – it is a long time ago. Anyway, one day they concluded that the SIS was spying on them. They threw themselves to work as they endeavoured to identify the spies and then set themselves to SPY ON THE SPIES SPYING ON THEM. They became so obsessive that they clean forgot to do anything revolutionary.

    I suggest, without totally forgetting about the distortions in the security service, that everyone just gets on with fomenting revolution, or working on ideas and policies that might help the put-upon sections of the population, or whatever it is you would have liked to have done, had it not been for the SIS.

    We’ll deal with the Thought Police when they show up.

  3. Outside our pathetic politics and beyond the sight of our worthless MSM I think there’re two independent events effecting NZ right now .

    @ ELLE and @ NICK . I think you’re both correct .

    Event # 01
    Re @ ELLE . Behind the darkly comical farce that is Labour and National pretending to vey for supremacy to best serve their constituents there is money . Vast amounts of easy money . Farmer money .
    I’d suggest you listen to this woman . Dr. Vandana Shiva . You’ll find a pod cast here of an interview on National Radio . http://www.radionz.co.nz/national/programmes/nights/20150218 “ Towards Agroecology

    What she says is fascinating in itself . But if one were to use her interview as a clue as to how important NZ’s agricultural heritage was in terms of earning money , you can begin to see the wealth that was plundered .

    And most , if not all , the political energy being expended right now is to in effect cover that swindle over with an ever thinning veneer of logical fallacies and half truths . It’s to hide ancient fortunes held by the privileged few .

    Event # 2
    Re NICK. You are right in that we should ignore the spectre of covert , black ops types hiding in the broom closet . Even if they’re there then fuck them !
    The MSM discourse re their presence is nothing more than hollow threats . I have a fridge magnet depicting a generic picture of Jesus . He’s all holy and lit up like a Christmas tree . The caption reads ; “ He’s watching . So give Him a good show . “

    The one or two who use our media to push their agenda would shit bricks if it were discovered that all of us, every dissenter, were indeed being watched . That might be the spark for the fuse . Trust me . They aint gonna push us that far . It’s all bullshit .

    So , we have an old and on-going swindle that’s being busily swept under the thinning carpet AND we have Super Rich foreign owners of vast corporates wanting to own NZ because they know that things for Earth and its inhabitants are going to get a fuck sight worse before they get a fuck sight better .

    I believe those two scenarios are connected . I believe that because the historic and on-going Farmer Money Swindle has meant that our political crooks have had to borrow money to hide that aforementioned swindle, they’ve had to compromise us all to foreign money lenders who are now in control of our economy .

    I believe that everything that’s wrong with our beautiful New Zealand / Aotearoa stems from that .

    How’s that for an idea !

    Re Tracy Watkins ? She’s just a windbag bimbo with a six figure sallary eyeing up a pair of designed shoes . Is that not right Girlfriend ?

  4. “the biased view of the mainstream media are part of the problem.” They are more than just one piece of the puzzle, they are the keystone….If NZ had a fourth estate worth more than a bowl of dried goat faeces, then little Johnny Numnums wouldn’t have got within a hundred miles of being PM…And that’s just for starters… Can one even imagine what this country would be like if the truth was the yardstick for public dissemination?

    I, for one believe it would still be a place to be proud of, and worth living in for NZers…

  5. I wonder what Andrea Vance thinks of her colleague, Tracey Watkins’ rather naive views on state surveillance and mis-use of government powers??

    Maybe it’ll take the PM’s Dept to spy on Watkins before she wakes up from, her warm-fuzzies cocooned world she lives in.

  6. Shearer was a plant from the right, we should have rejected him after Goff, as he has no balls, or would shun spying on us all either as he never complained at all when SIS was in the mincer over Ede/Key debarkle.

    Andrew Little may be o/k and worth trying to build upon, so we hope he gives the TPPA hell when he can.

    The US is in deep shit financially as the second worst indebted country in the world behind China and third is Greece compared to GDP.
    It’s hard to think about China as a country with a debt problem, but that’s precisely what it is.

    China’s ratio of total debt to GDP is 282%, according to the McKinsey Global Institute. That includes borrowing by the government, banks, corporations, and households.

    By comparison, the United States’ ratio of total debt to GDP is 269%. Greece’s was 260% at the time of its crisis.

    If we hitch up to this lot US/China then we are certainly going to be coerced into more indebtedness as these others are already.

    Perhaps this is the master plan for these other leaches to stuck our assets and wealth just to keep them alive?

    Tracy Watkins needs some coaching by Winston who knows the ropes better than most.

  7. $200 million sucked out of the economy by loan via Goldman Sachs,USA corporation.

    Mr Key says Polls show NZs are in majority in favour of sending NZ troops to fight Isis a US led war ,what polls? ??? Westfield malls threatened by Isis, False Flag maybe,to back up push for sending NZ troops.

    TPP a deal favouring US Corporations.
    JK in favour.

    NZ spy agencies ,US inspired and part of 5 Eyes spy network set up by US .

    So many Us inspired and involved incidents to take from NZ , others posting here can add to the growing instances of US sucking the lifeblood out of NZ. Its so blatent now.

  8. Oversight of the NZ security apparatus is more important than ever at this time. You may not have noticed (If you watch mainstream media) there are three huge geopolitical events occurring. The Bric Nations are establishing alternative monetary systems to the US dollar and the USA is going all out to prevent this even risking nuclear war with Russia. We are nearing the end of cheap energy. This is despite the recent drop in the price of oil. The whole ISIS libya Syria Iraq debacle has its ultimate cause in this and once again it is USA creating chaos in an effort to maintain its “right” to cheap energy. Thirdly the drive to globalisation being carried out in secret and proven to reduce jobs, reduce the income of the middle class and enrich the 1%. To allow our security services to blindly follow the immoral path Washington has chosen in this situation is not good for NZ. NZ needs independent security overseen by loyal New Zealanders not people whose allegiance is to Corporate America or anyone else. The week kneed exclusion of Metiria Turei by National and Labour shows were their allegiance lies.

  9. John Key wants us to go to war and I have some questions;

    1. Why isn’t Israel & Saudi Arabia undertaking direct action against ISIS? These countries have massive military forces, border the theatre of ops, Israel has nukes etc funded and supported by US/UK but you don’t see or hear of any Israeli or Saudi moves to join in the coalition fight and commit their forces against ISIS? Do they know ISIS not going to attack them? Why is that?

    2. Why is Key so keen to get us into a war without following proper democratic protocols e.g. get Parliament vote on it?

    3. Why is there evidence pointing to the fact that ISIS is funded via the US?
    http://www.veteranstoday.com/2015/01/29/kerry-told-isis-funded-from-us/

    4. Why has Fidel Castro made public statements to the effect that Senator McCain and Israel are backing ISIS?
    http://www.veteranstoday.com/2015/02/05/rt-castro-says-mccain-israel-behind-isis/

    5. Given the extensive reach of the 5 eyes why does ISIS have free reign over social meda? Would be easy to shut them down I would think. But the intel world are allowing it, why is that? Are those decapitation videos in front of a green screen?

    Are we being told half truths, lies and propaganda?

    This war is corrupt, it stinks and we should stay the f@#k out it big time.

Comments are closed.